Live data from Hacker News

Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

gitlab.bixilon.de

81–90 of 93 posts

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#81

Wait so this actually implements everything? Like all the features? System recs are quite high, I was hoping to find something that my kids can use on their Chromebooks but even if this isn’t it, this is cool as heck.

I've had a good success running the Java version of Minecraft in the Linux environment of ChromeOS.

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#82
post #75
post #60

Things like this always make me a bit sad when things like mine test exist. Since projects like this depends on decompiled Minecraft source, they're legally still piracy. Meanwhile, it probably would be simpler to implement some thing like hypixel in the open-source Minecraft-workalike minetest, where you'd be in much less legally muddy water. But still nobody would play that. Because brand.

Would you consider a word processor that is coded around the quirks of Microsoft Word and that is able to open and modify its proprietary format as piracy ?

If it was made based on de-compiled MS Word code? Yes.

That's a very important distinction.

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#83
post #66
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Minetest is a prime example of the weakness of the open source community. A bunch of people want to "system dev" you a framework. Very few want, or is capabale of, designing you an actual finished game, at least in the open source context. Op's kid deserve better. The best I can suggest is 0AD. https://play0ad.com/ It might require an actual computer though.

I suspect you don't have kids? Either way that is a hilarious recommendation, for a number of reasons. If my kids asked to play Minecraft and I installed that game, it would be a bit like them asking for pancakes and serving them bran flakes and a grapefruit. They're not even remotely similar games, and have wildly different levels of appropriateness for children -- though that obviously depends on parental preferenc…

FWIW, my 5th grader read this comment and got actively agitated at the comparison. He adores Minetest and wanted to convey that he "has a great community to play with". Of course YMMV, but I thought his take was worth mentioning.

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#84

Wait so this actually implements everything? Like all the features? System recs are quite high, I was hoping to find something that my kids can use on their Chromebooks but even if this isn’t it, this is cool as heck.

A nice addition would be starting a local Minecraft server and start the game for offline play, without any account, similar to UltiMC Launcher

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#85
post #54
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

hypixel is an impressive minecraft server, not mod

For a demonstration of what hypixel is, Technoblade has some great videos. My favorite being The Great Potato War saga: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qjnDd1rsII

Technoblade never dies!

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#86
post #31

https://github.com/Bixilon/Minosoft

Why the downvotes? Parent linked the mirror as OP's link returns 502.

I think someone posted the mirror in the time between me loading the comments and writing my own one

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#87
post #35

Wait so this actually implements everything? Like all the features? System recs are quite high, I was hoping to find something that my kids can use on their Chromebooks but even if this isn’t it, this is cool as heck.

If you're on a low end system, I can recommend Minetest. It's a similar but different experience - you still mine blocks and craft items but all of the details are quite different. I enjoy both games; while I prefer Minecraft due to community and momentum, Minetest is great if you just want a nice and simple sandbox.

Adding to the minetest suggestion, it's actually an engine for other minecraft clones, and I believe there's a specific entry called Mineclone that is built to be feature-aligned with Minecraft directly. I haven't played it but it seems pretty up to date.

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#88
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I suspect you don't have kids? Either way that is a hilarious recommendation, for a number of reasons. If my kids asked to play Minecraft and I installed that game, it would be a bit like them asking for pancakes and serving them bran flakes and a grapefruit. They're not even remotely similar games, and have wildly different levels of appropriateness for children -- though that obviously depends on parental preferenc…

FWIW, my 5th grader read this comment and got actively agitated at the comparison. He adores Minetest and wanted to convey that he "has a great community to play with". Of course YMMV, but I thought his take was worth mentioning.

Just in case my comment wasn't clear: I think Minetest -> Minecraft is at least a fair comparison, even if there are some glaring omissions in Minetest.

My bran flakes -> pancakes statement wasn't referring to Minetest. I was referring to the Age of Empires clone the parent comment recommended instead of Minetest.

P.S. Kudos to the young one for being open minded and independent about alternatives in the face of heavily-marketed-and-heavily-peer-used things! I can tell they're already wise beyond their years =)

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#89
post #71

Wait so this actually implements everything? Like all the features? System recs are quite high, I was hoping to find something that my kids can use on their Chromebooks but even if this isn’t it, this is cool as heck.

I haven't tried it myself, but it looks like the bedrock edition can run on chrome OS. I think https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mojang.min... is the link, though it says "Chrome OS version sold separately" so I'm not 100% sure

It works. I play Bedrock Minecraft on my Chromebook frequently. No issues.

Re: Minosoft: Open-source Minecraft client, written from scratch

#90

Author should be aware that Mojang has nuked copy projects before. Now that they have MS lawyers they will C&D anything that carries the "Minecraft" name relationship. Never even mention it, call it by more general technical terms like a "square voxel engine" or something.

If that had any ounce of truth clearly they would have tried taking down mineserver and minetest long ago. If projects gets taken down it's because of copyright infringement, not because they are referencing the name. Removing all references to Minecraft won't do anything if the project contains assets or decompiled code from Minecraft either.

Minecraft is a trademark. You can't make references to it from your own work. Feel free to research mojangs history and intellectual property laws. You don't have rights, only privledges given temporarily by the corp. They can choose to C&D whenever they like.
Post reply on HN