Live data from Hacker News

AI demand is already shrinking

honest-broker.com

41–50 of 116 posts

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#41

It doesn't help (especially Bing AI) is so restricted, politically correct, moralist, conformist.

Who would have thought that a machine would fail to bend it's computations to human sensitivites. Like someone who doesn't pick up on social queues that has to have all of their responses translated by someone who is overly-compliant.

No corporation can afford to turn AI loose.

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#42

Here, I had chatgpt generate the article so you don't have to read this one linked. # AI: The Overhyped Phenomenon Missing Immediate Results In recent years, there's been no shortage of hyperbolic rhetoric when it comes to Artificial Intelligence (AI). Prophets of the digital age tout it as the solution to virtually all of humanity's problems, from healthcare to climate change. But as we pause to look around, it's pr…

Haha. I love it.

Yes. Because AI hasn't changed the world in six weeks, that clearly shows it will never change the world.

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#43

It really looks like ChatGPT suffered from some form of "initial over hype syndrome". I'm not underestimating it, actually I think the application of transformers to do what ChatGPT is capable of doing is something really impressive, novel and caught the world by surprise. I'm sure we'll find many equally impressively good applications for it. But people eventually found its limitations. And did it quite fast. People…

I had a brief period of thinking it wasn’t as impressive as I thought, but came to realize that it’s still an incredibly useful tool for research and discovery, and occasionally debugging or loosely architecting code. I’m sure for others it has genuinely powerful and useful capabilities.

If you want it to do your job for you though, you’re going to have a disappointing time.

I almost think of it as a helpful method of finding what work I should do. It doesn’t really do any of the labour for me. Like if I want to find research papers about x, it’ll find things really well and make interesting connections between papers I otherwise might not. But I won’t rely on it to condense the papers or surface important details; you really still need to do that legwork. Same with code. It can give broad, loose, useful suggestions, but you really need to write it yourself. That’s fine with me.

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#44
Gartner calls this phase "the trough of disillusionment" - it's just part of the hype cycle. AI is overhyped, like almost every new technology is overhyped. Now people are realizing AI isn't all unicorns and rainbows. However, there are some of us, myself included, who were curious and are discovering what these tools are really good at and where they come up short. AI is a tool, a technology - not magic.

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#45

It's weird to me that some people just don't see the oncoming train. AI is here to stay. Use cases are still being worked out, but it's here to stay. Reminds me of the Astound application around 1995-1996. It was a pretty major PowerPoint competitor and I used it a lot. For whatever reason, they only had a Windows 3.1 version. So I called them asking when the Windows 95 version was coming out. They told me they didn'…

AI has been pervasive for decades. That being true doesn’t mean that the specific flavor of the month will necessarily stick around.

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#46
post #27

The real advantage of LLMs is not search -- that's just something that's easy to show people. No one really wants to talk to an LLM instead of using Google search. The real value is being general reasoning machines. Being able to accomplish basic tasks, retrieve information, etc. is the key value.

The problem is that LLMs aren’t very good at reasoning, needing constant guidance and double-checking.

Statistically likely answers are not necessary the correct ones.

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#47
I would use Bing as my search engine if Microsoft didn't have Bing chat locked to Edge or Chrome.

I use ChatGPT almost every day and use it to work out ideas, improve my writing, or even just for general queries. But the reality is that even though they charge for it it's not a product.

I think these chat bots are fantastic even though they are locked down and often kind of saccharine. I can't wait for this to become an actual product like a smart speaker or computing interface (like the Star Trek computer).

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#48

It's weird to me that some people just don't see the oncoming train. AI is here to stay. Use cases are still being worked out, but it's here to stay. Reminds me of the Astound application around 1995-1996. It was a pretty major PowerPoint competitor and I used it a lot. For whatever reason, they only had a Windows 3.1 version. So I called them asking when the Windows 95 version was coming out. They told me they didn'…

Funny, because AI has seen plenty of applications before ChatGPT, yet "the oncoming train" in most peoples heads is "this is going to completely replace artists, programmers, etc"

This is what is laughable, and has been from the very beginning. Will we _continue_ to use AI to try and find novel drug treatments? Yes. Will chatbots still be the first thing a customer support flow uses (and will it still suck)? Yes.

Re: AI demand is already shrinking

#50
It would make perfect sense to me if the "demand" is more of "excitement about the idea" than "desire to make this into a long-term product." I think the actual introduction of these technologies into our lives is going to be a lot slower and more constrained.

Every business would love to get rid of customer service agents and replace them with AI, for example. But no business wants to take a CS agent with an 85% accuracy/successful call record and replace it with an AI that's at 40-50%, because the liability would just be too high. Those numbers and that situation is made up, but I think it's going to be that way in lots of industries and situations for now. Adoption will lag the technology, as with most things.

Post reply on HN