Live data from Hacker News

O Holy Crap

thefp.com

291–300 of 323 posts

Re: O Holy Crap

#291

Regarding the short cords on appliances, my mother (retired) has actually taken the time to call up at least one appliance manufacturer and give them an earful about kitchen appliances whose cords don't reach. The manufacturer had the gall to try to tell her this is "what consumers want" and they're saving her the favor of having a cord that could tangle or be dangerous. So her kitchen features appliances plugged int…

I did a similar thing on a vacuum cleaner - funny thing is, it actually performs like the higher end model now - we had a lower end variant and the touchswitch/motor controller actually limited motor power.

Re: O Holy Crap

#292
post #249

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you keep buying the same one?

Because we really like it, otherwise.

How much is there to like for a kettle - like you put water in, flick a switch, it turns off once boiled.

What features keep drawing you back in?

Re: O Holy Crap

#293

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Speed Queen on the washer will last awhile and parts are plentiful when they do wear out. You can replace the fridge door seal pretty easily, too.

Speed Queen washers are all tiny, though. Our current LG (a company I despise, but had the highest CR rating by far), is something like 5 cubic feet. The Speed Queens were all in the 3 cubic feet range. Depending on family size, amount of bedding, etc., something that small can be a real pain to deal with.

Not true on the usefulness. Family of 5 here with a SQ front loader. It does everything we need, including cloth diapers, and any time we have needed to repair it, parts have been readily available from multiple suppliers.

Re: O Holy Crap

#294
post #285

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's definitely not ideal, and I obviously try to do better than that in any product I work on. But I've seen so many things fail due to bad switches, connectors, and other simple parts, to me it's a great tradeoff to occasionally reboot something as opposed to having it totally fail at some random time within a few years. I wouldn't trust my life to it, but I'll trust my watch party to it. Plus, a consumer now only…

We can design hardware to last, but I think we often don’t for economic reasons. My larger point is that using software just trades one well-understood failure mode for a group of unknown, hard to test failure modes, usually because it’s cheaper. I think my biggest complaint comes as a result of the data economy. You can still find “dumb” tvs but they are usually a lot more expensive than their smart variants, I assu…

I think that definitely applies when you have updatable software or software that interacts with something updatable, but less so for the 8 bit embedded MCU stuff typically used to replace hardware.

If you, say, use a microcontroller to soft start a motor instead of making it bigger, or use a capsense pad instead of a switch(Yes they can be obnoxious, but at least they last!), you are unlikely to get into a permanent bricked state because you're not writing to flash at all.

Your failure modes might increase in number as software complexity increases, but for the most part they stay ephemeral.

I'm not sure exactly why experiences are so varied on things like smart TVs and WiFi printers. I have the "Smart" version of almost everything, and it usually works very well, but some people seem to have generally bad experiences.

I think some of it might be because they only test on fairly generic consumer setups with the latest stock Android, no firewall, no VPN, Bluetooth never turned off, no custom DNS, gmail for the email account, etc, and more tech savvy people tend to have a few things that modern tech doesn't like.

It always seems like people who tinker have problems other people don't. I also notice iOS users seem to have trouble with random gadgets and peripherals not being too happy, but a my iPhone using friends aren't a big sample size.

If I was designing a product, I'd definitely be more careful, but as a user at home, I tend to avoid anything heavily customized, so I don't usually see as many of the bugs.

Re: O Holy Crap

#295

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've got my selling salts, please tell me which coffee grinder you own? And by the way, since the topic of "where do I find the good stuff" keeps coming up, why is there no site that is your one-stop recommendation destination for finding quality appliances, tools? We all know we can no longer trust Amazon reviews. Consumer Reports has been around for ages but I don't feel they've kept in lockstep with the changing t…

https://eightouncecoffee.ca/collections/hand-grinders/produc... And yeah for products like these you really need to search prosumer forums for the specific area in question, Consumer Reports would be useless.

