Live data from Hacker News

My Public Apology

news.ycombinator.com

111–116 of 116 posts

Re: My Public Apology

#111

-75 comment votes; +125 article points - you are a genius. As to your company, I'd never even heard of it before. There is no such thing as bad publicity.

This is not the type of publicity we want. This will be the first and last time it's caused by something completely in our control.

Re: My Public Apology

#112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I didn't downvote, but I didn't upvote either, for the simple fact that it wasn't funny . To paraphrase the pythons, humor is not the automatic gainsaying of the common sentiment.

I didn't downvote, I didn't upvote, I didn't vote sideways, and I didn't vote for the down-up-vote, etc. because I just don't care. You're thinking: what a jerk! Well, I care as much about this poor soul as I do about any of the other thousands of people who died today. I am a compassionate person, but I have some gripes, so please hear me out. I live in the UK, and for the past several weeks we've had to suffer the…

why didn't you just say that you acknowledge that you have a dark and twisted sense of humour and that you won't apologise for it?

I never apologized for my personality; to do so would have been disingenuous. As some have noted, I never said my opinion on the matter had changed. It just so happens that numerous other people have put that opinion far more eloquently throughout this thread. For that I am thankful.

Re: My Public Apology

#113
post #88

Well done, the 100+ upvotes you've got on this post have totally counteracted the negative votes you got on the other post, and you end the day with a net profit. Goes to show.. when it comes to social networking, any publicity is good publicity!

I think there's more to his apology than that.

Well sure, but it's mathematically amusing that an apology gets more social credit than lost through the faux pas causing that apology, no?

Re: My Public Apology

#114
post #53

I voted up your original comment. I thought it was smart and witty. I think people who voted you down probably regularly vote up witty remarks about the Bush administration or the war in Iraq, and are guilty of extreme hypocrisy. Human beings make fun of everything, including death, pets being run over, wars of occupation, rape, incest, ignorance, stupidy, disease, racism, the holocaust... Perhaps the same crowd woul…

I guess I would agree with you that no subject is off limits, and I can obviously only speak for myself, but there is a reason that I have a knee-jerk negative and perhaps overly zealous reaction to suicide jokes that I don't have to those about most other tragedies. Most people who end up committing suicide talk about it before they do it and they often aren't taken seriously. Because of this, I take a dim view of anything that makes light of suicide.

Wars are awful, but I doubt that many of them could have been prevented by taking the people proposing them more seriously, and the same goes for most other things.

As I said, it's entirely possible I take this view too far, but I figured I'd explain my reason, since it doesn't seem like anyone else has brought up that particular point.

Re: My Public Apology

#115

If there's anything I hate more than petty semi-scandalous incidents on the internets it's the meta discussions about such incidents...

And the comments commenting on the meta discussions on the petty semi-scandalous incidents on the internets.

And the comments commenting on the comments regarding the meta discussions on the petty semi-scandalous incidents on the internets.

Post reply on HN