93% here
Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
61–70 of 107 posts
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#62To be fair, to me, title should be more like are you able to tell cherry picked AI images from cherry picked human created images, since both clearly were selected to appear similarly picked to confuse a human in my opinion. No idea if that’s accurate, or even if it is, how to fix it, but one idea would be to get a list of the top ten search queries on a popular stock image site, then randomly pick an AI image and hu…
Actually no, they were not cherry picked. Except for generations which did not match the prompt at all, I took every image that was created. For the human images, I just took things from Unsplash's and ArtStation's front pages. I clicked on those images without looking. Early next year I'll do a better quiz with more variety. This was a weekend project.
> Actually no, they were not cherry picked. Except for generations which did not match the prompt at all
Second sentence describes process of selection. Is there difference in English between "filtered" / "selected" and "cherry picked"? Is "cherry picked" implying extreme filtering?
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#63How about you pay us for training your models instead of doing it for free!
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#6424 of 30 (80%)
My key for AI was: Does it looks like kitch? So probably there were few false positives.
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#65Got 24/30 (80%) Look at the hands, look for obvious repeating patterns in foliage, look for lines that don't connect right.
also look for geometric details that a human artist wouldn't bother with because they don't really make sense like some golden swirly jewelry thing on a dress that barely looks like anything
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#66> You correctly classified 13 of 30 (43%) images!
Huh tricky. Some might be easier than others
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#67This would have been so easy if the images were generated by Dalle. It always has huge ugly artifacts
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#68Earlier quoted context omitted.
I got 25 correct, and the majority of that was just looking at hands and text to see if they were messed up.
Text is a very good indication the photo is non-AI. Lots of AI generated images struggle with it, I don't know why.
Messed text is also giveaway that you are in dream.
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#6966% here
Same. Thought I would get at least 75% honestly.
Re: Show HN: Can you tell if an image is AI-generated?
#70> You correctly classified 26 of 30 (86%) images! > You identified 12 of 14 (85%) AI-generated images. > You identified 14 of 16 (87%) human-made images. In general, I followed a pretty simple rule: - If it's a photograph, it's likely human if there're no immediate imperfections - If it's an illustration, it's AI if the art has imperfections OR if it's anime-adjacent (example: images with glossy lighting on human ski…
I got 25 correct, and the majority of that was just looking at hands and text to see if they were messed up.
All of anime images are also has the quintessential SD/NAI eyes, that’s another tell.