Live data from Hacker News

Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

eff.org

71–80 of 162 posts

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#71

When I go to https://google.com/history while logged into my google mail account, I get redirected to https://www.google.com/ The redirected Google home page clearly shows me as logged in. Am I doing it wrong?

Likewise for me with the Google Apps account I'm usually signed in as when doing searches.

Going to the non-SSL page http://google.com/history (as suggested by someone here) doesn't result in the redirect, but gives the message "Web History is not available for mydomain.com."

As usual, it seems that Google Apps users are in a different (lower) class when it comes to Google functionality.

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#72

When somebody's life is horribly dismembered as a result of Google's insane privacy policy (new or old), please let me know. I'll start thinking about privacy and necessary safety measures at that point. Until then, please stop whining about privacy, because frankly, I just don't see how any of this really matters. My life has yet to be negatively impacted by Google and I don't foresee it happening in the near future…

When people draw your profile to sell you things it is just plain manipulation. I don't know about you, but I don't like it. Have you read this article, it is quite convincing.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2012/02/16/how-targe...

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#73
post #4

The official title of the article is "How to Remove Your Google Search History Before Google's New Privacy Policy Takes Effect", and the writing itself is much more neutral than this submission title. I'm still not sure why people are afraid of Google's new privacy policy. I understand that there are people who have specific privacy needs, but outside that scope I doubt you have anything to worry about. It's doubtful…

My rationale behind this is one of "I trust you but not your boss" or "I trust you today but I don't know if I can trust you tomorrow". I use this in telemarketing calls or whenever someone asks me for more information than they actually need.

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#74
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It sounds good in concept, but I'm concerned that somebody searching for child pornography or similar could be associated with myself. I have the same fear of running a TOR exit node.

It gives you plausible deniability, which is the point. Nobody can prove you really did those searches (though you can't prove the converse either).

It might give you plausible deniability in front of a jury (emphasis on might), but that says nothing about assumptions or biases made by law enforcement officials or prosecutors.

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#75
post #4

The official title of the article is "How to Remove Your Google Search History Before Google's New Privacy Policy Takes Effect", and the writing itself is much more neutral than this submission title. I'm still not sure why people are afraid of Google's new privacy policy. I understand that there are people who have specific privacy needs, but outside that scope I doubt you have anything to worry about. It's doubtful…

> The official title of the article is "How to Remove Your Google Search History Before Google's New Privacy Policy Takes Effect", and the writing itself is much more neutral than this submission title.

The submitter just removed the "How to" crud from the title! :)

If that encroaches too much on your ability to neutrally assess a topic title, well, this ain't gonna be your century.

> It's doubtful at best that Google's "log" of you would become compromised (unless your personal account were compromised, but then this would have been a problem anyways!). It also isn't the case that some Google employee is reading row after row of Google's customer DB snooping on individuals.

Both of these cases have happened in the past.

Personal accounts have been compromised. That this sucks for other reasons doesn't make it less of a problem--labelling your house keys with your home address is still a stupid idea, regardless of whether losing your house keys "would have been a problem anyways!".

Google employees have been snooping on individuals (minors, even) in Google's customer DB. They were fired on the spot, but afaik no legal charges were pressed.

So basically you just told yourself a pretty lie, writing what you want to believe, not the way things actually are. How can you speak of neutral writing?

And then there's of course the government requests:

http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/governmentrequests/

See, on one hand I can see your point. IF all my data would forever remain under the sole control of Google AND will only ever be used in the ways they tell us it is used now THEN yes I concede there is little practical concerns to be worried about.

But if you believe those two requirements are met today and will remain so as long as Google possesses relevant data about yourself, you are deluding yourself.

The data is already being given to the US government and maybe others too.

Data leaks are not going to get less, and exploits will not stop to be found, and at some point it'll be Google's turn.

Finally there's the possibility that Google will have a change of "mind" and either turn evil, sell their data, starts doing less conscionable types of data mining, or maybe simply becomes utterly lax in protecting your data. It's a risk.

Combine all those risks and it'd be pretty naive to just ignore the facts and hope for the best.

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#76
post #53

Is there a way to export the search history? I have close to 45k searches over 7 years, would love to keep that data and mine it myself.

You can export it as a feed: http://www.google.com/history/lookup?q=&output=rss&n...

Thanks, it's only exporting 922 searches for me.

Increasing the num=100000 argument doesn't seem to impact this limit.

One would think that your search history should be a core part of their data liberation effort.

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#77
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can export it as a feed: http://www.google.com/history/lookup?q=&output=rss&n...

Thanks, it's only exporting 922 searches for me. Increasing the num=100000 argument doesn't seem to impact this limit. One would think that your search history should be a core part of their data liberation effort.

You can specify the date to export, so could step back exporting batches until you've got everything.

https://www.google.com/history/lookup?month=11&day=30&#3...

It shouldn't be too hard to write a script to scrape you're whole history...

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#78
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My concern is that someone out there is accumulating a huge amount of very personal information about me. It happens to be a corporation that has a legal obligation not to me but to its shareholders and that obligation is to maximise profit. It also has a legal obligation to the US government and the US courts, a government I have no right to elect and a legal system I cannot afford. And here's my point: I simply can…

> It happens to be a corporation that has a legal obligation not to me but to its shareholders and that obligation is to maximise profit. That's a myth. I belived it was true until someone here on HN linked to a Harvard Business Review article debunking it. Unfortunately I can't find the article, but here's a blog post discussing the issue: http://truthonthemarket.com/2010/07/27/the-shareholder-wealt...

This article is all about errors that a management team could make, but I'm talking about their intentions. Google's management team cannot intentionally pursue goals that are bad for shareholders.

I doubt that it would be legal to do so, but I'm not a lawyer, so suffice it to say that it's not practical because they would be removed from their management positions very quickly.

Re: Remove Google Search History Before New Privacy Policy Takes Effect

#80
post #44

youtube.com doesn't have any obvious method of removing of past watched videos and is even more nefarious than Google will probably ever be (before March 1st, 2012 at least) about tracking visitors. Additionally, YouTube has become pretty much just a branch of the RIAA and MPAA and their local equivalents, and I'd rather burn down my house than allow them access to my data. That's why I've been blocking YouTube from…

http://www.youtube.com/my_history

http://www.youtube.com/my_search_history

I am not saying that the average user knows about them, though, but they're not that hard to find.

(Also, since you seem to talk about YouTube and Google as separate companies: They're not. Google owns YouTube and their new policy applies there as well.)

Post reply on HN