Live data from Hacker News

US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

reclaimthenet.org

211–219 of 219 posts

Re: US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

#211

Earlier quoted context omitted.

(citation needed - that’s not actually implemented in china at scale, though it’s a convenient talking point in the west)

> that's not actually implemented That's my understanding as well. > it's a convenient talking point in the west When online comments get worked up about The Social Credit System, a key thing I believe they're trying to do is spread awareness of how disturbing it is that a government is even considering such a thing that, as we understand it, is closely related to being a core technology in an authoritarian dystopia.…

Ok. If we’re talking speculative planning, the US also considers bringing privatized credit score system under government control instead, the very thing OP is criticizing. I have no problem with criticizing authorities but the us vs them look how much worse it is in red china god bless our freedoms here angle is tired bootlicking too

Re: US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m quite sure they are trying to automate this as well.

your citation still doesn't say much, just that most are at least still "preparing" or have rolled out a limited pilot, which is what I said originally

https://safeguarddefenders.com/en/blog/230000-policing-expan...

Re: US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’m quite sure they are trying to automate this as well.

your citation still doesn't say much, just that most are at least still "preparing" or have rolled out a limited pilot, which is what I said originally

And

https://safeguarddefenders.com/sites/default/files/pdf/110%2...

Re: US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or that VP of Apple quoting from a movie called “Arthur” at an auto show resulting in him being fired. It has begun right here in the United States and we just are oblivious to these new dastardly form of social credits.

Saying "they" are oppressing an Apple VP is an interesting contrast to the next post over which says Apple (FAANG) is part of "they".

Except that it was the bevy of Apple VPs putting pressure on this ouster.

Re: US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

#215
post #199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> plus the risk of randomly being flagged This is 100% going to happen, so my guess is it can’t be authoritative. It’s likely to be used to whittle down a list so that humans can review the results. Feels like the beginning of a hybrid Minority Report + Enemy of the State movie. I’d watch that. I don’t want to live in that world, though.

> > plus the risk of randomly being flagged > This is 100% going to happen, so my guess is it can’t be authoritative. Why do you think that it won’t be authoritative?

How many people write similar to you? I’d imagine it is more than one. Someone even did a show HN to find other accounts that write similar to you, which was entertaining.

Re: US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

#216
post #199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> > plus the risk of randomly being flagged > This is 100% going to happen, so my guess is it can’t be authoritative. Why do you think that it won’t be authoritative?

How many people write similar to you? I’d imagine it is more than one. Someone even did a show HN to find other accounts that write similar to you, which was entertaining.

I didn’t claim it would be correct or accurate. I doubted your allegation that it would not be taken as authoritative.

Re: US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

#218

Being able to be anonymous is actually a valuable thing. Think of people in oppressive regimes. I believe we need countermeasures, so we need to create algoriths that add fuzzyness to our writing to protect privacy.

But also think of the anonymous oppressors

they're usually regime-controlled, so it's ok.

Re: US Government plans to develop AI that can unmask anonymous writers

#219
Some other posts about Stylometry:

https://www1.icsi.berkeley.edu/~sadia/papers/oakland2014-und... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18328270 https://serhack.me/articles/unveiling-anonymous-author-stylo... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30571932

Post reply on HN