Live data from Hacker News

Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

arstechnica.com

11–20 of 32 posts

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#11
They're being forced to do it.

The natural market for EVs is a maximum of 20%. The cost/benefit is only positive for certain use cases.

Ford can't sell its Lightning F150 EVs. They just had a fire on one of the holding lots too that burned a bunch of them down. I guess they'll have to take the insurance.

Fun fact about EV fires: they're a chemical reaction, not an ordinary fire. Removing the oxygen source like you would with an ICE fire doesn't work.

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#12
post #8

https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/us-reaches-15-billion-settlem... Likely being forced to, a reminder this is the same company that deliberately and consistently cheated on emissions tests in the USA.

It's still a net positive that they're doing this.

Unless this is cover for something else. Unless this is just greenwashing. Unless this project pulls money in that would otherwise have gone to more effective projects. Commercial EV charge points are great but the low hanging fruit remains the vast numbers of private vehicles not currently served by charging schemes. Those people are basically everyone who doesn't own a house with a garage where they can install the bespoke charger for their particular EV.

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#13
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> long-haul electric trucking I wonder, does it even make sense? Long-haul (electric of course) rail + short to medium haul trucking make more sense - it would be much more efficient. Do long haul electric truck even make sense? Don't the batteries needed weigh too much?

It’s an engineering challenge, but doable as you get about a ton of extra weight for EVs. The main mental miscalculation I think people make when they say “why not just trains” is ignoring that rail is a super conservative industry, at least in the US, and in the case of passenger rail (not on existing tracks) that building out new rail infrastructure is super expensive, particularly for HSR where rights of way have…

It makes perfect sense. Roads let people take a variety of vehicles and loads anywhere they want. Rail needs specific drivers who can strike, construction and maintenance people same, and a load of land and planning and budget to add any addition destination.

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#14
post #11

They're being forced to do it. The natural market for EVs is a maximum of 20%. The cost/benefit is only positive for certain use cases. Ford can't sell its Lightning F150 EVs. They just had a fire on one of the holding lots too that burned a bunch of them down. I guess they'll have to take the insurance. Fun fact about EV fires: they're a chemical reaction, not an ordinary fire. Removing the oxygen source like you wo…

Do people normally remove the oxygen source with ICE fires? Wouldn't that be...the atmosphere?

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#15
post #11

They're being forced to do it. The natural market for EVs is a maximum of 20%. The cost/benefit is only positive for certain use cases. Ford can't sell its Lightning F150 EVs. They just had a fire on one of the holding lots too that burned a bunch of them down. I guess they'll have to take the insurance. Fun fact about EV fires: they're a chemical reaction, not an ordinary fire. Removing the oxygen source like you wo…

> Fun fact about EV fires: they're a chemical reaction, not an ordinary fire.

Aren't all ordinary fires a chemical reaction?

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#16
post #11

They're being forced to do it. The natural market for EVs is a maximum of 20%. The cost/benefit is only positive for certain use cases. Ford can't sell its Lightning F150 EVs. They just had a fire on one of the holding lots too that burned a bunch of them down. I guess they'll have to take the insurance. Fun fact about EV fires: they're a chemical reaction, not an ordinary fire. Removing the oxygen source like you wo…

Do people normally remove the oxygen source with ICE fires? Wouldn't that be...the atmosphere?

The problem is the battery has everything it needs to burn already inside its chemistry. It doesn't need the atmosphere to supply oxygen.

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#17
post #11

They're being forced to do it. The natural market for EVs is a maximum of 20%. The cost/benefit is only positive for certain use cases. Ford can't sell its Lightning F150 EVs. They just had a fire on one of the holding lots too that burned a bunch of them down. I guess they'll have to take the insurance. Fun fact about EV fires: they're a chemical reaction, not an ordinary fire. Removing the oxygen source like you wo…

Do people normally remove the oxygen source with ICE fires? Wouldn't that be...the atmosphere?

When a lithium-ion battery catches fire, it can be very hard to extinguish and can burn very fiercely³. If a battery is going to catch fire, the likely cause is thermal runaway¹. This is when a battery experiences an increase in temperature that eventually leads to cell short-circuiting or disintegration that can spark a fire¹. There are three main abuse factors that can send a battery into thermal runaway — mechanical, thermal or electrical¹. The contents of the battery are under pressure, so if a metal fragment punctures a partition that keeps the components separate or the battery is punctured, the lithium reacts with water in the air vigorously, generating high heat and sometimes producing a fire².

(1) What are the lithium-ion-battery fire risks & safety issues?. https://cosmosmagazine.com/technology/battery-fire-lithium-i.... (2) Just how concerned should the solar industry be about battery fires?. https://www.solarpowerworldonline.com/2020/02/just-how-conce.... (3) Why Lithium Batteries Catch Fire - ThoughtCo. https://www.thoughtco.com/why-lithium-batteries-catch-fire-6.... (4) Can Batteries Catch On Fire? Do They Ever Explode? - Firefighter Insider. https://firefighterinsider.com/batteries-catch-fire-or-explo.... (5) Lithium Battery Fires: How to Spot the Warning Signs. https://www.erieinsurance.com/blog/lithium-battery-fires.

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#18
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's still a net positive that they're doing this.

Unless this is cover for something else. Unless this is just greenwashing. Unless this project pulls money in that would otherwise have gone to more effective projects. Commercial EV charge points are great but the low hanging fruit remains the vast numbers of private vehicles not currently served by charging schemes. Those people are basically everyone who doesn't own a house with a garage where they can install the…

> the bespoke charger for their particular EV.

What EVs would they be. At least in Europe all new EVs use CCS and most of the older ones used Type-2. They can all be charged from an ordinary 230 V, 10 A domestic supply; Schuko in Europe or BS1363 in the UK (and Ireland?).

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#19
post #15
post #11

They're being forced to do it. The natural market for EVs is a maximum of 20%. The cost/benefit is only positive for certain use cases. Ford can't sell its Lightning F150 EVs. They just had a fire on one of the holding lots too that burned a bunch of them down. I guess they'll have to take the insurance. Fun fact about EV fires: they're a chemical reaction, not an ordinary fire. Removing the oxygen source like you wo…

> Fun fact about EV fires: they're a chemical reaction, not an ordinary fire. Aren't all ordinary fires a chemical reaction?

A chemical is a compound that has been purposefully refined or purified.

A chemical fire is far more complex and potentially dangerous than a normal fire.

Gasoline is a chemical, however we have a lot of experience dealing with gasoline driven fires and they can be easily doused with water. Large battery driven fires in vehicles are a new thing, and they are not easily doused with water.

Re: Daimler is setting up a $650M charging network for commercial EVs

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless this is cover for something else. Unless this is just greenwashing. Unless this project pulls money in that would otherwise have gone to more effective projects. Commercial EV charge points are great but the low hanging fruit remains the vast numbers of private vehicles not currently served by charging schemes. Those people are basically everyone who doesn't own a house with a garage where they can install the…

> the bespoke charger for their particular EV. What EVs would they be. At least in Europe all new EVs use CCS and most of the older ones used Type-2. They can all be charged from an ordinary 230 V, 10 A domestic supply; Schuko in Europe or BS1363 in the UK (and Ireland?).

Electric trucks have huge batteries and will need super-fast chargers to "refuel" on the road, you can't just plug them into an ordinary outlet. (Well, I guess you can, you just literally won't get anywhere.)

The good news is that there's an emerging standard for this, so hopefully Daimler adopts it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megawatt_Charging_System

Post reply on HN