Live data from Hacker News

Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

nytimes.com

51–60 of 160 posts

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#51
post #37
post #31

So where is the ad spend going instead?

Possibly nowhere. Advertisers reduce ad-spend when recessions are in the air.

There's also a shift away from products to services, but I'm not sure how different those ads yield for Google. I assume ecommerce does better because it's easier to track conversions.

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#53
post #27
post #3

Earlier today I was watching a legaleagle video about Alex Jones' argument that he has to keep pitching dietary supplements to pay his civil debts. YouTube interrupted this video to play an ad for... dietary supplements. Great work. I'm sure Alphabet will be fine.

And your point is?

> I'm sure Alphabet will be fine.

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#54
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am with you here. It is baffling to me how there are people using the internet without an adblocker on every device!

almost every website has a paywall now that detects adblockers and nags you. the number of distinct websites I regularly visit has dwindled drastically. If Im not on reddit/HN or reading documentation, I pretty much stick to the few sites I have subscriptions to.

[deleted]

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#55

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

If I don’t like a company but have to visit their site, I’ll click on their Google ad that often appears and cost them the $1. Particularly if I’m using my work machine

But what do you do if you also don’t like google?

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#56

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

The only times I click on them are by accident. Sometimes they get through my multi layered ad defense.

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#57

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

I was in Google Ads 2008-10, and people from outside the company always said, "Oh, I never click on ads!"

To which I responded, "Well, someone does, or we wouldn't have all this free food."

There's a simple test of your hypothesis, which they can do easily inside Google but it's harder to do from outside: has CTR gone down over the years?

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#58
post #39

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

I can recommend the book “Attention Merchants” by Tim Wu. People get used to Ads in any format over time like you noticed. But the fight for our attention will never stop. So in Google’s case, maybe their model won’t work in the future. The ad money will go somewhere else.

Are people getting used to native advertising though? It seems prolific to me but I still just hear people brag about how advertising doesn't affect them because they don't click on things. People are used to basic advertising (billboards, commercials, and web page images) but I don't think people are used to other types of advertising. I also don't think people understand how all the basic advertising works. For example, many car commercials aren't always trying to get you to buy a car but rather build brand prestige. These types of ads have existed for quite a long time but I don't think people acclimated to them because they still misunderstand how ads work (or rather the diversity in purposes of ads).

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#59

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

I am tech savvy and run ad blockers on all my devices. However I consume Instagram through an app, and can’t be arsed setting up an ad blocker that would deal with that. I have bought a whole bunch of stuff through Instagram ads. I see too many ads on Instagram, but not enough to make me stop using it, and the ads are apparently relevant enough.

I assume this is a large reason why websites are so keen for you to use their apps.

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#60

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

I am tech savvy and run ad blockers on all my devices. However I consume Instagram through an app, and can’t be arsed setting up an ad blocker that would deal with that. I have bought a whole bunch of stuff through Instagram ads. I see too many ads on Instagram, but not enough to make me stop using it, and the ads are apparently relevant enough. I assume this is a large reason why websites are so keen for you to use…

I run an ad blocker centrally on my router (pfSense with pfblockerng on an APU2.D4), which has an automatically updated list of all known ad servers worldwide, directing traffic for those into a DNS sink. No device configuration needed. Cannot be detected by websites.
Post reply on HN