Live data from Hacker News

US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

digit.so36.net

61–70 of 432 posts

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#61

I sincerely hope that the EU will give the appropriate but unprintable response to this request. At the time the biometric data was first collected plenty of people warned about this exact thing and we were repeatedly assured that it would never happen. Let's see if that is still true today. Never is such a long time...

[flagged]

Add it to the list of authortarian demands. Many have already been waiting more than six months for the US to drop the outdated Covid vaccine requirement.

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#62
Reading through the slides, it appears that what has been discussed is sharing signature and fingerprints for travel into the USA. There is a lot of weasel words, but it's probably worth nothing that the USA currently collects this information for foreign nationals coming into the USA (as the EU does for Americans traveling into the EU). This is being done in the context of a DB query as part of the e VISA application.

It's worth noting that almost all of this is still the output of the 9/11, where US and Saudi systems did not communicate and resulted in known terrorists in Saudi Arabia being able to travel at will into the USA.

I don't like biometrics, but the hyperbole needs to be tuned down a bit here.

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#63
post #21

Probably the most interesting part of this is if states don’t integrate by 2027 they will no longer be eligible for the Visa Waiver Program (VWP). That adds a lot of friction for citizens of that state to travel to the U.S. for any reason.

So what? If the rules are the same for all eu countries and with reciprocity, then the US will be isolated, and any eu-us business will be harder to do, and EU will do more trade with other countries, which also won't give biometric data to US, and US will be locked out of them too.

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> What is the US going to offer in return. Nothing, it's a hostage situation.

Then we should decouple a little bit.

Probably, and the EU was talking a big game about that a few years ago. But between Nordstream 2 and the Ukraine war the EU seems to have shown how willing it actually is to decouple...

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#65
post #13

I think it is vital we continue to discuss it here, but at the same time my conversations with my extended family show that people overall do not share my concerns over these at all. I do not get upset, because coming from a former soviet union country, I am trying hard to understand their frame of mind ( partially to see if there is a way to counter it ) and lot of it seems to a result from a deep trust in the syste…

It's mindblowing that people aren't bothered by it.

We're bothered, but maybe not enough to do away with visiting family/friends/coworkers/conferences/cons/national parks/etc. Also having various privileges (white, Western European, male, middle class, etc) dulls the concerns.

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#66
post #16

Starting from WWI western world is moving from what was basically complete freedom of movement to a corral. Think the best response would be something in line of go fuck yourself. No visa waiver - be my guest and have your tourism industry go belly up. Once tourism industry goes economic cooperation might eventually follow. Maybe this will teach our masters a bit. P.S. Being originally from USSR freedom of movement w…

This is asuming that EU will work in their (our) interest.

For me it seems that most of EU works with interests of other actors, especially US, from Ursula downwards, so they might give the US access and ignore their own people... again.

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

I haven't been back there since 2007 and have no intention to ever go back there. I missed a couple of funerals of friends because of that but the typical 'welcome' (I use the term loosely) afforded by DHS to visitors to the USA has persuaded me that I have better things to do with my life. The decision not to re-visit was made somewhere between the point where my shoes were confiscated because they might be used as…

Did you read TFA? It would only be used for people entering the US.

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#68
post #16

Starting from WWI western world is moving from what was basically complete freedom of movement to a corral. Think the best response would be something in line of go fuck yourself. No visa waiver - be my guest and have your tourism industry go belly up. Once tourism industry goes economic cooperation might eventually follow. Maybe this will teach our masters a bit. P.S. Being originally from USSR freedom of movement w…

> No visa waiver - be my guest and have your tourism industry go belly up.

Unfortunately for your plan, Yellowstone will still be Yellowstone, and New York will still be New York.

I agree with your attitude, but this "well, let them hang themselves" attitude just means the US ends up with the money and the data (via a slower path). A lack of visa waiver won't significantly negate tourism; there are a lot of attractions in the US.

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#69

I sincerely hope that the EU will give the appropriate but unprintable response to this request. At the time the biometric data was first collected plenty of people warned about this exact thing and we were repeatedly assured that it would never happen. Let's see if that is still true today. Never is such a long time...

[flagged]

Wanna spend some time out in Gitmo because your phrasing had wrong speak?

This is the introduction to draconian policies/laws in which you have no rights to opt out of this, representation caring to uphold your rights, or courts that are principled. Wanna get out, but still have family.. oh wait better give up more rights/risk going to jail to see them in the us. (Or they'll be interrogated back at home).

The point in this post is not to criticize you, but to criticize the lack of caring that a 6 month waiting for a visa is a systematic failure in need or ability.

Re: US Government demands direct police access to European biometric data [pdf]

#70
This is yet another violation of the forth Amendment right to privacy by the United States federal government as outlined by the Bill of Rights which applies to all people, not just US citizens and is self-evident and inalienable. Democracy worldwide is in absolute shambles as the United States government abandons the rule of law in favor of absolute dictatorship.
Post reply on HN