Live data from Hacker News

NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

goodlawproject.org

41–50 of 121 posts

Re: NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

#41
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ah meyers briggs, the tabloid astrology of the office worker.

I know someone who worked in finance HR for approx 20 years. Nearly every time the business hired someone who would have been identified as a poor fit by Meyers Briggs they wouldn't last 12 months.

Given a little time I can pass the test with whatever type they want.

Re: NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Must respectfully say that this company should not be allowed to exist. We are outsourcing state level powers to a completely opaque private entity with zero accountability. This can only end badly.

What does “state level powers” even mean? And they’re hardly “opaque”, at least not any more than any other publicly traded company is, and held to similar account. What do you think they do that’s so above-and-beyond what a non-government organization should be able to do? I wonder if you’re falling for a lot of the marketing hype…

> they’re hardly “opaque”, at least not any more than any other publicly traded company is

Publicly traded companies are required to report certain financial facts about the company, but they’re still extremely opaque.

Re: NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sure Palantir is up to just as much shit in its sales division as it is in its actual work, but normal human beings just call changing your communication style and content in response to the listener's reactions "having a conversation".

Normal humans don't try to communicate directly with each other through the media.

Have you ever been on public transit in DC? There are billboards all over the place (or were a decade ago when I was there last) that are clearly sales efforts targeting like 4 people. It's not that weird.

Re: NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

#44

Pre IPO ex Palantir here. Palantir will do a number of things to gain influence. They'll find out who are the decision makers on the space they want a contract, and they'll target them specifically. For example: if they know you take the train to work every morning, and read the news paper, they'll take a full page advertisement on the paper they know you like and that you'll see. They gain this information by, you g…

It's a slimy company with one very slimy founder in particular.

That we fund this company with our taxes is repugnant.

Re: NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm sure Palantir is up to just as much shit in its sales division as it is in its actual work, but normal human beings just call changing your communication style and content in response to the listener's reactions "having a conversation".

Normal humans don't try to communicate directly with each other through the media.

B2B companies do this via LinkedIn ads on the regular.

Re: NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

#47
post #6

I just don't get it. NHS needs a big data platform so they go to a... spy tech company? Why are they so insistent that it must be Palantir that builds this, instead of choosing from a dozen of other consulting companies that don't have a dodgy track record? Ideally the NHS would just build it in house, but sadly it's a slow and bloated organisation unable to innovate (as most government managed things usually become)…

Palantir offers a LOT of services to government orgs. So it's probably something akin to packaging more than one product in one.

Re: NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

#48

Pre IPO ex Palantir here. Palantir will do a number of things to gain influence. They'll find out who are the decision makers on the space they want a contract, and they'll target them specifically. For example: if they know you take the train to work every morning, and read the news paper, they'll take a full page advertisement on the paper they know you like and that you'll see. They gain this information by, you g…

They seem sketchy just based off their name from the LOTR object.

From Wikipedia:

"A major theme of palantír usage is that while the stones show real objects or events, those using the stones had to "possess great strength of will and of mind" to direct the stone's gaze to its full capability.[T 2] The stones were an unreliable guide to action, since what was not shown could be more important than what was selectively presented. A risk lay in the fact that users with sufficient power could choose what to show and what to conceal to other stones: in The Lord of the Rings, a palantír has fallen into the Enemy's hands, making the usefulness of all other existing stones questionable. Commentators such as the Tolkien scholar Paul Kocher note the hand of providence in their usage, while Joseph Pearce compares Sauron's use of the stones to broadcast wartime propaganda"

Re: NHS to investigate Palantir influencer campaign as possible contract breach

#50
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know someone who worked in finance HR for approx 20 years. Nearly every time the business hired someone who would have been identified as a poor fit by Meyers Briggs they wouldn't last 12 months.

Given a little time I can pass the test with whatever type they want.

Or just answer randomly. You might get rejected for inconsistent answers, but at least no one will have a "personality profile" for you that they can sell.
Post reply on HN