Live data from Hacker News

The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

news.sky.com

21–30 of 68 posts

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#21

this seems mostly about VW, a company that is both a huge presence in the EU economy and probably irrevocably f---ed VW is slowly vanishing from US markets (EV or ICE) and tried to enter the Chinese market only to get the crap kicked out of it I'd mention Stellantis which is also mostly an EU company now, but they are so screwed at this point it isn't even sporting

Their EVs are fine (except for software), but why they are so expensive?

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#23
post #8
post #2

> The skills built up by European carmakers over decades are simply not directly transferrable. Germany does have a giant, excellent chemistry industry. > China's interest in batteries is not a recent trend. It has been investing in their production for many, many years. It has been attempting to dominate not just the production of cells but also of the cathodes and anodes that go inside them - not to mention the che…

> Consistent, long term industrial policy is very effective. Yes. This is what kills the US in rare earths, cobalt, gallium, etc. US mines shut down when the price goes down. Sometimes they restart when the price goes up. Sometimes they don't. All this churn makes the business unprofitable in the US.[1] [1] https://mpmaterials.com/articles/mp-materials-reports-third-...

You're ignoring the fact that we also don't want oceans of toxic sludge left after the mining. This is not the case in China.

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#24
post #2

> The skills built up by European carmakers over decades are simply not directly transferrable. Germany does have a giant, excellent chemistry industry. > China's interest in batteries is not a recent trend. It has been investing in their production for many, many years. It has been attempting to dominate not just the production of cells but also of the cathodes and anodes that go inside them - not to mention the che…

China is of no concern to Europe or the US. Most of their tech is stolen or trickles down from innovation elsewhere. It is unlikely China will find success in the US given the sentiment (antiChinese sentiment is rampant in most of the US). Also, there are many legislations in place that would prevent it. I will mention though that the US and Europe need to get their act together. Too slow on EVs (it took an outsider like Tesla to get it going), and there is still too much reluctance to get the ball rolling. I view the best solution as "forcing" the oil giants to innovate in this sector, but given their lobbying prowess, it is highly unlikely. In a highly democratic society, Shell in Europe and Exxon here would be paying their dues in electric infrastructure and battery tech

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#25

How long until the next shock hits, building cars without a steering wheel, but with a sensor suite and self-driving software?

Not soon, this would requires sophistication in software and software development. US has the crown on this for now and near future at least.

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#26
post #2

> The skills built up by European carmakers over decades are simply not directly transferrable. Germany does have a giant, excellent chemistry industry. > China's interest in batteries is not a recent trend. It has been investing in their production for many, many years. It has been attempting to dominate not just the production of cells but also of the cathodes and anodes that go inside them - not to mention the che…

Angela Merkel's legacy has not been good..

https://archive.md/N3RWo

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#27

this seems mostly about VW, a company that is both a huge presence in the EU economy and probably irrevocably f---ed VW is slowly vanishing from US markets (EV or ICE) and tried to enter the Chinese market only to get the crap kicked out of it I'd mention Stellantis which is also mostly an EU company now, but they are so screwed at this point it isn't even sporting

> tried to enter the Chinese market only to get the crap kicked out of it That's a massive rewriting of history. VW was one of the earliest foreign automotive manufacturers to enter the Chinese market. In the 1990s and 2000s, the Volkswagen Jetta was China's Model T. And until 2023, VW was the top selling car brand in China. And that was the crux of the issue - VW grew complacent by leveraging "Made in Germany" brand…

Did people in the US really stop buying VWs because of the diesel emissisions stuff? Almost nobody in the US buys diesel passenger cars anyway. I could not care less about a cheat on roughly zero percent of cars sold. Diesel emissions could be totally unregulated and it would not make any difference -- nobody buys them anyway.

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#28
post #2

> The skills built up by European carmakers over decades are simply not directly transferrable. Germany does have a giant, excellent chemistry industry. > China's interest in batteries is not a recent trend. It has been investing in their production for many, many years. It has been attempting to dominate not just the production of cells but also of the cathodes and anodes that go inside them - not to mention the che…

China is of no concern to Europe or the US. Most of their tech is stolen or trickles down from innovation elsewhere. It is unlikely China will find success in the US given the sentiment (antiChinese sentiment is rampant in most of the US). Also, there are many legislations in place that would prevent it. I will mention though that the US and Europe need to get their act together. Too slow on EVs (it took an outsider…

> Most of their tech is stolen or trickles down from innovation elsewhere.

This is how it always works, until it doesn't. Why is everyone so quick to forget that Japan was the exact same way in the 70s and 80s?

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#29
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The world knows how to make good cars now. Companies can forget how. Stellantis (which owns Chrysler, Jeep, Dodge, Fiat, and some other forgettable car brands) forgot how. The CEO was fired on December 1st, 2024. His strategy had been to crank prices way up, add on post-sale service charges, and get the biggest bonus in automotive executive pay history (not counting Musk's current litigated bonus.) Sales went down.…

Forgettable as Citroen and Peugeot, for example?

I think GP means forgettable in the US. Here is the brands from the Wikipedia article:

  - Abarth
  - Alfa Romeo
  - Chrysler
  - Citroën
  - Dodge
  - DS Automobiles
  - Fiat
  - Jeep
  - Lancia
  - Maserati
  - Opel
  - Peugeot
  - Ram Trucks
  - Vauxhall
None of them I would call "forgettable". Most of these brands have been there for more than a century. The only ones more recent than that are Abarth, DS and Ram. DS and Ram refer to iconic vehicles by Citroën and Dodge respectively and lately turned into their own brands.

Re: The electric shock behind Europe's stuttering EV future

#30
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes but the level of investment the Chinese have poured into battery production and EVs in general is also completely unparalleled. Industrial policy is nothing new for US and EU but just not at that level. To be able to compete with China the West would need to: - Match generous subsidies to companies, not just through banks but at the government level by building entire towns just for battery production. - Making l…

Western nations have absolutely done this in the past. It’s the reason we are generally the richest and most secure nations in the world. The decision not to do this potentially means we forfeit those advantages for the rest of this century. And China is hugely deploying renewables, which they happen to be able to produce very cheaply due to their industrial policy. The difference is that China is using their fossil…

> while the west is using its fossil fuel resources to shove crayons up its nose

what a bunch of empty invective

Post reply on HN