Live data from Hacker News

Akiyoshi’s Illusion Pages

ritsumei.ac.jp

11–20 of 65 posts

Re: Akiyoshi’s Illusion Pages

#11

Can these affect your vision (long-term) if you stare at them for too long? I feel like many of these images produce similar effects to the McCollough effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCollough_effect

This is an interesting question and one that we’re possibly just on the leading edge of being able to ask correctly.

The answers are likely to be varied and along multiple axis:

- Do they affect the muscles of the eye, especially the ones that affect the lens

- Do they affect the rods/cones (and do they equally affect people with genetic differences)

- Do they affect the way the signals are sent to the brain

- Do they affect the visual cortex itself

and

- Do they affect the brain’s processing of visual input in some way

In my personal experience, I’d say we’d need to look at someone for a minimum of 3 years, and ideally 5 or more.

Re: Akiyoshi’s Illusion Pages

#12
post #6

I'm very shocked that these were only discovered so recently (Well. If you consider the early 2000's to be "recent". I'd have assumed that we'd have found these out earlier) I suppose that's why they were all the rage in childrens' books and museums around that time.

[deleted]

Re: Akiyoshi’s Illusion Pages

#13

Can these affect your vision (long-term) if you stare at them for too long? I feel like many of these images produce similar effects to the McCollough effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCollough_effect

When I was young (maybe 8 or so?) my mom got me a book of B&W moiré patterns. It consisted of a book of B&W patterns and a clear plastic sheet also with similar patterns. When you overlaid the plastic sheet over the patterns in the book is when you got the moiré patterns.

Besides seeing yellows and other fringe colors appear from the moiré, I always wondered if the patterns were linked to ocular migraines I would have for some decades after.

(Edit: yeah, this book: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/2446119.Optical_Designs_...)

Re: Akiyoshi’s Illusion Pages

#14

Can these affect your vision (long-term) if you stare at them for too long? I feel like many of these images produce similar effects to the McCollough effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCollough_effect

I could imagine that it will change the way you perceive things. There are experiments where people got goggles that switched the left and right eyes and people adjusted after a few days.

Re: Akiyoshi’s Illusion Pages

#16

Can these affect your vision (long-term) if you stare at them for too long? I feel like many of these images produce similar effects to the McCollough effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCollough_effect

I could imagine that it will change the way you perceive things. There are experiments where people got goggles that switched the left and right eyes and people adjusted after a few days.

That's pretty wild.

Re: Akiyoshi’s Illusion Pages

#19

Can these affect your vision (long-term) if you stare at them for too long? I feel like many of these images produce similar effects to the McCollough effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McCollough_effect

I could imagine that it will change the way you perceive things. There are experiments where people got goggles that switched the left and right eyes and people adjusted after a few days.

Or even simple glasses which turn the view upside down. Human eyes were able to adjust itself (or the image) correct way after few hours.

Re: Akiyoshi’s Illusion Pages

#20
post #15

Are there rules for creating these illusions?

Mark Changizi had an interesting insight on how some illusions work [1].

What we see is a reconstruction by the brain interpolated from our sensors. The idea of Mark is that the image is not only an interpolation of the present, but actually also an extrapolation of what the image will be in the next tenth of a second. For tasks such as catching a ball, this would allow us to compensate for the delay of the signal between our brain and our muscles.

Based on this idea, he wrote a classification of many illusions [2].

[1]: https://www.livescience.com/4950-key-optical-illusions-disco...

[2]: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1080/03640210802...

Post reply on HN