Live data from Hacker News

Apple orders 10 episodes of a Neuromancer TV series

arstechnica.com

21–30 of 32 posts

Re: Apple orders 10 episodes of a Neuromancer TV series

#21
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes. Here's hoping. I watched Foundation to the end, no matter how bad it got. Just can't stop watching the Live Action adaptations of the old favorites. 'Peripheral', also watched it all, no matter how bad. etc... So, I'll watch this one too. They must know they have built in audience that will accept anything. Why can't there be more like 'Expanse'?

I enjoyed Peripheral, having not read the book. I'd be curious to hear (spoiler-free) criticisms. (The concept was compelling enough, I definitely intend to read the series, especially given its cancellation.)

https://www.reddit.com/r/WilliamGibson/ has certainly what you are looking for.

Re: Apple orders 10 episodes of a Neuromancer TV series

#25
post #2

After what they did to Foundation, I haven't got the least bit of interest.

Interestingly it's the opposite for me. The book (read only the first) was not enjoyable and I thought it's poorly written, bad characters and plotlines. So hearing the Foundation in TV is not like the book makes me want to see it.

Re: Apple orders 10 episodes of a Neuromancer TV series

#27
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think Apple just wanted their own Game of Thrones flagship, and on paper, Foundation seems like it should be that (epic scale, big ideas). But honestly, it needs a more subdued treatment: mostly talking heads in rooms, and an anthology that jumps forward decades with each episode, rotating characters as necessary. Blockbuster narratives need heroes, which works directly at cross-purposes to the long-term systemic t…

> I think Apple just wanted their own Game of Thrones flagship Dune makes the most sense for TV and not the movies. A lot of the political subtlety is lost in the movies

Except that the other books are just wierd

Re: Apple orders 10 episodes of a Neuromancer TV series

#28
post #2

After what they did to Foundation, I haven't got the least bit of interest.

Interestingly it's the opposite for me. The book (read only the first) was not enjoyable and I thought it's poorly written, bad characters and plotlines. So hearing the Foundation in TV is not like the book makes me want to see it.

It was basically an entirely different (not very good) thing. I thought the genetic dynasty part of it was super awesome though, not a closely examined subject in the books and the guy who played empire day i thought was very good.

Re: Apple orders 10 episodes of a Neuromancer TV series

#29
post #14
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

agree, the show betrays essential principles of the trilogy. Why even have psychohistory at all if you’re throwing away everything that stems from it? especially sad, considering that it has a solid cast and looks beautiful

I think Apple just wanted their own Game of Thrones flagship, and on paper, Foundation seems like it should be that (epic scale, big ideas). But honestly, it needs a more subdued treatment: mostly talking heads in rooms, and an anthology that jumps forward decades with each episode, rotating characters as necessary. Blockbuster narratives need heroes, which works directly at cross-purposes to the long-term systemic t…

Julian May's Galactic Milieu might be that kind of thing. Start at Jack's book, maybe add Rogation's book as flashbacks. Th Rebellion and fury's antics give a good framework to let a bunch of writers add more material in between.

Re: Apple orders 10 episodes of a Neuromancer TV series

#30
post #2

After what they did to Foundation, I haven't got the least bit of interest.

Foundation is different than the books but I appreciate a lot of the story they've been telling in the show. I'm looking forward to their Neuromancer treatment

Gotta say didn't read foundation, but i like the show, really sucks that people don't get that studios will always need to tweak books for appeal or other reasons to make it work for their audience, it doesn't make the shows bad.

This is why we end up with studios not willing to make shows and keep them around the people that just get upset cause it didn't meet their expectations from books.

Post reply on HN