Live data from Hacker News

Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

apple.com

421–430 of 1001 posts

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#421

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The information provided for level two is end to end encrypted and not stored so the risk level is pretty low here.

Ent-to-end encrypted means that the other end (Apple/NSA) has access to it.

It does need to process the data. The server has no persistent storage and no remote shell. It is a limited and locked down special-purpose iOS.

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#422

Am I only person who's reached their threshold on companies forcing and shoving AI into every layer and corner of our lives? I don't even look at this stuff any more and see the upside to any of it. AI went from, "This is kinda cool and quaint." to "You NEED this in every single aspect of your life, whether you want it or not." AI has become so pervasive and intrusive, I stopped seeing the benefits of any of this.

Currently, AI use has a "power user" requirement. You have to spend a lot of time with it to know what it is and is not capable of, how to access those hidden capabilities, and be very creative at applying it in your daily life. It's not unlike the first spreadsheets. Sure, they will some day benefit the entire finance department, but at the beginning only people who loved technology for the sake of technology learne…

[deleted]

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#424

Their demos looked like how I imagined AI before ChatGPT ever existed. It was a personalized, context aware, deeply integrated way of interacting with your whole system. I really enjoyed the explanation for how they planned on tackling server-enabled AI tasks while making the best possible effort to keep your requests private. Auditable server software that runs on Apple hardware is probably as good as you can get fo…

Until this gets into reviewers' hands, I think it's fair to say that we really have no idea how good any of this is. When it comes to AI being able to do "all kinds of things," it's easy to demo some really cool stuff, but if it falls on its face all the time in the real world, you end up with the current Siri.

Remember this ad? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sw1iwC7Zh24 12 years ago, they promised a bunch of things that I still wouldn't trust Siri to pull off.

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#426

Microsoft Recall => bad. Apple Recall => good.

Two companies who have earned very different reputations over the decades, will elicit rather different reactions when announcing similar features, yes.

I also missed the part of the linked article where it says that my Mac is going to take a screenshot every few seconds and store it for three months.

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#427

I have only one question: can I turn it off?

Turn off what part and why? They announced several new systems, much of which runs on-device, one of which is simply an improved Siri. I was surprised by how considerate they seemed about AI data privacy, even for Apple.

> Turn off what part and why?

Assume any part, and assume none of your business.

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#428

I have only one question: can I turn it off?

It's one thing to have private information at rest, another to have it indexed, and interpreted by a LLM. What if some virus orders the LLM to search for blackmail material and email it to them? The very act of putting a LLM near your data is a security concern. If someone else orders your Siri to reveal something, it can get to the prize in seconds, with AI help.

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#429

Earlier quoted context omitted.

if I can't turn 100% of this botshit off then my iphone's going in the bin I'll go back to a dumbphone before I feed the AI

You’re not feeding anything by having this feature turned on

Right. This thread on the other hand ...

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#430

So, if I've got this correct there's: 1. On-device AI 2. AI using Apple's servers 3. AI using ChatGPT/OpenAI's services (and others in the future) Number 1 will pass to number 2 if it thinks it requires the extra processing power, but number 3 will only be invoked with explicit user permission. [Edit: As pointed out below, other providers will be coming eventually.]

I see no real difference between 2 and 3. Once the data has left your device, it has left your device. There is no getting it back and you no longer have any control over it.

You do realise that already happens though? If you read apple's privacy policy they send a lot of what you do to their servers.

Furthermore how private do you think Siri is? Their privacy policy explicitly states they send transcripts of what you say to them. That cannot be disabled.

Post reply on HN