Live data from Hacker News

Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

youtube.com

101–110 of 117 posts

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#101
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"I believe ZTE was banned by the US government, along with Huawei for doing shady things." The shady things are beeing chinese owned and there is a trade war? Otherwise I heard lots of accusations, but saw no proof of anything.

It’s a very easy search

To find something concrete against Huawei? Sources please, I was not able to find anything like that.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#102

We need a law, and that"s coming from a libertarian. If the owner of a hardware device is using it, that person has total control over the device. Nothing can be blocked. Nothing can be hidden. All data must be available in plain language. That owner/user should have the right to inspect and modify everything in the device in plain language. With today's memory / storage capacities and with today's LLMs, that should…

> Nothing can be blocked. Nothing can be hidden. In US/EU there is a law which explicitly forbids complete access to the wifi part of any device. So that you can't modify it's maximum power/frequencies. Any company giving you complete wifi access is criminally liable in US/EU.

I haven’t checked the laws in those jurisdictions, but having worked with a mobile radio network in the past, that doesn’t look entirely unreasonable. People don’t realise how much carnage a single rogue device (whether through failure or intentional hostile act) can cause and how hard it can be to track down the source of a rogue transmission. There is no physical barrier that prevents the normal laws of physics from applying to frequencies carrying control signalling and disrupting everyone else using them, so legal and technical barriers are all you have to try to maintain a working network for everyone as much as possible.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#103

Tip; Syncthing is available for Android and is really really good to keep your data distributed. Thought it would kill my battery when I installed it, but it's very well optimized. Even Google Play services drains more battery.

I use Syncthing-Fork just for the ability to set it up so that it doesn't try to sync all the time to save battery and mobile data.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#104
post #27
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You prefer totally non-transparent cloud scanning that allows for ad hoc, warrantless, untraceable, personally-targeted scans from anyone who can threaten a big company? I saw client-side scanning as much more transparent and limited. Yes, there could be abuses, but there is not a single possible abuse worse than what is already happening every day with cloud-side scanning.

I don't want any of my data scanned which is why I don't tend to store it in the cloud. If Apple rolled out client side scanning what's to prevent them from extending it to all data on the device, regardless of whether it's synced to iCloud?

Google does cloud side scanning and owns Android. What’s to stop them from scanning your local files?

Hint: nothing technical

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#105

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If Apple releases mid-tier phone after this, they will win the market for sure.

You forgot the other reason. I don't want an IPhone because I prefer to actually own my device (and because Android is overall more secure and I personally care about this).

The security of Android vs Apple keep ping-ponging back and forth for which is considered more secure against programmatic exploits.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#106
post #3

That's messed up. I have generally preferred Samsung products,too. 10-15 years ago, when I had a lot more free time, I used to put CyanogenMod on my phones and play around with that. Are there any good open source mobile OS around these days?

Lineageos is still here, GrapheneOS and CalyxOS is more updated and presumably more secure and private, but Graphene only supports Pixels and Calyx supports Pixels plus some other models. Pixels should be your best bet in terms of ROM compatibility.

It sucks. There's basically no other choice except a Pixel phone. And even some of them are locked if you buy it through your carrier.

I would get some Linux phone even if they aren't perfect, but I have no cell reception, and rely on Wifi calling, which seems to be some proprietary thing that only Apple and Google are able to implement.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You forgot the other reason. I don't want an IPhone because I prefer to actually own my device (and because Android is overall more secure and I personally care about this).

> I prefer to actually own my device What do you mean by that? Its an odd take in an article about Android users learning they don't own their device. > and because Android is overall more secure and I personally care about this citation?

You can flash android phone with another OS that won't spy on you. And you cannot do this with iPhone.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#108
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Parent isn’t talking about control. Their comment is off-topic, but correct.

Parent says his prison is prettier, I say they his prison was the first of its kind and others start to copy it.

In his prison only warden snoops in your stuff, in Samsung other inmates too.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#109
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple has new iPhones for sale at various price points all the way down to the very affordable iPhone SE.

The iPhone SE still starts at 3x the price of a low-tier Samsung smartphone. Example from Poland: https://mediamarkt.pl/telefony-i-smartfony/smartfon-apple-ip... https://mediamarkt.pl/telefony-i-smartfony/smartfon-samsung-...

And unlike said Samsung, it will last for 2-3 more years.

Re: Samsung disables customer phones remotely, holds data hostage [video]

#110
post #96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In a free market, people choosing not to buy Samsung phones would prevent them from doing this.

But they pulled this after the phones were bought.

This is called reputation.

People will stop buying from you.

Post reply on HN