This has two problems:

1. The prosumers can get detached from the needs of ordinary consumers (see: audiophiles)

2. Some products just don't generate enthusiasts. I recently had to buy a washing machine. All the reviews are sponsored and slightly suspicious crap because nobody cares enough to be the Tom Laundry Tips of the world

Re: O Holy Crap

#296
post #112
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I used to think if you looked hard enough and researched things, maybe paid more sometimes, you could get around it. I still think that is necessary, but not sufficient. It won't save you; you also need a bit of luck. My biggest bugaboo in this area is with clothes. At some point I started being more careful, but found the published specs won't help because they don't actually tell you everything you need to know, or…

I've run into this issue with jeans. They develop holes around the crotch six months after buying a new pair. A decade ago I'd buy jeans and they'd last years. Unfortunately my waist line has since increased and none of those survivors now fit me. I started with Levi 511s and -- when they started failing -- moved to Nudie Jeans (2x price) as they offer free repairs. When I tried to get them repaired though I was told…

Bonobos brand jeans have served me well. I highly recommend them.

I too notice the decline in jeans quality. The cheap jeans I had as a kid in the 90’s were nearly indestructible. Sometimes I’d skin my knee but my jeans wouldn’t get a hole…

Re: O Holy Crap

#297
post #265

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In my experience this means they're fitting wrong and there's undue stress in the place that they're failing. For crotch area specifically, look into Duluth Trading's "Ballroom" pants. Alternately, the moment you buy new pants, add some iron-on patch reinforcement across the area. A two-dollar giant patch can spread the force out quite a bit and probably double the lifetime of the unreinforced fabric. But really, a t…

As someone who has also had these issues with the crotch of pants wearing out, I would also suggest trying these options. It's a combination of stretching and friction. Jeans have it especially bad because they have prominent seams right where the thighs touch, causing an extra large amount of friction. A gusseted crotch (which I believe the Ballroom jeans have) both helps with the stretching and moves the seams arou…

[deleted]

Re: O Holy Crap

#298

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A broken fridge ruins lots of food, worth lots of money. A broken washing machine or dishwasher can flood your house, costing 10s of thousands of dollars. A broken dryer can burn your house down. And even if some of those aren’t common failure modes (fridge is common), it is incredibly inconvenient and expensive to be without a major appliance for (insert supply chain guesstimate number of) weeks every year or so.

I've only personally seen one failure like that, a bad washer flooding a friend's house. I would imagine a heat pump dryer would be very unlikely to burn anything down. It is a really big inconvenience when they go offline, but there are still lots of brands that seem to work fine for 10 to 20 years. I'm surprised ultra high reliability isn't more of a consumer selling point. Refrigerators in particular could do it w…

Appliances probably don't need redundancy, but rather a guaranteed service person you could call that will fix the thing for a reasonable price instead of just telling you its the "control board" to try and sell you a new one. Perhaps some engineering to support easier diagnostics, and definitely to reduce the number of replacement part SKUs.

Re: O Holy Crap

#299
post #79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have a 2nd fridge in my garage, an old philco one - still running perfectly, 365 days a year for almost 70 years. Never needed a repair in the 25 years I have owned it.

Throw it away! It is costing more in annual electricity than a new one. Never mind it's old; it's insulation is worthless and its compressor is very inefficient.

Compressor efficiency hasn't changed much actually. Insulation, probably, is where most of the energy savings come from.

Re: O Holy Crap

#300
post #82

I don't quite know what to say to what I found near the end in this article: > Recently, my wife needed a carrot peeler. She needed one rather quickly. Off to Target. The one she bought (the only one on sale)... I stopped at the phrase "the only one on sale". Inevitably the next part reads: > looked handsome enough, and the brand was one she recognized, but it failed in the useful department, miserably. It wasn’t sha…

She was sold a carrot peeler. She didn't receive a carrot peeler. It's not relevant what the price was: that's a decision for the shop. If they can't sell carrot peelers at a price that makes sense for them, the answer is to not sell carrot peelers, not to sell things that are described as carrot peelers but which cannot peel a carrot.

I don't understand your point? The whole article being discussed is about tons of crap getting sold.
Post reply on HN