Live data from Hacker News

YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

twitter.com

121–130 of 277 posts

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#121

Unwanted advertising is spam. Period. A lot of junk mail landed in my mailbox when I moved to a new place, until I put a red dot sticker on it. Within a week or two, they disappeared. We should implement this "red dot sticker" feature in browsers (with optional exceptions), and pages, services and whatnot should respect it, or they will be facing fines. Fines that really hurt.

What is a red dot sticker?

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#122

I don’t like ads, especially not irrelevant and excessive ones (I pay for YouTube premium), but the amount of people bragging about getting around ads is just sad. I assume most of us here have jobs. Are we ok with working for free? Many people on YouTube do it full time, with ad revenue and exposure being their primary source of income. Somehow some people have it in their heads that if the job is entertainment then…

> Are we ok with working for free?

No, which is why I decided to pursue a career where I'm paid based on a salary, protected by employee rights (even if limited in the US), and not beholden to a single corporation's platofrm to perform my job.

Most of the youtubers I watch aren't making a living off of it, and the few that do are able to do so because they've monetized outside of the YouTube platform.

Nothing you say will make me feel a single twinge of guilt over using ad blockers.

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#123
post #113
post #92

I haven’t seen an ad on YouTube in ages with ublock origin.

sad that it is not available on iOS

Yattee [1] and AdGuard [2] are two solutions I’ve found that can help.

[1] https://github.com/yattee/yattee [2] https://adguard.com/en/blog/how-to-add-a-shortcut-to-block-y...

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#124
post #63

Imho, the big question here is, if there's actually a trend. Was it easier, 10 years ago, to make money from a website, with just one single (non-animated) banner on top, than it is today with a website that's plastered with animated banners, link ads, and other stuff? Was it easier, 10 years ago, to make money from a video platform, with just one single skip-able ad at the start of each video - than it is today with…

Did you ever see Idiocracy? It's become hackneyed to say that we're approaching it, but look at the way they handle advertising. Basically the video you watch is just a window surrounded by scrolling advertisement banners. The trend was clear then. Look at shows from the past, a "1 hour" program used to consist of what, 52 minutes? I know it's crept from 48 minutes to 42 last I checked. I even remember reading about…

Look at the content as well, it all descends into "reality" TV shit like Ghost Hunters and Street Outlaws.

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#125

I wish that next to the thumbs up button was a support icon that allowed you to fund the creator a small amount in an easy way. The platform owner would get a percentage.

They already have that. When people livestream, there are buttons you can click to pay money: $5, $10, $20 etc.

Looks really gauche and cheap, but then again so does most of the 'creator' economy.

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#126
post #109

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Creators have their own e-stores, I've supported those. Your suggestion is like buying a record from Walmart to support the artist, instead of buying it directly at a show.

Your suggestion is like stealing records from Walmart and rationalizing that by saying you send money to the artists.

I think of it as walking into the store and ignore the person shilling their Walmart rewards card. Some people will stop and chat, others won't. I'm the second category.

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#127
post #126

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your suggestion is like stealing records from Walmart and rationalizing that by saying you send money to the artists.

I think of it as walking into the store and ignore the person shilling their Walmart rewards card. Some people will stop and chat, others won't. I'm the second category.

That’s not the same thing at all lol

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#128
post #71
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

they'll add ads to that once enough people are using it

Bullshit. The whole and only point of Premium is that it has no ads. If they add them for paid users too they'll lose pretty much all of them.

Cable TV would like a word with you.

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#129
post #31
post #11

Well I'd imagine youtube's infrastructure is very expensive. I guess they can no longer pretend the service they provide for free doesn't need to be funded. What did people expect?

It is expensive but even then Youtube has been profitable for many years now. It represents 10% of Google revenue. 5-10 ads is a cash grab imho.

unless it changed recently it has never been profitable

Re: YouTube currently testing 5 to 10 unskippable ads before video starts

#130

I subscribe to Youtube TV and I feel like they have been doing this in there already. It was a great service and now not only do I have to pay $65 a month for the service but also have to watch 3 3-minute advertisement blocks during a 30-min episode of Family Guy. It's starting to make cable more attractive.

At that point, why not just get a copy of the series on DVD or Blu-ray? You can rip a copy to a NAS (or a flash drive if you have a smart TV with a USB port) if you would rather have a streaming experience. Copies of the show often show up in good condition at second-hand bookstores. You wouldn't have to worry about ads, the show getting rotated in or out of the cable/streaming service, could resell the copies if you don't want them anymore, and would be paying only for the shows that you want to see
Post reply on HN