Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

news.ycombinator.com

151–160 of 182 posts

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#151
post #91

Bluetooth and WiFi both borrow their spectrum from microwave ovens. It's typical and expected that microwave ovens will cause some interference with other users of the 2.4GHz ISM band that are very nearby. Microwaves operate at very high power levels and are required to be shielded for human safety, but the permissible leakage power is relatively high compared to typical WiFi and Bluetooth devices---there's a simple…

And on the follow-up, "Why use 2.4(5) GHz for microwaves?" Because it happens to be a convenient frequency that water absorbs readily, which is the easiest way of heating up what we'd want to heat with a microwave (read: food). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromagnetic_absorption_by_... And once we'd polluted the frequency for any stable commercial use, why not use this weird carve-out for a little thing called W…

> "But this would have been the 1950s(?), so I'd assume they empirically determined a balance of functionality + technical feasibility for water, called it a lunch, and went to have five martinis in a practical fashion."

Or maybe they just wanted to revive frozen hamsters more humanely: "I promise this story about microwaves is interesting." by Tom Scott, about scientist James Lovelock - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tdiKTSdE9Y

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#152

Bluetooth and WiFi both borrow their spectrum from microwave ovens. It's typical and expected that microwave ovens will cause some interference with other users of the 2.4GHz ISM band that are very nearby. Microwaves operate at very high power levels and are required to be shielded for human safety, but the permissible leakage power is relatively high compared to typical WiFi and Bluetooth devices---there's a simple…

And now my new microwave actually has Wi-Fi built-in, we've come full circle.

[deleted]

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#153
post #97

There's about 1000 watts of RF inside the microwave, it has to be attenuated to less than a few microwatts on the outside to avoid congestion, as they use the same frequency band. I'm amazed WiFi or Bluetooth ever works at all. 8) You can thank Hedy Lamar for that. Try cleaning the mating surfaces around the door thoroughly. If that doesn't work, consider replacing the microwave or relocating the speaker.

> Try cleaning the mating surfaces around the door thoroughly. (I'm obviously not an electrical engineer, given this is 10x stuff) If we're talking a 2.45 GHz microwave signal, that's a 12.2 cm wavelength. But I thought for shielding you only needed to have gaps of Is there some fractional-wavelength propagation, or is my understanding of EM shielding off-base? How are microwaves noisy? E.g. https://physics.stackexch…

But the gap around the door might only be millimeters wide, but it is 30cm or more long.

It is "both* dimensions that must be a long way below the wavelength to keep microwaves in.

Instead the door seal uses a technique called a quarter wave choke. It relies on reflecting back any microwaves wanting to escape, and by making incoming and reflected waves perfectly cancel, no power is transmitted.

As OP said, even a small amount of soup dripped onto the seal and your microwaves will all start escaping.

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#154

Bluetooth and WiFi both borrow their spectrum from microwave ovens. It's typical and expected that microwave ovens will cause some interference with other users of the 2.4GHz ISM band that are very nearby. Microwaves operate at very high power levels and are required to be shielded for human safety, but the permissible leakage power is relatively high compared to typical WiFi and Bluetooth devices---there's a simple…

And now my new microwave actually has Wi-Fi built-in, we've come full circle.

That's probably a good thing, because it means they have to take extra care to make sure the shielding is good enough that microwave energy used for cooking won't interfere!

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#155
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Try cleaning the mating surfaces around the door thoroughly. (I'm obviously not an electrical engineer, given this is 10x stuff) If we're talking a 2.45 GHz microwave signal, that's a 12.2 cm wavelength. But I thought for shielding you only needed to have gaps of Is there some fractional-wavelength propagation, or is my understanding of EM shielding off-base? How are microwaves noisy? E.g. https://physics.stackexch…

> Is there some fractional-wavelength propagation? "Propagation" is probably not the right word, but fractional wavelengths can "leak" some amount of field. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evanescent_field

Notably, that field is powerful enough that microwave doors need to be about an inch thick. The rest of the inch is just empty space and a sheet of plastic to stop you putting your fingers into the evanescent field.

