Live data from Hacker News

Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

developers.googleblog.com

111–120 of 151 posts

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#111
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for the link. That's unfortunate, though perhaps the benchmarks will be updated after this latest Gemini release. Cursor with Sonnet is great, I'll have to give Aider a try as well.

It is updated actually, gemini-1.5-pro-002 is this new model.

That was fast, I missed it!

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#112
post #13

This price drop is significant. For For comparison, GPT-4o is currently $5/million input and $15/million output and Claude 3.5 Sonnet is $3/million input and $15/million output. Gemini 1.5 Pro was already the cheapest of the frontier models and now it's even cheaper.

whats confusing they have different pricing for output. Here [1] it's $5/million output (starting 1st october) and on vertex AI [2] it's $2.5/1 million (starting 7 october) - but characters - so it's overall gonna be more expensive if you wanna compare to equivalent 1 million tokens. It's actually even more confusing to know what kind of characters they mean? 1 byte? UTF-8?

[1] https://ai.google.dev/pricing

[2] https://cloud.google.com/vertex-ai/generative-ai/pricing

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#113
post #94

Has anyone used Gemini Code Assist? I'm curious how it compares with Github Copilot and Cursor.

I have used Github Copilot extensively within VS Code for several months. The autocomplete - fast and often surprisingly accurate - is very useful. My only complaint is when writing comments, I find the completions distracting to my thought process. I tried Gemini Code Assist and it was so bad by comparison that I turned it off within literally minutes. Too slow and inaccurate. I also tried Codestral via the Continue…

I see, perhaps with Gemini because the model is larger it takes longer to generate the completions. I would expect with a larger model it would perform better on larger codebases. It sounds like for you, it's faster to work on a smaller model with shorter more accurate completions rather than letting the model guess what you're trying to write.

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#114

Has anyone used Gemini Code Assist? I'm curious how it compares with Github Copilot and Cursor.

I tried it briefly and didn't like it. On the other hand, I found Gemini pro better than sonnet or 4o at some more complex coding tasks (using continue.dev)

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#115

Its just not as smart as ChatGPT or LLAMA, its mind boggling Google fell so far behind.

Has it changed much since March when this was written? Gemini won, 6-4. And it matches my experiences of just using Gemini instead of ChatGPT because it gives me more useful responses, when I feel like I want an AI answer. https://www.tomsguide.com/ai/google-gemini-vs-openai-chatgpt

"For this initial test I’ll be comparing the free version of ChatGPT to the free version of Google Gemini, that is GPT-3.5 to Gemini Pro 1.0."

The free version of ChatGPT is 4o now, isn't it? So maybe Gemini has not gotten worse, but the free alternatives are now better? When I compare ChatGPT-4o with Gemini-Advanced (wich is 1.5 Pro, I believe) the latter is just so much worse.

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#116
post #112
post #13

This price drop is significant. For For comparison, GPT-4o is currently $5/million input and $15/million output and Claude 3.5 Sonnet is $3/million input and $15/million output. Gemini 1.5 Pro was already the cheapest of the frontier models and now it's even cheaper.

whats confusing they have different pricing for output. Here [1] it's $5/million output (starting 1st october) and on vertex AI [2] it's $2.5/1 million (starting 7 october) - but characters - so it's overall gonna be more expensive if you wanna compare to equivalent 1 million tokens. It's actually even more confusing to know what kind of characters they mean? 1 byte? UTF-8? [1] https://ai.google.dev/pricing [2] https…

They do mention how characters are counted in the Vertex AI pricing docs: "Characters are counted by UTF-8 code points and white space is excluded from the count"

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#117
post #92
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Moat could be things like direct integration into Gmail (ask it to find your last 5 receipts from Amazon), Drive (chat with PDF), Slides (create images / flow charts), etc. Not sure if their models are the moat. But they definitely have an opportunity from the productization perspective. But so does Microsoft.

Have you tried the Gemini Gmail integration? I have that enabled in my GSuite account. It's incredible how bad it is. I've seen it claim I've never received mail from a certain person, while the email was open right next to the chat widget. I've seen it tell me to use the standard search tool, when that wasn't suitable for the query. I've literally never had it find anything that wouldn't have been easier to find wit…

> I'm genuinely confused why they released it like that.

I agree. Right now it's not very useful, but has the potential to be if they keep investing in it. Maybe.

I think Google, Microsoft, etc are all pressured to release something for fear of appearing to be behind the curve.

Apple is clearly taking the opposite approach re: speed to market.

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#118
post #13

This price drop is significant. For For comparison, GPT-4o is currently $5/million input and $15/million output and Claude 3.5 Sonnet is $3/million input and $15/million output. Gemini 1.5 Pro was already the cheapest of the frontier models and now it's even cheaper.

> For comparison, GPT-4o is currently $5/million input and $15/million output and Claude 3.5 Sonnet is $3/million input and $15/million output.

Google is the only one of the three that has its own data centers and custom inference hardware (TPU).

Re: Two new Gemini models, reduced 1.5 Pro pricing, increased rate limits, and more

#119

Looks like they are more focused on the economical aspect of those large models? Like 90~95% performance of other frontier models at 50%~70% price.

They are going for large corporate customers. They are a brand name with deep pockets and a pretty risk-adverse model. So even if Gemini sucks, they'll still win over execs being pushed to make a decision.

Not even trying to be snarky, but their lack of ability to offer products for more than a handful of years, does not lend google towards being chosen by large corporate customers. I know a guy who works in cloud sales and his government customers are PISSED they are sunsetting one of their PDF products and are being forced to migrate that process. The customer was expecting that to work for 10+ years and after a ~3 year onboarding process, they have 6 months to migrate. If my neck was on the line after buying the google PDF product, I wouldn't even short list them for an AI product.
Post reply on HN