Live data from Hacker News

#BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

plus.google.com

311–320 of 374 posts

Re: #BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

#311

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple Legal is at odds with Apple Engineering, trying to litigate away the competition instead of innovating past them I don't even... what do you expect Apple Legal to innovate? "Accept EULA to unlock?" They aren't at odds with engineering any more than having a good defense is at odds with having a good offense. Have you used an up-to-date android phone in the last 6 months? Perhaps even gotten to play with an Nexu…

> I don't even... what do you expect Apple Legal to innovate? Apple Engineering creates great products. Apple Legal pays private security firms and complicit local officials to storm journalist's houses. Apple Engineering is trying to create a reputation as a great place to work, Apple Legal is scaring away engineers left and right. Apple Legal plays dirty, Apple Engineering and Design talk about the nobility of grea…

why is this being down voted ? it is a fairly good response in my eyes.

Re: #BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

#312
post #225

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The fact that a country as a whole is relatively non corrupt doesn't say anything about specific people and their corruptibility. Also, the U.S.A. is number 24 of around 180 countries on the Corruption Perceptions Index and appears below countries such as Bahamas, Chile or Qatar.

I'd be more than a little skeptical of an index which places the U.S. below Qatar and Chile.

[deleted]

Re: #BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

#313

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't know if Panic had any patents regarding this. The patent system doesn't really benefit the small developer. I was listening to Build & Analyze and Marco Arment was asked if he would patent features of Instapaper and he essentially said that it is more pain than it's worth. They don't have time time and money required to enforce it.

That is a horrible idea now that patents in the US are first to file rather than first to invent. You leave yourself open to somebody else patenting it, then coming back and suing you. Sure, you might be able to get that patent thrown out, but there is no guarantee and you are dumping a ton of money on lawyers in the process. Like it or not, patent trolling is just getting warmed up.

First-to-file doesn't nullify the idea of prior art. If your invention is published before first filing, it still counts as prior art for invalidating patents.

Re: #BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

#315

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On a small scale, petitions will work better than a hash tag on a Google-owned website. The person that made the decision is the judge. So a rational way to protest is to protest the decision itself. On a large scale, make something disruptively innovative to fight back. #BoycottApple may work by alarming and reminding Apple of their unethical act (to the crowd). But the effect is small because it has nothing to do w…

Remember Amazon and one-click? There was sufficient backlash that they never tried anything like that again. Could work with Apple.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1-Click#Patent says the revised patent was confirmed and they've been paid for licenses to use it (by Apple and possibly B&N). I don't see any effect the backlash had.

Re: #BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

#316

Earlier quoted context omitted.

True, but developers are more likely to care, and they matter a lot more than the average user. A lot of developers preferred not to use Microsoft products when MS was the evil empire, and there would probably be an MS monopoly now if they hadn't.

Developers matter a lot. Developers know which users and platforms pay out the best (iOS) and this is what guides their efforts. Not patent infringement, injunctions or boycotts.

If it was just about which platforms pay out the best, there wouldn't be much software for Linux, and there wouldn't have been much for Apple during their inter-Jobs nadir.

Re: #BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

#317
post #84

Why is such a trend on Google+ relevant? As much as I would like to embrace Google+ as a Facebook alternative, Google+ has still a very limited audience – and, of course, a very Android-focus audience … EDIT: Downvoting my comment just because it isn't enthusiastic on Google+? Comm'on!

It is appealing to see a down-voting complaint for an unpopular opinion related to a comment which dismisses a trend on Google+ being irrelevant because the network is relatively unpopular. I doubt the 75 million people who use Google+ consider themselves a "very limited audience." Regardless, not a reason for down-voting.

I would have thought using a false claim to denigrate something would be a reason for down-voting.

Re: #BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

#318
post #248

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd be a little skeptical of an index which shows Japan as being relatively less corrupt than the US. If one were to read up on Japan, it's clear that for a first world country, it's rather corrupt --not the same way, say Indis is corrupt, but still, I feel more so than the US, specifically. Dogs and Demons (A. Kerr) is filled with instances how corruption has contributed to massive misallocation of resources, coveru…

Do you have an opinion on the measures used to create the index? Are they leaving something significant out? Or is the data gathering process flawed perhaps? I'd hardly say Japan is not corrupt--obviously, it is--but saying it must be more corrupt than the US isn't exactly a justified statement when all you're working off is a feeling.

No I don't. I don't know enough. And you are right. It's only a feeling --but one based on my experiences compared with other people's experiences.

I think the big knock on the US, deservedly, is the undue influence of PACs on our politics. That said, in Japan, PACs are less necessary because of the business gov't relationship (i.e Japan Inc.)

Re: #BoycottApple trending on Google plus due to Galaxy Nexus ban

#319

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nope ;-) Problem with Apple is that if all players will play using Apple strategy we will not have any innovation at all. Motorola, Nokia, Samsung invested billions in mobile technology without knowing if this will even work, they risked and created cell phones and so on. They had big invest, big risk and at the end big win. Apple didn't take any risk, they simply polished existing products and started to sell it wit…

> Apple didn't take any risk, they simply polished existing products and started to sell it with much higher price tag. This comment invalidates everything else you wrote. Apple's investment in R&D for mobile handheld usability and devices predates even the existence of some of these litigants, and predates the "smartphones" by them.

> This comment invalidates everything else you wrote.

It doesn't, and it shouldn't.

Post reply on HN