Unfortunately there were a few microwaves sold recently in Europe which forgot that design element, and if you pointed at food while cooking it, you would cook your fingers too.

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#156
post #78
post #12

My data is anecdotal, but I've observed that Panasonic inverter ovens that I've used interfered in the 2.4GHz range, while models of other brands (e.g. GE) have not. (This is unfortunate because Panasonic seems to be the only brand that can actually adjust power output, whereas the others simulate lower power levels by cycling on and off.)

I know of at least two Panasonic inverter microwaves that failed within a 5 year period of ownership. Mine emitted white smoke warming up some tea while I was in another room. I hope to God it wasn’t beryllium. I still have a Panasonic OTR microwave, but it’s inverterless. It appears to be an improved design of a GE model from the same OEM.

Probably burnt paint from the inside of the waveguide.

Happens frequently when the mica sheet that covers the injection port gets moisture from steam (who'd have thought - steam in a microwave?!?)

Simple fix is to replace the mica (a few cents from AliExpress) and use steel wool to get rid of any carbon residue around the injection port.

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#157
post #12

My data is anecdotal, but I've observed that Panasonic inverter ovens that I've used interfered in the 2.4GHz range, while models of other brands (e.g. GE) have not. (This is unfortunate because Panasonic seems to be the only brand that can actually adjust power output, whereas the others simulate lower power levels by cycling on and off.)

You can thank terribly written intellectual property laws for that exclusivity. It’s not like inverters are some kind of new technology, and yet here we are.

I suspect the inverter design is now cheaper too.

The traditional design needs all power to go through a transformer. A 1 kilowatt 60Hz transformer necessarily uses a lot of copper and steel. The inverter design can use MOSFETs (theoretically cheap, but a reasonable IP cost) and far less copper and steel.

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#158

My neighbors have something crazy emanating from their house. None of my Bluetooth devices, from Bose to Plantronic to new AirPods Pro, survive signal connectivity when I walk past their house. The connection gets very disrupted and the devices have trouble reconnecting. So I have to leave everything off when I go for a run and not connect headphones until I make it to the end of the street. It’s weird.

Old CCTV cameras cause this. They use the whole 2.4 G band and transmit at high power, acting as WiFi and Bluetooth blockers for about 100m around.

If someone tries to use WiFi, it garbles the video feed too.

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#159

There's a particular spot on a local highway that interrupts my wireless CarPlay connection if I spend too long in it (eg when traffic is slow). It's right next to an exit with a bunch of buildings (including a hospital) so I'm sure there is some massive emitter in one of those buildings. I'm still at a loss about what could cause that kind of interference inside a major city and still be legal.

Sounds like Berkeley or North Oakland. :) I have the same issue, I never considered Bluetooth interference.

Re: Ask HN: Does your microwave interfere with Bluetooth? Mine does

#160
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And on the follow-up, "Why use 2.4(5) GHz for microwaves?" Because it happens to be a convenient frequency that water absorbs readily, which is the easiest way of heating up what we'd want to heat with a microwave (read: food). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electromagnetic_absorption_by_... And once we'd polluted the frequency for any stable commercial use, why not use this weird carve-out for a little thing called W…

> " But this would have been the 1950s(?), so I'd assume they empirically determined a balance of functionality + technical feasibility for water, called it a lunch, and went to have five martinis in a practical fashion. " Or maybe they just wanted to revive frozen hamsters more humanely: "I promise this story about microwaves is interesting." by Tom Scott, about scientist James Lovelock - https://www.youtube.com/wat…

Holy shit. That at 101 I should be so blessed as to recall technical specifications from experiments performed decades earlier.

Sadly, it looks like Dr. Lovelock passed away a year after that was recorded, last year in 2022.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Lovelock

HN obit: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32250694

Post reply on HN