Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

engadget.com

11–20 of 81 posts

Re: Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

#11
How will this affect applications like Matlab 2012 64bit, which require a compiler (such as in the Win 7 SDK) to be installed to use certain features such as SIMULINK?

http://www.mathworks.com/support/compilers/R2012a/win64.html

Will there even be a compiler they could licence from MS and bundle?

Re: Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

#13
For Windows 7, they pulled the plug on DirectX, and targeted gamers who had to upgrade from Windows XP to be able to use DirectX 11. Under the belt, but worked as expected.

For Windows 8, they're pulling the plug on freelance developers (who can still btw develop for Windows 7 if they are okay with VS 10 Express).

For now this doesn't seem to hurt because of the following reasons -

a) Gamers are indeed a vast majority of people who consciously choose Windows for a valid reason, that most mainstream games for PCs are still built with DirectX. They had no choice but to upgrade.

b) How does hurting the free developer help your case? Only that this will encourage people to build more Windows 8 stuff, but -

c) Devs can still continue to develop for Windows 7/XP using VS 10 Express. Granted, VS 11 will bring some attractive features in the language.

d) Point remains that ordinary users, gamers included, will be scarcely affected.

I just hope they're not planning anything else like the DX11 crap they pulled last time. Also wish a good graphics/multi-media framework gets developed in Linux which can give strong competition to DirectX.

Re: Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

#14
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well said. However, we can go to back the open platforms, like Android.

Honest question: how open is Android? I mean, when you consider Play. Can you write/submit an end-user programming app like Scratch? I know we can always dev-unlock the device and install anything we want, but what about the kid with an Android tablet who wants to start hacking? I'm worried about this move to walled gardens on all the platforms. The desktop is one of the last bastions of openness, but its not really…

Won't the first thing the kid with an Android tablet who wants to start hacking do would be to learn how any application can be installed in the device?

Re: Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

#15

How will this affect applications like Matlab 2012 64bit, which require a compiler (such as in the Win 7 SDK) to be installed to use certain features such as SIMULINK? http://www.mathworks.com/support/compilers/R2012a/win64.html Will there even be a compiler they could licence from MS and bundle?

VS Express 2010 will continue to be available.

Previous discussion here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4020222

Re: Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

#16
post #6

I think they should instead focus on making Metro appealing to develop on, rather than making it the only free option. At least they still allow other compilers and any programming language. I wish Ubuntu would step up their development resources game, so that it becomes less painful to do anything there.

It's only Visual Studio 11 Express Edition which is limited to Metro. VS 2010 EE will still be available for developing Windows 8 desktop applications.

Re: Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

#17
+ Freelancer devs will be 'encouraged' to develop for Win 8, an argument can be made this will positively impact Win 8 sells, albeit it will be a difficult argument

- Open source development on Windows will take a hit

- Freelancers will either stick with older and less effective tools, or will choose to abandon Desktop

- Users will tend to get less new software for their Windows 7

+/- Will not affect big corporations, e.g. gamemakers, who use the professional version

- This will provide no additional motivation to bulk of the users (e.g. corporate, gamers) to switch to Windows 8

- This will further 'encourage' piracy of VS11

Re: Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

#18
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well said. However, we can go to back the open platforms, like Android.

Honest question: how open is Android? I mean, when you consider Play. Can you write/submit an end-user programming app like Scratch? I know we can always dev-unlock the device and install anything we want, but what about the kid with an Android tablet who wants to start hacking? I'm worried about this move to walled gardens on all the platforms. The desktop is one of the last bastions of openness, but its not really…

> Can you write/submit an end-user programming app like Scratch?

Yes, you can. e.g AIDE : https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.aide.ui

Re: Microsoft Pulling Free Development Tools for Windows 8 Desktop Apps

#20

+ Freelancer devs will be 'encouraged' to develop for Win 8, an argument can be made this will positively impact Win 8 sells, albeit it will be a difficult argument - Open source development on Windows will take a hit - Freelancers will either stick with older and less effective tools, or will choose to abandon Desktop - Users will tend to get less new software for their Windows 7 +/- Will not affect big corporations…

Freelancer devs will spend the money on the full version of the tools instead of just using the free version. You have to be a pretty small potatoes freelancer to not be able to afford visual studio in some incarnation. See also: graphic artists and photoshop.
Post reply on HN