Live data from Hacker News

Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

nytimes.com

21–30 of 160 posts

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#21

> On Thursday, the company posted its fourth consecutive decline in profit as it grapples with a slowdown in digital advertising. Layoffs as a means of cost reduction to stem the tide seems very rational.

Shouldn't they instead punish those who inadequately planned for this?

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#22
post #12

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

Idk, but the drop in revenue is due to companies (eg coca-cola), no longer wanting to pay alphabet to have their ads displayed on alphabet's platforms, not so much as a drop in the amount of people clicking ads. (I say no longer wanting, there's still companies wanting obviously, demand for a spot on the platform is just lower). And it's mostly just the effects of monetary tightening, and companies trying to prepare…

I think this gets really close to the actual story. A ton of the money in all faangs, is between the big companies. Google paying to be the default search engine. Microsoft doing the same. Everyone paying to be the top Google result. How many stupid large payments are between the big players directly?

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#23

It couldn't possibly be because the google search engine produces pretty bad results these days, could it?

Well it’s possible! Solid user traffic numbers are hard to come by these days, but the anecdotes about search result pages full of trash keep piling up. I doubt my usage has changed much, but I’m ripe for poaching over to a better product. Google is in danger of being disrupted.

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#25

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

I think your bubble might be very tech heavy. My wife (a millennial) and her friends buy things from ads All. The. Time.

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#26

What is the chance that adtech is all a house of cards? Meaning that all of the "precision targeting" for segmenting married men over 30 who speak German and English while having house cats doesn't work at all? For a while, I was getting ads on Instagram in Spanish, and I don't speak Spanish.

If someone clicks on an ad, don’t you think it is because it resonated with them?

Even from first principles, it stands to reason that the more precisely you can craft a message (e.g. an ad) for your audience, the higher the chances that it would resonate, and be something you can monetize.

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#27
post #3

Earlier today I was watching a legaleagle video about Alex Jones' argument that he has to keep pitching dietary supplements to pay his civil debts. YouTube interrupted this video to play an ad for... dietary supplements. Great work. I'm sure Alphabet will be fine.

And your point is?

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#29

The fact that the ad model has worked so well is always a nice reminder of how much of a bubble I live in. Personally I have never intentionally clicked on a Google/YouTube/etc ad. Never. I wonder if the general population has been getting more tech-savvy and skeptical of ads over time, but this change takes a very long time to play out. I sometimes see my dad clicking on ads because he doesn't understand the mechani…

I think your bubble might be very tech heavy. My wife (a millennial) and her friends buy things from ads All. The. Time.

Yes, I think you're right.

Enough of the population falls for predatory online scams for them to be profitable.

Re: Alphabet’s Profit Falls 34% (fourth consecutive drop) Amid Ads Slowdown

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Their model likely detected you as an outlier and might disregard your clicks

If google thought your IP was from a click farm, wouldn't it block you from youtube entirely, to avoid wasting the bandwidth?

No way. Imagine the terrible user experience when that goes wrong.
Post reply on HN