Live data from Hacker News

Ads chew through half of mobile data

nextpit.com

11–20 of 256 posts

Re: Ads chew through half of mobile data

#11

Aren’t browser-extension ad blockers (uBlock Origin, AdBlock, etc.) not helpful for solving this problem? As far as I’m aware, by the time the ad can be blocked by such programs, you have already consumed the data. Wouldn’t a better solution be DNS sinkholing, like PiHole or AdGuard Home?

Ad blockers intercept the request and cancel it before it's actually made. It's wise to use both methods.

Re: Ads chew through half of mobile data

#13
Ads? Which ads? None on my devices at least. Block the filth already, there is no reason to subject yourself or your family to it. Get a device which is under your own control - nothing made by Apple, get an Android device on which you install something like LineageOS or GrapheneOS or another similar AOSP-derived distribution, do not use unmodified stock Android distributions - and install several layers of content blocking. Use a VPN with an endpoint at your own router on which you have more content blocking, that way you can safely use public WiFi hotspots. I never see advertising and would not accept anything else.

Re: Ads chew through half of mobile data

#14

I question the methodology of this: Enders used a browser that mimicked an iPhone 6 and accessed a total of eight "popular" news sites (though they didn't confirm what these were)." 'iPhone 6', an phone that's 10 years old. A sample size of 8 and undisclosed.

Article is 8 years old, so a 10 year old phone makes sense

Re: Ads chew through half of mobile data

#16
post #5

Well, nextpit.com, you're really no better than the rest of them. This could have been a few kilobytes of static html...

This is desktop, not mobile, but: I turned off ad blockers, scrolled to the bottom, and waited. 60.9MB transferred https://imgur.com/a/ftGkR3m . They are in fact worse than the rest of them. It is still going up as the ads rotate. I count 11 ad placements.

> 60.9MB transferred

Opening this page 6 and a half times would exceed the monthly download limit on the first broadband internet plan my family had about twenty years ago in Australia.

Re: Ads chew through half of mobile data

#20

Ads? Which ads? None on my devices at least. Block the filth already, there is no reason to subject yourself or your family to it. Get a device which is under your own control - nothing made by Apple, get an Android device on which you install something like LineageOS or GrapheneOS or another similar AOSP-derived distribution, do not use unmodified stock Android distributions - and install several layers of content b…

Even an i-device can use adguard plus and get rid of most of the ads.
Post reply on HN