Live data from Hacker News

Orgzly Revived: a community-maintained version of Orgzly

github.com

41–50 of 71 posts

Re: Orgzly Revived: a community-maintained version of Orgzly

#41
Does it have an option to open a file in place in my shared data directory? I don't need to "import" a file into its app data space, and I want to keep using mgit/syncthing to sync across devices.

At the moment I have a script that calls org-html-export-to-html which I sync to view, but obviously can't update on the device (without setting up emacs).

Re: Orgzly Revived: a community-maintained version of Orgzly

#43
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It helps a lot if you have a third machine, which runs 24/7. Haven't had any sync conflicts in ages.

What does the third machine do?

It's a read-only peer with a huge disk which is always on and syncs changes across all devices continuesly. This way you can safely change the same file across all devices, without them having to be online simultaneously.

Re: Orgzly Revived: a community-maintained version of Orgzly

#44
post #15

How does it compare to other note taking apps like Obsidian, Notion, Joplin etc? I used Joplin for about a year and ended up taking a lot of notes. But after a year it was so full of garbage that I found it increasingly difficult to keep things tagged, clearing my "inbox" of quickly taken notes. And it ended up looking like my work email inbox. The catalyst for giving it up was a subtle policy change at work that mad…

It's an org-mode limited editor, to have org-mode outside Emacs. Compared to MarkDown and "modern note apps" using it it's like a starship (org-mode) against a bike (MD and modern apps), but Orgzly is limited by the OS/input mode of so it's barely usable. If you want to take notes seriously you need a desktop.

> If you want to take notes seriously you need a desktop.

Emacs on android and a keyboard also lets you take notes seriously.

Re: Orgzly Revived: a community-maintained version of Orgzly

#45

Wow, I live out of Orgzly every day and had no idea this was a thing I needed - every day I am so happy I sub to this site. Thank you for posting!

Same here, I use it for todo lists on my phone and didn't know it wasn't being maintained. Although, maybe that's because i haven't encountered any issues. But my use of it is really minimal, as I prefer typing on a keyboard.

Looking back, a few years ago I used to get Orgzly updates fairly regularly and I remember thinking, "Wow, it's nice to use actively developed software and get all these features I never expected but which are convenient." That hasn't happened in a while, but I also didn't realise it hadn't.

Re: Orgzly Revived: a community-maintained version of Orgzly

#46
post #25

I used orgzly+syncthing for a while but the overhead of manually resolving conflicts between my laptop and phone were not worth it in the end. I'd consider using it again if a sync protocol or some other mechanism of merging changes across multiple computers is added.

The approach I use is to have a single incoming notes file for my phone. I then refile those notes into the correct location on my laptop later. It works for me because I realised that when I want to take a note on my phone I usually don't have time for a complete note, so the extra refile step gives me the opportunity to fill it out more at my leisure on my laptop. As an extra benefit though, it means that I only ha…

This is how I also do it, and with ediff-files it is fairly quick to resolve whatever conflicts inevitably come up anyway.

Re: Orgzly Revived: a community-maintained version of Orgzly

#47

I really really need a mobile app for org-mode that syncs without pain (yes, I am aware of Orgzly + Syncthing, I am using it, but it still is not as smooth as I want it to be, and has too many annoyances). I simply cannot imagine leaving the comfort of org-mode for something inferior like markdown, even though there are cool plugins in the Obsidian ecosystem. Question if you are an Obsidian user - what are your most…

You need to:

- enable save/sync on resume orgzly

- ensure inotify based sync enabled on orgzly folder

- enable polling every minute on syncthing folder

- sync files by most recently modified

Re: Orgzly Revived: a community-maintained version of Orgzly

#49
I'm using Orgzly on my phone now to take notes. I also have Emacs on my various computers, always open on at least one, though I never got into Org-mode much. Now, I'd like to try having the same notes on all devices.

Synchthing is mentioned often with Orgzly, so I looked into Syncthing. I've been disappointed to find Syncthing drains the phone battery excessively if you enable continuous (event-driven) two-way sync between phone and server.

The problem is Syncthing doesn't hook into the phone's notification delivery service, so it can only pick up changes by keeping a socket open to the server and sending packets often, throughout the day, to keep the socket alive. Even if there are no file changes to report. That drains the battery much faster than, say, a chat app that uses the notification service to send triggers from the server to the phone when there's a new message. (I wrote about technical reasons why that's more battery-efficient here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38661294).

Does anyone have a recommendation that will keep notes in Orgzly two-way synchronised with Org files on my server, reliably, without draining the phone battery excessively, and without a long delay for changes on the server to propagate to the phone?

Post reply on HN