Live data from Hacker News

UVA Computer Science professor resigns over incompetence of board

gist.github.com

131–133 of 133 posts

Re: UVA Computer Science professor resigns over incompetence of board

#131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is a University's job to educate students, and to expose them to many fields of study that will give them a grounding for later study and inquiry. Basic instruction in many different topics at least gives the students enough grounding to ask good questions. Education in foreign languages has far reaching affects on many aspects of life and cognitive abilities - this is a documented fact. The analogy to Exchange is…

There is teaching and training. If they have a German lit prof who has published nothing for years, has no research students, no enrollment and the justification for keeping them is "learning German is useful" - then it makes sense to close the dept, buy some language tapes for the library and pay some German grad students to help. Rather than fire 10% of the post-docs in semi-conductor physics because you are making…

You can't ask questions of tapes, nor can you ask for extra help from said tapes the same way you can with an actual teacher. A tape base program can't tell you when you are mispronouncing, nor can it detect the areas you are confused in. There are benefits from having someone knowledgable around to teach.

Re: UVA Computer Science professor resigns over incompetence of board

#133

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Indeed. I may have to look her up. The most interesting things I've seen written about debt in the past 20 years comes from an anthropologist, David Graeber. Debt, the first 5000 years . Insights I've never seen from an economist. I'm curious as to what a sociologist has come up with.

What I've seen of Graeber's stuff is interesting. Economics is too important to be left to the economists. But I've always regarded sociology as undisciplined and people studying it unrigorous. I haven't missed much by those rules of thumb. A number of Sullivan's books were written with one Elizabeth Warren. When other academics tried to examine their data they came up short. Look her up if you like, but you're more…

I share some of your sentiments for the softer social sciences. I've also grown increasingly skeptical of significant portions of economics as well. Another author I've recently learned of, still need to start chewing into his work, is Jonathan Nitzan, whose Capital as Power is predicated on the notion that splitting Economics and Political Science apart was a mistake. I'd been leaning that way myself.

Lawrence Lessig's Free Culture notes that much recent copyright wrangling is really a return to feudalism. I've been suspecting that it's rather more than just copyright.

Post reply on HN