Live data from Hacker News

Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

cbc.ca

81–90 of 145 posts

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A similar law was passed in Venezuela in ~2005. It forced radio stations to play traditional Venezuelan music as a percent of all their airtime. From the only article I could find in english [0]: > The law can make listening to the radio an adventure in dizzying contrasts. One minute a disc jockey is playing American rap, and the next minute it’s flutes and fiddles from the Andean highlands. It pushed some local arti…

> It pushed some local artist to get creative and come out with some electronic traditional music, which frakly, sucked You gotta start somewhere. I lived through a similar transition in a different country, I hated the law at the time for the same reasons. However, it lit a fire under the local music industry which now supports more artistes than before. The music now sucks much less, and the local subgenres are uni…

>> You gotta start somewhere

Such a strange concept. People like songs from "Region A" but we in "Region B" and want people to like songs from our own region. We do this by restricting access to "Region A"'s songs, not by making better songs in "Region B".

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#82
post #47

The French speaking part of Canada of which I am a part of generally view this legislation positively since it does mean more money for culture in French. Money that currently goes toward English content. Now if we could actually produce quality shows it would be great (right now its like 90% bad soap/romcom/cop shows), otherwise the younger generations (me included) will just continue to watch US English content. If…

There is good content that is being produced in Quebec, you just have to look out for it and not expect Hollywood quality production. Xavier Dolan, Denis Villeneuve and Jean-Marc Vallée (rip), Monia Chokri and more, all started their career in Quebec thanks to legislation around creating French content.

The "90% bad TV" also happens everywhere, especially in the US. The number of CSI spinoffs must be really high.

One of the dangers from YouTube/streaming platforms in regard to French Canadian content is that the economics is just not the same. For example, Linus Tech Tips have a global reach since it's English content. M. Net (now defunct tech show in Quebec) or something similar would not even be closed to compete monetarily.

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#83

As a Canadian, I am of two minds about it. FM radio is required to broadcast Canadian produced or performed music at least for 35% of the time. There are not too many, in absolute numbers, songs that are both Canadian and popular which results in few songs being broadcast to death. At least that was the case when I used to listen to FM radio. On the other hand, that legislation certainly helped Canadian artists.

>> FM radio is required to broadcast

So, how does this work on Spotify? Am I now required to listen to Nickelback?

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#84
post #76
post #73

I both want diverse cultures to flourish & be celebrated but wow, this is not the way. Bossing around entities on the internet to give special treatment to your niche causes is the new thing, is what everyone all of a sudden is giving themselves laws to do. It just has such limits, pushing other people around to give yourself favor. How is the internet supposed to keep on, when every nation demands their pound of fle…

> Bossing around entities on the internet to give special treatment to your niche causes is the new thing, is what everyone all of a sudden is giving themselves laws to do. In Canada the only unique thing here is the “on the Internet” component of your sentence. Canada has been bullying business of all sorts into all sorts of things under the guise of “culture” for decades. Apparently our culture is so weak that it c…

> Apparently our culture is so weak that it can’t stand up on its own and needs the entire edifice of government to prop it up.

It's interesting to me that I live reasonably close to the Canadian border on the US side and yet literally the only Canadian media I know of is Trailer Park Boys / Letterkenny.

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And 100% garbage! (Not because it's Canadian, because it's on radio)

I make no apologies for being a fan of The Weeknd. And Carly Rae Jepsen.

And I make no apologies for having never heard of either of them! Just not interested in music that's made from the ground up just to stick in people heads for a few days, personally. The art is gone, they follow a pretty basic formula. And they usually don't even write their own music except for the lyrics. And if you're lucky you might even get to hear their actual voice!

Might as well just listen to generative music at that point. At least that will have interesting moments in it when it enters the uncanny valley.

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#86
post #73

I both want diverse cultures to flourish & be celebrated but wow, this is not the way. Bossing around entities on the internet to give special treatment to your niche causes is the new thing, is what everyone all of a sudden is giving themselves laws to do. It just has such limits, pushing other people around to give yourself favor. How is the internet supposed to keep on, when every nation demands their pound of fle…

It’s astounding to me that the bulk of replies in this thread are supportive. Yay big government! Yay Brave New World!

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm assuming your not canadian. Canadian content is a tax we (canadians) all pay, being forced to wade through a sea of government approved crap to actually watch a good show. It benefits some small elite class of people, it's not for "difficult" Canadian customers.

I'm Canadian, and I like CanCon rules. While this new law has major flaws, I still view it as a net positive.

I'm Canadian and view it as a net negative.

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#89
post #73

I both want diverse cultures to flourish & be celebrated but wow, this is not the way. Bossing around entities on the internet to give special treatment to your niche causes is the new thing, is what everyone all of a sudden is giving themselves laws to do. It just has such limits, pushing other people around to give yourself favor. How is the internet supposed to keep on, when every nation demands their pound of fle…

It’s astounding to me that the bulk of replies in this thread are supportive. Yay big government! Yay Brave New World!

It's easy to understand when most popular streaming services here are foreign owned and have created a terrible image for themselves by producing barely any tax revenue for the country.

Re: Controversial bill to regulate online streaming becomes law in Canada

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is already the case, but it's not based by location but by languages. Spanish-speaking internet is vastly different from the English-speaking one, and so is the internet for Chinese, Russian, French, Portuguese speaking population. Every major language have their own corner of the internet. Anyone who is bilingual can tell you the same :)

Mr. Beast was the first YouTuber to really recognize this and pays to have people dub and subtitle his videos into other languages. His media empire has become absolutely massive.

Is he uploading videos to other websites than YouTube? Otherwise it's kind of missing the point. If you want to reach ordinary Russians (not biased by English-speaking ones), you probably want to upload videos to RUTUBE and vk, not just YouTube, as Russian-speaking folks use other websites than just YouTube.
Post reply on HN