Live data from Hacker News

Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

journals.sagepub.com

31–40 of 506 posts

Re: Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

#31

Makes perfect sense to me. The free exchange of information is more appealing and less threatening when you have more information processing capability to begin with.

That is why businesses routinely encourage their workers to exchange salary information amongst themselves.

Re: Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

#32
post #9

It would be interesting to see if they could control for level of/exposure to formal education in cognitive ability (plenty of smart uneducated people, and dumb educated people). I think this would help tease of if this is a feature of cognitive ability, or if cognitive ability is just a proxy to how much civics education you've likely had.

“Controlling for gender, ethnicity, and education did not meaningfully alter the associations between cognitive ability and support for freedom of speech. Also controlling for participants’ ideology (separately or in addition to the demographic variables) did not meaningfully affect the associations.”

Re: Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

#34
post #4

There appears to be a recent shift on HackerNews no longer support freedom of speech. I don't know that its just HackerNews either - it seems like its 'internet residents no longer support freedom of speech.' I'm not sure how to interpret this.

according to the study, a valid hypothesis is that hn became more stupid more seriously, the shift is not just HN it is everywhere. We have generations of people who have been grown up to self-censor at every step, so by natural extension freedom of speech is not a priority. Urbanization and the evergreen/growth/globalist agenda that comes with it is also in favor of restrictions that maintain the cohesion of large c…

Somewhere along the line, we stopped teaching children that everybody doesn't have to agree with you. And now those children have grown into adults who want only those opinions of which they approve to be heard. No free and open society can survive with that kind of thinking.

Re: Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

#35
post #7

It seems to be based on data grouped on questionable labeling of dubious grouping of people, correlated with a weak proxy of cognitive ability (How many word associations do homosexuals get right; that's really one of the cells in the analysis). And it answers nothing of interest. How is this publishable?

Cognitive Ability Is Related to How Seriously You Take Studies Like This

Trust the science (unless it's science I disagree with)

Re: Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

#36
In my experience, the notion of being "for or against freedom of speech" is actually referring to something more subjective, and that phrasing is used to imply which side of the disagreement the speaker believes is correct, like referring to the debate about abortion as the debate about murdering babies. It signals a strong bias.

Re: Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

#37

Makes perfect sense to me. The free exchange of information is more appealing and less threatening when you have more information processing capability to begin with.

So how would you protect those with less information processing ability from the consequences of more free exchange of information?

Re: Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

#38
post #30

I can see how their conclusions play out in real life. One of the common threads I've noticed across many people when trying to explain why defending freedom of speech, and the free and open exchange of ideas in general, is that they're not just defending some "right-wing" person's rights, they're actually defending their own rights. Because the same tactics and rationales that are being used to suppress and silence…

How do you protect the rights of those being bullied, trolled, harassed, doxxxed and revenge-porned.

With laws.

Re: Cognitive ability is related to supporting freedom of speech (2020)

#40

There appears to be a recent shift on HackerNews no longer support freedom of speech. I don't know that its just HackerNews either - it seems like its 'internet residents no longer support freedom of speech.' I'm not sure how to interpret this.

If you really want to scramble your noodle, look at the recent spate of state laws placing restrictions on speech and notice the lean of the parties that control those states.

Can you give some examples? Is it actually speech that's being restricted, or actions, or access to certain types of speech/content (e.g. age restrictions)?
Post reply on HN