Live data from Hacker News

This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

wired.com

101–110 of 164 posts

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#101
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As I understand it, lane splitting is illegal in many U.S. states, but is considered lawful in California (though there is no law for or against it... it is simply "allowed"). I might be wrong but I thought the main justification for lane splitting was due to the air-cooled aspect of motorcycles and the harm that can come from sitting in stalled/slow traffic (although, where I live I see this get abused everyday by m…

The vast majority of motorcycles are water cooled and have been for some time. Incidentally, lane splitting isn't being abused when motorcyclists do it to go faster than cars; that's the whole point.

I see a hell of a lot of Harley Davidsons (whatever your opinion on them) out on the road every day, and those are air cooled. So is my Triumph.

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#102
post #78
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's illegal to split lanes in most states.

And it's not like it's illegal but folk do it anyway -- I have never, ever seen someone do that in my state.

How congested are the roads there? It is legal in California, although I typically don't ride in heavy traffic so I don't feel the need. I'm told that it's also quite common in Washington DC, despite being illegal there.

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#103
post #100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For most of the 90s gas was underpriced compared to historical levels. This was due to a variety of reasons, some technological, some economic, some geopolitical. Over the last decade or so gas has gone up in price though the price is still quite volatile. Short-term estimates are that gas prices probably won't go much higher. Longer-term estimates are tricky, but increasing production of crude oil and natural gas fr…

You're strawmanning. I didn't say we were going to "run out" of oil, I said prices were headed upwards, had been for a long time now, and was showing no signs of reversing. And that we're at the point now where fuel costs are 1:1 with production costs of vehicles, and thus we're going to start seeing changes in vehicle designs at the low end to compensate. I don't see a "this time it's different" anywhere, just an ex…

> > Short-term estimates are that gas prices probably won't go much higher.

> For which you conveniently fail to produce a cite. :)

http://www.lmgtfy.com/?q=gas+price+forecast+2012

:)

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#104
post #77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The vast majority of motorcycles are water cooled and have been for some time. Incidentally, lane splitting isn't being abused when motorcyclists do it to go faster than cars; that's the whole point.

Since there is no law on the books that really defined the "rules" of lane splitting, back when I drove a classic Mini I often wondered what would happen if I just started driving in between cars that I knew I could fit between. I suspect I'd be getting tickets for that. So bikes are allowed to do it for what ever reason. I wonder what a biker would think if I just pulled up along side them on the freeway. I suspect…

A good motorcyclist would not allow you to pull up along side them in their lane. When riding normally, we take up an entire lane by riding in the middle, to prevent people from thinking "Oh, that motorcyclist is at the edge of the lane, that means I can try and use the rest of the lane to pass".

Lane splitting is an exception, and a pretty hair-raising one at times because people are constantly jockeying to get into the next lane over which looks faster, without signaling. And then there are the people who actively attempt to prevent lane-splitting, by pulling onto the line when they see you coming.

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#105

The gyro-stabilized, two-wheeled future of transportation is the bicycle, people. Seriously. If you're really into it, you can throw an electric assist motor on.

They already have them on kids bikes. Now they just need to upgrade to adult size, lower the weight, strap on an electric motor... http://www.thegyrobike.com/category-s/93.htm

And they should build the batteries into the wheel rims for extra stability.

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#106

This is a non-starter. This fills the same niche as an electric moped at 6% or less of the cost. And people can drive electric mopeds on city streets legally today . For less than half the price someone could buy a used, low-mileage sedan (such as a Civic, Corolla, or Accent), with a trunk, seating for 5, seatbelts and airbags. And then use the other $8k to pay for gas at $5 a gallon for the next 48,000 miles. Or, th…

Talking about safety, why is the driver's forehead right behind a metal beam? Even the slightest head-on crash would lead to death or paralysis!

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would hope that in case of a gyro failure the computer would stop listening to the gyros, display a warning light on the dashboard, and you'd be able to bring it to a stop based on the same principles that keep a normal bike upright. You might have to dump it on its side when it comes to a stop, but you shouldn't have to spin off. The dangers of that are roughly similar to a blowout in a normal car, momentary but n…

It's a gyro-wheel not a gyro-sensor. The angular momentum of the wheels is what keeps it upright (laterally). This is different to the Segway which used the motors to control the forward-backward tilt with position input from a gyro (actually an accelerometer)

That can't be the (only) reason bikes stay upright. The gyroscopic effect is way too weak to keep it upright. Here is an article explaining why bikes do stay upright: http://ruina.tam.cornell.edu/research/topics/bicycle_mechani...

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#108
post #98
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm just as skeptical as you, but... Electric mopeds cannot go on freeways. An electric motorcycle is better for nontrivial distances. On the other hand, an electric moped which cannot travel faster than 20mph also has an advantage: in California it is treated as a bicycle and can travel on bike paths on major bridges. My main complaint: if neither electric motorcycles nor self-balancing motorcycles are currently pop…

Personally, I've always wanted a vehicle with the speed and fuel efficiency approaching a motorcycle and a 5-star crash safety rating. Motorcycles are a death trap, and I refuse to ride one despite their many advantages.

And this is the value add.

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#109
post #104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Since there is no law on the books that really defined the "rules" of lane splitting, back when I drove a classic Mini I often wondered what would happen if I just started driving in between cars that I knew I could fit between. I suspect I'd be getting tickets for that. So bikes are allowed to do it for what ever reason. I wonder what a biker would think if I just pulled up along side them on the freeway. I suspect…

A good motorcyclist would not allow you to pull up along side them in their lane. When riding normally, we take up an entire lane by riding in the middle, to prevent people from thinking "Oh, that motorcyclist is at the edge of the lane, that means I can try and use the rest of the lane to pass". Lane splitting is an exception, and a pretty hair-raising one at times because people are constantly jockeying to get into…

So I guess we can agree that lane splitting is a double standard where the motorcycles get favor. Besides the air-cooled aspect (which may or may not be as relevant today), what are some other reasons why motorcycles should be allowed to pass in such a way that cars are not?

Maybe around the SF Bay Area we are the exception to the lane splitting exception because I see countless motorcycles lane split at all speeds on the freeway during my commute. I would NEVER intentionally get in the way of a passing motorcycle. That is just wrong and dangerous. However, I don't really go out of my way to move over for them either. See... I also drive in the middle of my lane, just like all the good motorcyclists do. :)

Re: This Is the Gyro-Stabilized, Two-Wheeled Future of Transportation

#110
post #59

This is a cool concept, although I doubt it will be ready by 2014 at their current rate. My reasoning on that is that you have to have a complete pre-production vehicle before you can even start safety testing. But that isn't a knock, I like optimism as much as the next person. The horizontal flywheel concept is quite cool, and I'm glad they avoided the problem of earlier attempts which just had one (cars that did th…

Amusingly the problems you mention are inherent to a two-wheeler, and given the necessary dimensions of the egg-shaped outside you might as well add some more wheels at the corners to solve the stability problem. Then you end up with something like Renault Twizy [0] (look at the top view on page 2 to get an idea of its dimensions), currently sold today starting at 7000€, plus 50€/month of battery rent. I would not ha…

It's beautiful! I just think it needs a bit more of a trunk.
Post reply on HN