Live data from Hacker News

Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

washingtonpost.com

761–770 of 1001 posts

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#761
post #89
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's probably a portion of the TSLA slide that can be chalked up to this, too. So more than $45b, though how much more is anyone's guess.

https://openargs.com/oa645-we-badly-underestimated-just-how-... This is very good podcast about this exact topic.

Thanks for the recommendation!

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#762
post #684

Musk on November 6th: My commitment to free speech extends even to not banning the account following my plane, even though that is a direct personal safety risk https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/15894149585086914...

Yes, thank you for reminding this forum, although I’m sure everyone here remembers or has already been made aware of this contradiction.

Can you argument this point further or is it enough to imagine it with a trollface meme?

Me personally, I argue that it was an exaggerated policy position to take. Under no circumstances should menacing, harassment, threats to personal safety be tolerated.

It’s definitely a good thing that Musk backtracked on this, as the previous policy would have been used to cover some outrageous behavior, such as invading the personal space of LGBTQ accounts, outing them at work, or even menacingly posting selfies in their neighborhood.

There are limits to speech, free speech is meant within the context of public sphere debate and politics.

This tit-for-tat confrontation has to be suppresses, or the verbal rioting that is online trolling will again spillover into IRL.

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#763
post #760

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Completely fair banning them over policy violation. But Elon promised 'absolute' free speech when he took over? No one would be complaining about these bans if not for the hypocrisy. I have never seen this two face stand. Elon is now understanding the risk and fallacy of absolute free speech when some rando stalked his family. But glossed over when others shouted at the same.

Apples and oranges. I think the doxxing policy makes sense. It's absolutely not okay posting people's real-time locations, especially for famous figures who are already targets. I don't hear anybody criticizing the policy. Because it is right. Instead people are attacking Elon's past promise, as it is the only thing they can attack. So maybe "absolute" free speech is not a very good idea after all. What matters is go…

Doxxing is a fair policy and sharing real time location to be included in the doxxing policy is fair. No disagreements there.

Elon backtracking from the absolute free speech is fair to be mocked and laughed at as 'I said so'.

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#764
I don't care whether the Washington Post is right or not on this one; but it is good to see that these people are now getting a taste of their own medicine.

Nobody from that camp was lifting a finger when "conspiracy theorists" were being banned from Twitter. People were saying that "Twitter was a private company who could ban whoever it wanted".

Here is a past thread of mine: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31154200

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#765
post #325

I don't like seeing anyone banned by any social media company. This is a fail by Elon considering his previous absolutist stance. I'd rather shine the light on both stupid and brilliant and let people decide on their own what they'd like to consume in terms of information and entertainment. The VC Elite should raise a fund, hire former Twitter employees, and mount a competitive alternative. They could "Build a better…

I believe https://post.news/ is the attempt to do this (though mostly not with past Twitter employees). Basically the same as Twitter but with a little more emphasis on publishers. Seems fine, though occasionally it gets a little sluggish, and the content skews towards general popular interest without a big tech community yet.

Do they have an ActivityPub interface? If not, how does post.news convince their users that the time spent on establishing their social network isn't wasted when the company is sold to yet another abusive investor somewhere in the future?

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#766
post #520

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The people who cheered Musk for his "pro free speech" attitude don't actually believe or want free speech. They want free speech for themselves and censorship for people they don't like. See the terrorist attacks against Drag Queens.

I want free speech, hence I think Elon is a tremendous hypocrite for enacting this policy. Once you start deciding whether or not things are 'safe' to say you will end up in the exact situation Jack, et al. were in when they were censoring just with different biases. He doesn't seem to understand that and is doomed to repeat their mistakes. There is some irony now seeing those that didn't believe the banning of accou…

> There is some irony now seeing those that didn't believe the banning of accounts arbitrarily was an issue under previous management decrying this move by Elon.

No, the irony is not that the site under both owners is trying to remove bad/harmful content (just defining it differently).

The irony is that Musk thought he wasn’t going to have to do it at all: “absolute free speech”, “public square”, “comedy is legal”, etc.

One of the banned journalists went on Mastodon and said (paraphrasing): “It’s his site and he can ban whoever he wants”

And to be fair, under both owners, accounts were banned for violating ToS policies. The policies are just different, but they’re still the rules you agree to when you use the site.

I just don’t think anyone thought “free speech” meant no parodying, no republishing public FAA info, etc.

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#767

Earlier quoted context omitted.

perhaps the ultimate irony will be that people will ditch Twitter for something like Mastoden. Elon jet is alive and well over there. https://mastodon.social/@elonjet

yeah, not gonna happen. mastodon is not normie-friendly enough for that to happen.

Have you used it? My local feed is overflowing with people that I think you would definitely describe as "normies"

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#768
It's not that complicated. This is a credible threat to his family and Musk is scared. I'd be scared, too. I'd have shut down the jet account and any account linking to it as well. If you think you'd have done something different, you're a liar or a robot or a fool.

There are some legitimate things to pick on Musk for. This isn't one of them.

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#769
post #724
post #684

Musk on November 6th: My commitment to free speech extends even to not banning the account following my plane, even though that is a direct personal safety risk https://mobile.twitter.com/elonmusk/status/15894149585086914...

That was the case until a stalker got close to his toddler. That clearly shook him and changed his mind. Now the account will come back with a delay. He also changed his mind on free speech absolutism. He came around to the "freedom of speech is not freedom of reach" argument.

So shaken that he (and his security team) forgot to file a police report.

Re: Twitter applies 7-day suspension to half a dozen journalists

#770
post #325

I don't like seeing anyone banned by any social media company. This is a fail by Elon considering his previous absolutist stance. I'd rather shine the light on both stupid and brilliant and let people decide on their own what they'd like to consume in terms of information and entertainment. The VC Elite should raise a fund, hire former Twitter employees, and mount a competitive alternative. They could "Build a better…

I believe https://post.news/ is the attempt to do this (though mostly not with past Twitter employees). Basically the same as Twitter but with a little more emphasis on publishers. Seems fine, though occasionally it gets a little sluggish, and the content skews towards general popular interest without a big tech community yet.

I’ve seen some members of the science twitter community set up accounts over there too, though most seem to be hedging their bets with mastodon accounts as well. Will be interesting to see how it all shakes out.
Post reply on HN