Live data from Hacker News

New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

bbc.com

101–110 of 227 posts

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

With 8% of NZ smoking and that number apparently falling, can you state the problem?

> She added that the legislation could close the life expectancy between Maori and non-Maori citizens. The overall smoking rate for Maori citizens is at 19.9% - down from last year's figure of 22.3%. 8% among general population but 19.9% among Maori.

And falling rapidly.

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#102
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But I don't understand that, if we're operating on under the premise that smoking is bad for all (which it is), then why not ban it for all now? Thats sets a horrible precedent.

Because older people already got addicted while it was legal seems like a pragmatic decision (and... "sets a horrible precedent" for what?)

Would you be against the same law if it was about alcohol? (Ban for people born after 2008)

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#103
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>"But yes, alcohol is harmful but I think smoking is even more so." I disagree. Also alcoholics harm many other people around them

See, I’m old enough to remember holding my breath to get past a throng of chain-smokers when they’d gas out a restaurant or clog the front of a store.

I agree with this particular aspect but it is long gone. I do not see smokers harm anyone but themselves now. Alcoholics on the other hand ...

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#104
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>"But yes, alcohol is harmful but I think smoking is even more so." I disagree. Also alcoholics harm many other people around them

See, I’m old enough to remember holding my breath to get past a throng of chain-smokers when they’d gas out a restaurant or clog the front of a store.

Me too, doesn't really happen anymore so it seems like with time, some sensible regulations and education everything works out? Why the need for a ban?

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#106
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Really not clear. Nicotine isn't very good for your vasculature system and the vehicles (like PEG) aren't really a good thing to be breathing.

They're still not as bad as ammonia and smoke. Edit: It hit me that over the next few decades they are probably going to invent some really nasty things to put in vapes, like they did with cigarettes (that were made to be a lot worse than the "mere" nicotine and smoke inhalation of tobacco smoking), so don't read this in 20 years thinking that people in the past thought whatever they're doing in the future is safer t…

Also, at least in the US, the vehicles (solvents) are unregulated, as are the heating devices (I have been told by some vaping friends that they like the "toasted" effect at the end of a long pull, which is the polymer heating, fracturing, and crosslinking. Ugh.

PEG is a common vehicle; some molecular weights are so safe they aren't even regulated (called GRAS -- "generally regarded as safe") and some are quite toxic. If you were making the drug delivery device for some pharmaceutical your delivery system would be closely regulated to make sure both drug and vehicle were safely administered at all times. But these drugs are not regulated and neither are their delivery systems. You can sell whatever the hell you like.

It's similar to tattoo inks -- some are OK some are really bad (like copper or sooty inks), but all the FDA can do is post some web pages rather than require safe inks.

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#107
post #2

actually discussed here, but it didn't gain a lot of points, so not much visibility for such big news https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33967454

Big news? It's certainly not a topic of active conversation in NZ.

It was talked about for a day or two when it was announced a while back - I haven't seen a single news article about it recently, nor has anyone talked about it. The opposition political parties haven't made a big deal out of it either that I've noticed.

I don't think anyone really cares. With vaping still being allowed - it's all a bit moot. Anyone born after 2008 is going to be buying a vape.

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> She added that the legislation could close the life expectancy between Maori and non-Maori citizens. The overall smoking rate for Maori citizens is at 19.9% - down from last year's figure of 22.3%. 8% among general population but 19.9% among Maori.

And falling rapidly.

Could you point me to the numbers that suggest a rapid fall over time or are you implying it based on the change over the course of one year mentioned in the article?

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#109
post #40

Not just cigarettes — all tobacco products. How very appalling. Smoking is a human right. Pipes smell wonderful; tobacco generally tastes great and has a positive effect on one’s mood and attention. Sad day for New Zealanders.

That zeal. From what I heared, anti-drug laws may be construed is that selling is a different matter and possession and production are accessory. That's why possession of small amounts of cannabis for example is decriminalized while traffiking is still prossecuted where I'm from. This is arguable because addictive substances will be sold with the intention of creating dependence, not unlike the loot box topic, thus i…

> And to be real, the wonderful smell acts on your parasympathic nervous system because of appetite, for the smell is associated with roasted food. Add to that the childish reflex of sucking on a nipple. So it is pretty much an eating disorder, in my humble opinion.

Even Freud once said "Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar". There is no scientific basis for the whole "oral fixation", so calling it "childish" is pretty ignorant.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oral_stage

Edit: "Contradicting the Freudian psychosexual development concept of oral-stage fixation, the Duration of Breast-feeding and the Incidence of Smoking (2003) study of 87 participants reported no causal relation between the breast-feeding period and whether or not a child matures into a person who smokes."

Re: New Zealand passes legislation banning cigarettes for future generations

#110
post #90
post #79

As nonsmoker I'm strongly against this, when did alcohol prohibition, war on drugs or their COVID restrictions worked? You will just anger people and it seems completely unnecessary considering there is steady decline in smokers and there are surely more dangerous issues to deal with, in case of NZ it would be pandemic of obesity.

Assisted suicide is legal in New Zealand. What if I want to smoke myself to death? Absolutism from the state is so noxious. Make cigarettes prohibitively expensive and difficult to acquire sure. But complete prohibition is an infringement on our natural right to decide what to consume.

You wanna smoke yourself to death? Do it at home. Most people want to smoke themselves to death in the open, around other people though. It's nobody's right to pollute our air for the sake of their bad habits, thus regulations.
Post reply on HN