Live data from Hacker News

The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

coryzue.com

201–210 of 347 posts

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#201
post #153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You call them naive like if it was a bad thing. I for one welcome the naive ones, they don't feel like they are transparently trying to take advantage.

It is a bad thing if you can be fired if someone digs up your 10 year old tweets.

Hm well you may be right there, I admit I was mostly thinking about person-to-person engagement than twitter timelines.

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#203

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> as people seek more engagement, their content gets worse. What’s going on here? This is a well observed trend where appealing to a broader audience makes the content worse. People, as individuals, are unique and therefore interesting. Appealing to more than one person relies on what those people have in common. The more people you try to reach, the less in common they all have. If the content is going to speak to w…

I am very interested in your take. When Michelangelo sculpted the Pietà, the pain it expressed was a feeling that many people had shared, so it became culture. But when a teenager makes a tiktok about the pain of being rejected by their crush, and it's a feeling many people have shared, and many people like it, that's basic, vague and shallow.

> When Michelangelo sculpted the Pietà, the pain it expressed was a feeling that many people had shared, so it became culture.

So, first, any art that is funded by the church or a patron is not really in this conversation. The entire economics of that art is outside of the eyeball conversation.

If art that is pre-funded strikes a chord with people, it is the same thing as I said about artists in the past. Like Coltraine or Hendrix, they expressed something unique or personal that it was discovered that all people shared, and it therefore became culture.

There are mounds upon mounds of crappy pre-funded religious art that impacted no-one whatsoever. So Pietra is precisely the opposite of pop art, although that is what it became. Which is what makes it culture.

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#204
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> difference between shopping at costco and shopping at walmart Could someone please explain to me what is implied here? I've been to the USA only once, and I didn't visit neither a Costco nor a Walmart. The only difference I could point to between them, is that no "Costco people" phenomenon exists on YouTube. Sincere thanks in advance!

Walmart shoppers are uniquely incapable of existing in an area without being in the way. I've not experienced anything like it in any other store. It's like they're constantly trying to take up as much space as possible. Between that and Walmart having narrower aisles than most stores, the place feels busy even when there aren't many people in it. Also, the workers and shoppers alike all seem depressed, which is anot…

Dollar General, universally understaffed, often with random shit stacked up in aisles, quite often just a single soul running the shop, is usually pretty depressing for me.

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#205
post #172

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Human connection doesn't scale! But authenticity isn't connection. You do not need to connect with someone to see their authenticity. I think the original sin of Elon-Twitter is mistaking popularity for authenticity - because by definition authenticity isn't universally recognizable. It's how authentic experience is unexpected, arbitrary, incomplete and often contradictory. People being authentic in a world you're no…

This is something I've noticed with documentaries on the furry community. Outsider documentaries always focus on the fursuits. You almost never see someone out of one even though most furries don't own one. Pittsburgh's news outlets always do interview segments during Anthrocon, and it's always fursuiters in suit. And then from the inside, you get stuff like The Fandom which goes into the real human stories behind th…

This is another wonderful example!

There's an aspect of...how any complex trend will inevitably have some aspects that would appear to outsides like they were included by mistake...but insiders will assure you are essential and typical. You need insiders to guide you because, as outsiders, you can't understand.

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#206
post #42

The use of the words "Attention Economy" is what I personally call the pablumization of a problem. If we want to address the problem we need to use the correct term: clickbait economy. The internet as we know it, is bought and paid for by clicks. And the way to get more clicks has nothing to do with authenticity. Just the opposite. Which article would you click on to read - "More and more Americans sink into poverty"…

There are two fundamental problems with social media. The first is the ad-driven revenue model as you pointed out. The other is the dopamine economy that is driven by getting your stuff to have “engagement”, which is financially reinforced by the ad revenue model. If any one platform by themselves tries to fix these problems then it will be suicide. The industry as a whole has to do it, and they won’t without regulat…

It’s going to have to be a non-industry move or a radically different model sustained by an interested minority. Federated systems are the other way this can work.

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#207

Some thoughts: > Megathreads about AI, thoughtful, longform narratives that could have been blog posts... Honestly, the long form tweets became a signal to just ignore that tweet. I unfollow or block users that tweet long form often. > The people in my feed—most of whom I’m not following, by the way— Yea, just use the chrono-tab ("following"). Only usable version of Twitter. > love posting for engagement. Some of the…

> I block even people that don't share follows if I got to see a tweet I just don't like.

What does “don’t share follows” mean?

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#208
post #204

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Walmart shoppers are uniquely incapable of existing in an area without being in the way. I've not experienced anything like it in any other store. It's like they're constantly trying to take up as much space as possible. Between that and Walmart having narrower aisles than most stores, the place feels busy even when there aren't many people in it. Also, the workers and shoppers alike all seem depressed, which is anot…

Dollar General, universally understaffed, often with random shit stacked up in aisles, quite often just a single soul running the shop, is usually pretty depressing for me.

This is all true, yet doesn't bother me like Wal Mart does.

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#209
post #199

I think by now the most efficient social media would be an endless doom scroll with sub 5 second videos that the viewer gets to like or dislike to train the algorithm. No thinking, just flashing lights straight into the brain. I'm sure this is what the kids will be watching in 2-10 years. Total mindless entertainment. I'd develop it myself and get rich, if I didn't have a conscience.

that already exists...it's called tiktok

Re: The slow death of authenticity in an attention economy

#210

>And yes, on the surface this incentivizes people to create better content. The better your content is, the more it gets seen, and the more money you make. And yet, my felt experience of this change is the exact opposite—as people seek more engagement, their content gets worse. What’s going on here? It always tickles me when terminally online people realize that human connection doesn't scale . It's valuable precisel…

fyi, I can't get used to the term me*space. I can hardly type it. It articulates a level of contempt for humanity that can only be borne of complete dissociation or deep hatred. I know that's not how it's meant, but I really, really encourage people to avoid using the term.

Strangely, I don't feel the same way when some wisdom traditions remind us that we are mortal (a bag of bones comes to mind), or in response to a number of other diminishing epithets. Weird.

Post reply on HN