Live data from Hacker News

Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

culture.pl

51–60 of 123 posts

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#51
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ok, I need to double check, but I'm pretty sure using ketchup anywhere near pierogi is illegal.

My mother in law is 2nd gen British, her parents came from Poland in the 1930s, so they are nearly 100 years out of Poland. It might be something to do with that.

Ah, the British' fine taste in cuisine!

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#52
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have been in Poland for much of the time since the war started, and while I have read news articles about this supposed new term pierogie ukraińskie , I don’t think I have ever seen it in the real world. The pierogis served at milk bars, or from Żabka to be microwaved, are still overwhelmingly referred to as ruskie . Even the Ukrainian cafe nearby serves them as pierogie ruskie .

In Ukraine they're called Varenyky (originating from a verb "boil", like "boiled things").

Unless they're filled with meat, and then they're pelmeni.

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#53
post #3

There's an interesting shift in language associated with the Russian invasion of Ukraine - a type of pierogi which used to be called ruskie (from the region of Red Rus, where they originate) are now commonly named ukraińskie (Ukrainian) instead. The reason is that the adjective ruskie is typically understood as "Russian" in general parlance.

I have been in Poland for much of the time since the war started, and while I have read news articles about this supposed new term pierogie ukraińskie , I don’t think I have ever seen it in the real world. The pierogis served at milk bars, or from Żabka to be microwaved, are still overwhelmingly referred to as ruskie . Even the Ukrainian cafe nearby serves them as pierogie ruskie .

I've seen them and was at first confused as to what they were, especially that Ukrainian borscht is very different from the local version, so I assumed it was something new.

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#54

My polish mother called them "pirojki", which is the french term. She made 2 variations: - mashed potatoes and white cheese - rice and meat rolled in a cabbage leaf One of our neighbors offered one with mashed potatoes and apricot jam (I hated that). Too bad I'm gluten intolerant now.

The latter is called "gołąbki" ("pigeons").

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#55
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Stealing? It's their shared East Slavic heritage.

You then obviously don't know the history. One notable thing to mention is that Russia started as Principality of Moscow, a vassal state to Mongols, a collector of tribute for Mongols. Taking their own share from this tribute allowed them to prosper.

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#56
post #3

There's an interesting shift in language associated with the Russian invasion of Ukraine - a type of pierogi which used to be called ruskie (from the region of Red Rus, where they originate) are now commonly named ukraińskie (Ukrainian) instead. The reason is that the adjective ruskie is typically understood as "Russian" in general parlance.

So it's basically a new version of the "Freedom Fries" mania, but with higher popularity?

Anecdotal, but I'm in Poland for the weekend every other week and I've never seen this.

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Stealing? It's their shared East Slavic heritage.

Indeed. “Rus” is an ethnonym, of famously Scandinavian origin, used across the entire East Slavic area and was never something limited to people in now-Ukraine that people in now-Russia could “steal”. The Uralic- and Turkic-speaking peoples of the Middle Volga, for example, already called the neighboring Slavic-speaking populations “Rus” in the medieval era.

Actually no. "Rus" was meant to describe "all" East Slavic people, but Russians took it for themselves "only" and started to call Ukrainians "Little Russians" in sense of "Lesser Russians".

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#58
i still remember the first time i tried pierogi at a music festival in Poland after a few beers -- they were amazing

but years later that experience was overshadowed when i tried their traditional zurek soup -- now that was divine

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#59
post #3

There's an interesting shift in language associated with the Russian invasion of Ukraine - a type of pierogi which used to be called ruskie (from the region of Red Rus, where they originate) are now commonly named ukraińskie (Ukrainian) instead. The reason is that the adjective ruskie is typically understood as "Russian" in general parlance.

I'm not sure if it's a shift in language - it's more like a reaction/virtue signalling of some restaurants in the first weeks of invasion that briefly got viral, but - in the rare case of accuracy winning over memes - it died out as people soon after (re)learned that "ruskie" in "pierogi ruskie" refers to Ruś, not Russia. At least, that's my local experience (Kraków, Poland) - we went through the meme phase and came out of it a week or two later, and I haven't heard anyone mentioning "ukraińskie pierogi" ever since (until on HN, today).

Re: Poland's Most Famous Dish: Pierogi

#60
post #19

+1 from me, as article mention one of the small annoyances I have. My family comes from Red Ruthenia, region where ruskie pierogi comes from. Because of lingual characteristic they are usually linked to Russia (as mentioned in article) and so, with all the turmoil many restaurants decided to rename them: either to pierogi with potatoes and cheese or to galicean - as from Galicia, which is commonly perceived as Krakow…

> My family comes from Red Ruthenia, region where ruskie pierogi comes from Is there any definitive proof behind that? My family too come from former Polish territories in Ukraine. It feels like in the last decade all of Slavs have been rushing into claiming as their own many traditions. I find it sad and unnecessary. In fact I suspect the dish to be popular to move of the former Kievan Rus' region and I know for sur…

There’s no more proof than any other dish. It’s so popular that no one bothered to have a “protected origin” certificate.

Yet they predominantly are served in this region so having them being “ruskie” or “ruthenian” (a huge region) is much more fair than naming it Galician.

Post reply on HN