Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: 2048 turned 10 this year, I built an updated version to celebrate

play2048.co

51–60 of 233 posts

Re: Show HN: 2048 turned 10 this year, I built an updated version to celebrate

#52

Just downloaded the new classic version with ads and wanted to pass along a suggestion that Thor makes. While I understand that you’ve gotta make a living, ads are far more palatable if the user can consent to them. And the way to make the user a part of the process is to offer a trade for the ad, rather than obtrusively running them. “Would you like 500 gold to watch an ad?” Yes? Ad for in-game currency that provide…

This is interesting feedback. I always thought that ads being unobtrusive and not part of gameplay would be the saner choice. In my mind, when games ask you to trade watching an add for some kind of in-game benefit or currency, that feels like an unreasonable demand. The ads impinge on the gameplay. The way I've set up the site, ads are tucked in their own corner and should never affect gameplay (though there have been instances of ads spilling over the powerup bar, I'm working on that). Thanks for sharing!

Re: Show HN: 2048 turned 10 this year, I built an updated version to celebrate

#53

There are a lot of comments mentioning Threes! and holding it up as superior. I play a lot of games, and I greatly prefer Threes myself -- but I also remember very well when 2048 came out; I was in college, and 75% or more of my dorm had no interest in Threes and preferred playing and remixing 2048. Threes is very stressful and intense, while 2048 goes straight for your brain's pleasure centers, like many other mobil…

Totally agree. I prefer Threes! myself but ultimately, the market determines what's fun. Grabriele has been so humble about his success and while I feel for the Threes! developers, they came across as exceptionally sore.

Re: Show HN: 2048 turned 10 this year, I built an updated version to celebrate

#54
I'm disappointed in HN for stomping this person for the game that they made. They had no idea Threes existed, made this game as an experiment, and it went viral. Despite this, they still acknowledge Threes on their site.

But they post here and are dogpiled on by people saying they ripped off another game and should feel like a scumbag. That's wrong, let's be kind to each other instead of exhibiting rude behavior that discourages people from pursuing their projects because "it's a ripoff of xyz". This started as an experiment, and is now this person's full time career. Can we instead encourage others to follow?

We're not talking about a 1:1 ripoff, we're talking about a game whose gameplay is adjacent to another game. Is Call of Duty a rip-off of Medal of Honor because they're both WWII FPS games?

Re: Show HN: 2048 turned 10 this year, I built an updated version to celebrate

#56
TypeScript was fairly new at that time and to learn it, I ported 2048 to TypeScript. It was fun!

Fast forward a couple of years, I was debugging an issue with a react component and glanced over the .d.ts of react. I was quite surprised when I saw that my name was in them. I never contributed to react's types myself.

It turned out that someone took some types I wrote for 2048 and used them in the very first type definitions for react: https://github.com/DefinitelyTyped/DefinitelyTyped/commit/4b...

It's still there to this date, but I've lost my TS port in the sands of time.

Re: Show HN: 2048 turned 10 this year, I built an updated version to celebrate

#58
You know how the distribution of 2-value vs 4-value for new tiles is a weighted random function? And sometimes you get an unlikely 4 that really screw you over? Have you thought about adding a mode which always creates the worst option of the 2?

You could call it “God does play dice with the universe. They're loaded and he hates you.”

Re: Show HN: 2048 turned 10 this year, I built an updated version to celebrate

#60
post #48
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Let it go, Matt.

[flagged]

It seems like you are piling on just to pile on, not simply "pointing out the origin". There's already 52 matches for "Threes" on this submission. I think we get it. The author of has added credits to Threes. You won!
Post reply on HN