Live data from Hacker News

Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

autoweek.com

31–40 of 401 posts

Re: Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

#31

While it can be overridden, hopefully this saves many lives. We limit speeds on scooters and e bikes so cars are only fair

It won't stop reckless driving on roads where the legal limit is way above the practical limit.

Although I have absolutely zero stats to backup my argument, I'd say deaths on twisty country roads where the vehicle was under the legal speed limit far exceeds those on straight motorways breaking the limit.

Re: Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

#32
post #18

This is terrifying. I routinely cross a bridge with a 30ton weight limit, which my car mistakes for a 30km/h speed limit sign. I would cause an average of 2 accidents per month if I suddenly slowed from 70 to 30 and the people behind me weren't paying attention. The technology is _not_ there and this won't save lives, potentially it will cause deaths. (Yes I read the article, this is initially only "for the driver's…

This uses GPS data, not optical recognition

You can also turn it off every time you start your vehicle.

Re: Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

#34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm almost certain that the Autobahn is inside the EU and it's famous for the very thing this law supposedly limits.

And on the derestricted section of the autobahn it will do nothing, given that there is no speed limit.

Until gps fails and it starts repeatedly braking because it thinks it is somewhere else

Re: Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

#35
post #23

Hopefully the EU's right to repair allows consumers to fix their cars by removing this malware.

If you have relatives who got killed by a speeder you may think differently.

Given that the tech doesn't actually work reliably I'd remove it even without any intention to speed.

It's the same reason why I keep lane keeping assistance off in my car - not because I disagree with the idea, but because the implementation is so bad it's actively dangerous.

Re: Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

#36
post #18

This is terrifying. I routinely cross a bridge with a 30ton weight limit, which my car mistakes for a 30km/h speed limit sign. I would cause an average of 2 accidents per month if I suddenly slowed from 70 to 30 and the people behind me weren't paying attention. The technology is _not_ there and this won't save lives, potentially it will cause deaths. (Yes I read the article, this is initially only "for the driver's…

Yea, yea, people are going to get into accidents and maybe die, but think about all the shareholder value that will be created by companies as they try to make these systems barely work and sell them to car manufacturers who are mandated to buy them! Won't someone please think of the shareholder value for a change?

EDIT: Jeez, nobody gets sarcasm unless you end your post with /s

Re: Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

#37
post #17

Bit funny how the article states that the systems are unobtrusive as to be essentially useless, which ignores the fact that these systems are defanged to appease entitled speeders. Governments around the world impose various requirements on vehicle speeds, most notably ebikes being capped at 20mph for "safety reasons". Meanwhile private cars can travel at over 100mph for no apparent reason other than to not upset dri…

Ebikes go where bikes go, that's why. They can mingle with pedestrians. They don't require a licence to operate.

Re: Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

#38
post #18

This is terrifying. I routinely cross a bridge with a 30ton weight limit, which my car mistakes for a 30km/h speed limit sign. I would cause an average of 2 accidents per month if I suddenly slowed from 70 to 30 and the people behind me weren't paying attention. The technology is _not_ there and this won't save lives, potentially it will cause deaths. (Yes I read the article, this is initially only "for the driver's…

This uses GPS data, not optical recognition

From TFA:

> Cars have been able to figure out when they're speeding for a while, thanks to GPS as well as traffic sign recognition

Re: Speed limiters now mandatory in all new EU cars

#39
post #18

This is terrifying. I routinely cross a bridge with a 30ton weight limit, which my car mistakes for a 30km/h speed limit sign. I would cause an average of 2 accidents per month if I suddenly slowed from 70 to 30 and the people behind me weren't paying attention. The technology is _not_ there and this won't save lives, potentially it will cause deaths. (Yes I read the article, this is initially only "for the driver's…

This uses GPS data, not optical recognition

It uses both, AFAIK.
Post reply on HN