Live data from Hacker News

Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

michael.stapelberg.ch

71–80 of 470 posts

Re: Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

#71

Great review. Are you returning the monitor? Also, have you kept the Kinesis 360 keyboard and did you get used to the plam pads? Personally, I'm using the palm pads of the Advantage 2.

Yeah, I’m returning it.

I kept the 360, but am currently using the Advantage 2 again. I never got used to the 360 palm pads.

Re: Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

#72
post #33

Although I haven’t used these monitors, my experience with high dpi on windows and Linux has been a nightmare compared to OSX. It’s surprising me the non Mac world hasn’t made this a bigger priority.

Modern Linux DPI support is a nightmare. It's a shame, since if you just run and old-school software stack (X11; minimal window manager; xrandr to adjust DPI if you hotplug a monitor), then it has much nicer font rendering than Mac OS. This is particularly frustrating since I've been using high DPI displays since the CRT days. Everything horribly regressed about a decade ago, and still isn't back to 1999 standards.

IDK, high DPI worked fine for me under Linux. I just set the desired DPI in Xfce settings, and everything scales properly. (Except Firefox, which has its own DPI setting! But it works equally painlessly.)

Where things go haywire is mixed resolution. It's best avoided :-\ Hence now I have a 28" 4k external screen which is exactly like four 14" FHD screens of my laptop, so the DPI stays strictly the same.

Re: Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

#73
post #71

Great review. Are you returning the monitor? Also, have you kept the Kinesis 360 keyboard and did you get used to the plam pads? Personally, I'm using the palm pads of the Advantage 2.

Yeah, I’m returning it. I kept the 360, but am currently using the Advantage 2 again. I never got used to the 360 palm pads.

Funnily, I was trying to buy the monitor as well last Friday in Austria, but was informed that the inventory nr on the website was wrong - so my order was cancelled. After your review, I guess I'll be waiting for the Samsung ViewFinity S9 (5k).

Re Kinesis: I have mixed feelings as well but in the meantime I got used to the 360 model. With the old palm pads, it feels more like the Advantage 2. I'm a bit sad that I didn't order the pro model. I really liked my Advantage 2 as well, but I can't go back to it as some electronic part seems to be damaged. It just seems to send random characters without touching the keyboard.

Re: Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

#74
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's been pretty amazing how stagnant the monitor space is. I too am really craving an 8k@120 monitor, although there's a decent chance I'll balk at the price.

It’s crazy how much of a regression there was in resolution and picture quality when we went from CRT to LCD displays. In the late 90’s you could get a CRT that did 2048x1536 no sweat with great color and decent refresh rate. Then suddenly LCD displays became the standard and they looked awful. Low resolutions, terrible colors and bad viewing angles. The only real advantage they had was size. It took a decade or so t…

How much did a 2048x1536 CRT monitor cost though? That's usually high and I bet it probably priced similar to what a 6K or 8K monitor is today.

Re: Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not for tmux + firefox

Unless people are far more sensitive than I am, I don't see how >60Hz is needed for a desktop workstation environment. High frame rate is really only noticeable for very fast reaction time gaming. 4K 120Hz may be noticeable if editing ultra high frame rate video on a video editing workstation, but if you are a video production crew with a camera capable of recording at that framerate, you probably already know that.

When I throw my iPhone into low power mode and it drops to a 60FPS cap, it is immediately noticeable.

Re: Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

#76

Friends dont let friends buy Dell monitors.

What's the issue with Dell monitors? I'm still using my Dell P2715Q (4k) from > 5 years ago every day and the only reason that would make me switch is that it doesn't support the latest HDMI connections any more.

Re: Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

#79
post #6

Slightly off topic but I can’t wait until there’s a 120 Hz 8K monitor. It’s the only thing holding me back from upgrading from 4K. I wonder if the current limitation is on the panels, cable bandwidth or absurd price tag…

8k@120Hz is going to need one heck of a video card

Not in text mode. Hercules FTW

Re: Can Dell’s 6K monitor beat their 8K monitor?

#80
post #51
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What is your actual use case apart from technology fetishism?

I guess you could look at the use-cases for 120Hz displays on MacBook Pros. It's useful for smoother scrolling amongst other things. I'd like a display that has parity to my laptop but is just bigger so I can fit more on it.

MBP's 120hz display is a lifesaver for me.

Previously, I actually often felt motion sickness when scrolling through code on small 60hz laptop screens. Had no problems with larger (> 23") desktop screens, though.

Post reply on HN