Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Apparently I am a robot

aiweirdness.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–50 of 52 posts

Re: Apparently I am a robot

#41

Post by ggm »

ilyt wrote: post #26
ggm wrote: post #2

Yep. I've been accused of using ChatGPT to compose some of my posts here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33930584#33930756

> Musk may well find himself restoring the various Ikea ball room for grown-ups in due course. > But in a workplace climate with 20,000 former FAANG washing around like polystyrene debris in the canal estate.. maybe he has picked his time well. I'd think "Ikea ball room for grown-ups" came from chatbot too, that's on you dude

Admit it: if you could, you'd launch yourself into one. I know I would.

Re: Apparently I am a robot

#43

Post by nathias »

I hope the turing-passing content will shift focus from the origin of the statements to the actual content of what is being said. Authentication of origin is only a helpful rule of thumb when dealing with trusted authorities, something that doesn't really scale beyond a village.

Re: Apparently I am a robot

#47

Post by ghoward »

robocat wrote: post #16
ggm wrote: post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think I've been subtly insulted again... fail the test, more closely aligned to the statistical model of an ideal GPT and using cliché. I plead guilty to all of them. I clearly took one for the team, let the side down, disappointed at the finish, peaked early and missed by a country mile. Try harder. Grow a backbone. (Hu)man up!

77 tokens, 88.25% fake. You are really good at this game! And https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18576101 which you wrote 4 years ago (before GPT2) has: 79 tokens 99.86% Fake Hopefully someone writes a script to run the detector over past users, because we are sure to find someone who naturally writes like GPT (after all, the training corpus came from somewhere!) Also: no intent to insult - I would be even more amu…

Hey, what tool are you using for detection? I'd like to run it on my own comments and on my blog posts.

Re: Apparently I am a robot

#48

Post by sdfignaertgnio »

nathias wrote: post #43

I hope the turing-passing content will shift focus from the origin of the statements to the actual content of what is being said. Authentication of origin is only a helpful rule of thumb when dealing with trusted authorities, something that doesn't really scale beyond a village.

I claim London is the capital of France. Try to prove me wrong without relying on any authority whatsoever. I think you will find it impossible.

Re: Apparently I am a robot

#49

Post by ilyt »

nonrandomstring wrote: post #34
maxbond wrote: post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For sure. I could have phrased this better. Perhaps, "younger people were socialized to interact with people over the internet, unlike their parents or grandparents. In the same way, their children will grow up socialized to use a battery of tools to determine what's real or fictional in an environment of adversarial information." I'm not necessarily saying they'll be good at it (indeed, that's part of my concern) ju…

I think together, you and ggm raise a troubling point. Your exchange is presently civil and exploratory (all very HN), but I expect we will see a rapid descent into accusations of impersonation and ML assisted posting elsewhere. Yuri Bezmenov and others have detailed the active psyops tactics to systematically undermine a society by destroying mutual trust between individuals and between and within institutions. Ulti…

You don't exactly need GPT for, that, few assholes if left unmoderated can make any social place terrible.

And society doesn't exactly equip people to deal with that, schools don't exactly learn how to converse or deal with people that assume you're "the evil" and refuse to even entertain the though to think about their own argument, let alone someone's else. Hell, we are barely taught how to have normal problem-solving conversation correctly (or at least that's what I reason from amount of times asking few "why's" about someone's idea made them immediately realize it's not as good as they thought)

Re: Apparently I am a robot

#50

Post by Gigachad »

maxbond wrote: post #7

I think we're all going to get a crash course in how difficult measurement is and how no single indicator can be relied upon, over the next few years. I think we're going to have to develop robust ways of knowing by composing many indicators together, along with intangible/vibes based epistemologies. I think that in the same way "Gen Z" (acknowledging that the concept of generations isn't as meaningful as we might wa…

Future generations will sprinkle anti corporate messages and racial slurs in their comments to verify a real human wrote them.
Post reply on HN