Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

news.ycombinator.com

91–100 of 118 posts

Re: Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

#91

Nice product overall. Not sure anybody pointed out this yet, but you should consider changing spaces for dashes on your slugs, they look better than the coded space (%20) on pages like: https://itslaunched.com/profile/Kazane%20Shimizu

Thank you for pointing this out. Will be fixed as soon as possible.

Re: Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

#92

It is good to create direct, fair and healthy competition for the Product Hunt (I am all for diversity). Competition is always good for business. As far as successful launching on Product Hunt and getting feature isn't just for everyone. You have to do marketing, building hype around your product, moderate product idea (it's a minimum to get featured), good copywriting and whatnot. I'm also going to sign up because o…

Thank you for the kind words and support! You're absolutely right. Launching successfully anywhere requires a mix of everything. My goal with this platform is to level the playing field a bit more for indie makers and small teams who might not have the resources for a big marketing push.

Also excited to have you on board, and I hope the features make your experience worthwhile. Would love to hear your thoughts once you’ve explored the platform.

Re: Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

#93

Love it. Are you thinking about monetizing it?

Thank you! Right now, the focus is entirely on building a fair and vibrant community around the platform. Monetization isn’t a priority at this stage. That said, if the platform grows and requires funding to sustain, I would explore options.

Re: Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

#94

Great ! PH has become "too big" and full of spam, it needs alternative :) Bug report : When you post a comment, if you refresh the page it's sending it again and you have duplicates

Thank you for the kind words and for reporting the bug. I agree that providing a simpler, cleaner alternative is essential, and I'm working hard to make it just that. Regarding the bug, I'm already looking into fixing it to ensure it doesn't happen again.

Re: Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

#95
post #73

Awesome, congratulations! A few notes: - Sign up with Twitter? Please consider sign up with Apple, Github and maybe Google. - You should def hide votes until someone has voted or used all their votes for the day to reduce bias.

Thanks so much for the congratulations. Coming up some more sign in methods, I just had setup Twitter as it was the easiest to setup at that time.

About your suggestion, hiding votes until users cast their own is a really smart way. I will look at the possibility of implementing something like that.

Re: Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

#98
post #67

If you care fairness, I have 1 extra suggestion that you might be interested in. It was proven by several data-science research that when users have to votes (or give ratings) and if they are able to see the previous result, then the first few votes have an extremely important effect. For instance here is one stury, very well written article by a famous teacher Robert West, "of sheep and beer" https://dlab.epfl.ch/20…

This is not a study but a reality for me. At one point on HN I wanted to farm for karma points. That period lasted for a few weeks, I wasn't too intense about it, just a fun question I had. My tactic? Find something that has something like 15 upvotes and you suspect to be rising quick in upvotes. Create the first comment and your best to make an as thoughtful comment as possible, even if you don't know anything about…

I feel like that was gaming the system in the spirit of https://xkcd.com/810/

Re: Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

#99

I really wish Ryan Hoover would take back the integrity of Product Hunt. It's such an amazing product with such currently painful execution, assumingly in the name of site traffic traded for ad dollars. I truly think that the conversion rate for advertisers on PH would go UP if the quality of the site (moderated posts, comments, bot traffic) did the same.

I'm consistently baffled by the rarity of a product owner improving their bottom line by simply improving their users' experience.

I think the calculation is made on the sum of user experience.

Any activity can be made worse if they find a way to increase users by other means.

Re: Show HN: I built a fair alternative to Product Hunt for indie makers

#100

Surely this trades being in the spotlight for a few minutes now for being in the spotlight in a year's time when it's your turn in the 10-products-per-day queue?

That's a fair concern! However, the idea is to create a balanced system where every product gets its moment to shine without being overshadowed by dozens of others launching on the same day. The first-come, first-serve queue ensures fairness, and since launches can be scheduled up to 30 days ahead, creators can plan their timing strategically. The goal is quality exposure over a rushed spotlight.

Makes sense! I guess you can see how it goes and adjust. I hope it goes well.
Post reply on HN