Live data from Hacker News

Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

theregister.com

751–760 of 778 posts

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#751

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Working in the AV space, it's really frustrating how confidently people who have no idea about what's hard and what isn't go off about Tesla right now. Mercedes has soundly beaten the last decade of Tesla efforts by reaching L3. I've personally watched FSD go off the rails and into a crash situation within 60 seconds of being turned on three times this month (I have a friend who loves to try it in San Francisco) Had…

This FUD is insane. You make it sounds like Tesla's with FSD on are crashing all the time. This makes no sense at all, because... they aren't?

An there are no official investigations into Tesla crashes either?

https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2022/INOA-EA22002-3184.PDF

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#752
post #397

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure what the track record for FSD is so far but Autopilot's isn't great and inspires little confidence: https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/06/10/tesla-a... 17 fatalities, 736 crashes.

Those are crashes WITH, not crashes BECAUSE. Without knowing the usual amount of no fault crashes given the number of driving miles the number is meaningless

If anything, Tesla was found to be deactivating the autopilot mode at the second before a crash [1], embellishing the statistics of miles driven between crashes...

[1] PDF https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2022/INOA-EA22002-3184.PDF

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#753
post #499

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> What do we want from self driving cars? Nothing. Absolutely nothing. I want public transportation infrastructure and far, far, FAR fewer cars. I think the US should strive to reduce car ownership by 75% over the next 20 years, at least in cities over a certain population size. I don't want any more money invested in self-driving cars. But I'm also a grown-up of a certain age and realize the bright-eyed 20-something…

This ship sailed like 60 years ago (blame your parents, speaking of consequences). At this point, autonomous driving is the best we can do in places like Los Angeles or San Diego.

You should look at Dutch cities, for example Utrecht got rid of a huge chunk of hideous highway in the center of the city and in its stead is now a beautiful canal with one the busiest bike-traffic streets in all of Europe.

https://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2016/01/05/motorway-remov...

Yanks could do the same if they wanted to, but unfortunately they've been brainwashed into thinking walking is the devil

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#754
post #2

"Slow and steady" better than "move fast and break things"? :-)

40k+ people die per year in car accidents in the US alone. I would say "move fast and break less things" is better.

You're fooling yourself to think that Tesla is the solution. First, most of the fatalities are in cars that cost much much less than Tesla. Their owners will never afford a Tesla. Second, the only realistic way to prevent some of these deaths is to empower public transport, the way it's done in Europe. Third, although that's the least important point, Tesla statistics of miles driven between crashes are biased, because they turn off autopilot before crashes [1].

Please be careful not to conflate the goals of capitalism with the goals of technology and science.

[1] PDF https://static.nhtsa.gov/odi/inv/2022/INOA-EA22002-3184.PDF

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#755

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because it's a party trick that requires a vehicle in front for tracking and can only be used under 40 mph on the highway. It's a joke. I can do the same thing. Why can Tesla offer FSD beta which can drive around on any roads while Mercedes can't?

It is not a party trick. It literally allows you to do anything while stuck in traffic, which is definitely not a rare occurrence. Meanwhile Tesla's FSD beta doesn't allow me anything I can't do with another car, as I still need to pay the same amount of attention and hold the same liability. Mercedes could offer a similar service, but won't as their assistants already offer a similar experience without the dangers o…

You've got that exactly backwards buddy. Tesla could easily offer the same thing, but why would they waste time with that BS? Mercedes 100% cannot offer full self driving on any street. What world are you living in?

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#756
post #754

Earlier quoted context omitted.

40k+ people die per year in car accidents in the US alone. I would say "move fast and break less things" is better.

You're fooling yourself to think that Tesla is the solution. First, most of the fatalities are in cars that cost much much less than Tesla. Their owners will never afford a Tesla. Second, the only realistic way to prevent some of these deaths is to empower public transport, the way it's done in Europe. Third, although that's the least important point, Tesla statistics of miles driven between crashes are biased, becau…

> Second, the only realistic way to prevent some of these deaths is to empower public transport

I'm the one fooling myself?

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#757
post #754

Earlier quoted context omitted.

40k+ people die per year in car accidents in the US alone. I would say "move fast and break less things" is better.

You're fooling yourself to think that Tesla is the solution. First, most of the fatalities are in cars that cost much much less than Tesla. Their owners will never afford a Tesla. Second, the only realistic way to prevent some of these deaths is to empower public transport, the way it's done in Europe. Third, although that's the least important point, Tesla statistics of miles driven between crashes are biased, becau…

> Second, the only realistic way to prevent some of these deaths is to empower public transport

I'm the one fooling myself? That's in no way realistic

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#758
post #23
post #6

"Conditionally automated driving: Mercedes-Benz DRIVE PILOT further expands U.S. availability to the country’s" - https://media.mercedes-benz.com/article/81a29ac5-4d02-4b58-b... ”Mercedes-Benz DRIVE PILOT is the world's only SAE Level 3 system with internationally valid type approval. It builds on a very robust foundation, setting new industry standards. DRIVE PILOT uses a highly sophisticated vehicle architecture ba…

It's also worth pointing out that this is an extremely limited system: > On suitable freeway sections and where there is high traffic density, DRIVE PILOT can offer to take over the dynamic driving task, up to speeds of 40 mph. Basically, this will follow the car in front of you in slow freeway traffic. It won't navigate, it won't even change lanes. It won't work (and it's not clear to me how it disengages) when traf…

„Beating“ depends on the perspective. German engineering and marketing approaches are most certainly more conservative, which is important in certain technological advancements such as driving assistance / self-driving.

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#759

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I would appreciate "automated rumble strips" that warns me gently if I veer out of my lane. Lane departure warning systems do exactly that. My mazda does this and basically between smart cruise, lane departure warnings, and big old alarms when someone in front of me suddenly hits the break, driving is SO MUCH MENTALLY EASIER. And don't get me started about blindspot alerts and HUDs oh man so amaze. I still think Le…

I rented a car with that kind of assistance yesterday and I found it annoying that the steering wheel give you some resistance when you want to go back to the main lane after overtaking a car on the opposite one!

You need to use turn signals. Using those the algos know what line crossings to expect. My dad went through this because it forced him to start signalling. This is also probably why I'm seen more and more BMWs use turn signals... maybe it wasn't faulty turn signal wiring after all (/s)

Re: Mercedes beats Tesla to autonomous driving in California

#760

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I were Tesla why would I take responsibility for something no one is forcing me to take responsibility for? Lawmakers are responsible for this charade and its embarrassing to me that a company can be so misleading with marketing and get away with it.

I wouldn't do any business with you for example if that is your default level of ethics.

It's not about me. This is exactly what Tesla is doing and for some reason no one seems to care and continues to hand Tesla money for subpar quality cars with fake FSD. I don't get it.
Post reply on HN