Live data from Hacker News

Twitter now requires an account to view tweets

techcrunch.com

71–80 of 1001 posts

Re: Twitter now requires an account to view tweets

#71

Putting the internet in the hands of corporations was the worst thing that ever happened to technology

What in the heck are you even talking about? The internet would be nothing without tech companies.

At university I was using JANET, and in some ways it was better than what we have now.

I don't think they'd have ever bothered inventing privacy violating trackers A/B testing (though if I'm wrong this is the best place to assert wildly and be quickly corrected).

Re: Twitter now requires an account to view tweets

#74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why the hell are government agencies using Twitter/Facebook for official communication in the first place? At the very least if these sites are being used for official communication that might be critical to peoples safety some sort of privileged status or ToS should be negotiated. Can you imagine Musk banning some random non-USA government agency because he had a fit while high at 3 am? Also: https://xkcd.com/743/

Musk has been deferential to governments to date, even when that flies in the face of his idea of a free speech platform.

> Musk has been deferential to governments to date, even when that flies in the face of his idea of a free speech platform.

It’s a business. Free speech is the brand.

Re: Twitter now requires an account to view tweets

#75
post #47

Putting the internet in the hands of corporations was the worst thing that ever happened to technology

The internet was conceived as a democratic haven, a realm where every individual had the potential to influence and shape their digital experience. However, a pervasive dip in technological literacy and a rising dependency on heavily-guided online pathways has begun to shift this balance. If this trend persists, corporations will continue to maintain their overarching dominion. A dynamic, user-driven community still…

> The internet was conceived as a democratic haven, a realm where every individual had the potential to influence and shape their digital experience.

I have a hard time reconciling this perspective with history. Were any of these ideals present among the people/organizations responsible for the internet and the Web at the time that they were being developed? Or is sentiment like yours something that people adopted later on?

Re: Twitter now requires an account to view tweets

#76
Paul Graham famously started to use Mastodon (but has not written anything there since last year). But the HN Status emergency “is HN down” channel is still only on Twitter. It used to be publicly readable at https://twitter.com/HNStatus>. But now, if HN was to go down, only logged-in Twitter users would be able to see why.

Re: Twitter now requires an account to view tweets

#78

You can blame this all you want on evil social media corporations, but the reality is AI companies scraping public conversations to feed LLMs are the current reason for walls being erected around every single garden. Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Reddit, LinkedIn.. all heading toward full walled garden mode to prevent scrapers from repurposing data and profiting off their systems. Federated systems are a nice idea, b…

AI companies is a stupid argument. If the AI company operates legitimately, then TOS prohibiting using the content for LLM training purposes would be enough. If the AI company doesn’t want to play ball then restricting public access won’t stop them, they’ll just register accounts en-masse and scrape that way.

Re: Twitter now requires an account to view tweets

#79
I’m not active on social media for the most part, and have to remind people not to send me links to sites that require a login (Pinterest for example). I don’t have a Twitter account, but there were accounts I liked to browse occasionally. In the months before the Musk takeover, Twitter kept coming up with new things that you couldn’t do without logging in. Finally, it was completely unusable. One of the earlier easy wins Musk made was undoing all of that. Now, on top of everything else he’s managed to spectacularly torpedo, we’re back to this.

Re: Twitter now requires an account to view tweets

#80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why the hell are government agencies using Twitter/Facebook for official communication in the first place? At the very least if these sites are being used for official communication that might be critical to peoples safety some sort of privileged status or ToS should be negotiated. Can you imagine Musk banning some random non-USA government agency because he had a fit while high at 3 am? Also: https://xkcd.com/743/

> Why the hell are government agencies using Twitter/Facebook for official communication in the first place? Reach. IDK if anyone is using it as the sole method of communication. But Twitter in practice has a much higher reach than every other method.

I've definitely seen critical info communicated either only on Twitter, or first on Twitter and only much later elsewhere. Not sure if it was alerts ("chemical plant on fire, close windows") or crisis communication ("emergency water supplies being distributed at Foo street"), but it was a case of "use Twitter or suffer serious consequences".

Stuff like "public transit line 17 out of service" being announced only on Twitter is completely par for the course.

Post reply on HN