Live data from Hacker News

MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

origin-discussions2-us-dr-prz.apple.com

51–60 of 588 posts

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#51

Apple has always tried to blame customers whenever they can. I remember when my MacBook pro 2015 started glitching and Apple voided the warranty by saying there was liquid spillage/fluid damage. So apparently macbooks have these small stickers inside them which change color upon contact with liquids to help detect liquid damage but the issue with those stickers are that they also change color if you live in a humid a…

Heh, the punk at the Amsterdam Apple Store had the audacity to guilt trip me for a complaint I had within the mandatory EU warranty.

According to him, I had exposed an iPhone to excessive humidity despite the sensing sticker remaining white. His reasoning was that if the connector was growing copper corrosion it must have been humidity and therefore my fault (not a bad batch of connectors.)

I chuckled and asked him how could that happen if I always keep the thing in my pocket and he said “well that’s a humid environment and the phone is not designed for that.”

The fact that he also called a security guy before lecturing me about my warranty expiry was a clear indication of the sort of narrative and treatment I’d receive if I insisted, so I walked. Other times I was given red-carpet treatment and expensive replacements without a peep.

I guess it really depends on whether Cupertino acknowledges the defect, until then Genius KPIs must include how many customers they successfully subdue and kick out.

SMH… but I guess you get assholes everywhere

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#52
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

M1 = "the 1st gen MacBook Air with the M1 chip"

Yes, I know, but I don't think the chip is the reason for the cracking. I think it may be tolerances in the case. Maybe they also started using a different, more brittle glass, with this generation. Maybe the stress has always been there, but didn't cause cracks, with the last type of glass.

You missed the point. Nobody’s saying chip is the culprit—“M1” in this context refers to the Macbook series powered by the eponymous chip. Which means those Macbooks are only a few years old at most, yet there are 49 pages of user reports that their screens are prone to cracking for no reason.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#53

A friend just had this happen to their M1 Air under warranty and Apple quoted him $400 for the repair claiming it was "accidental" damage, even though he didn't do anything to it, like the 50 pages of people who replied in the thread. Wanted to make a quick PSA against purchasing one of these to save a few hundred bucks vs the M2 Air which hopefully won't have this problem, and possibly put some pressure on Apple to…

Given the number of models with the butterfly keyboards which were somewhat similar (model-wide issues, not acknowledged by Apple, blamed on the user), what makes you think M2 Air is going to fix any potential screen issues?

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#55
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A warranty that can be voided just because some little sticker a user can't access indicates moisture detection doesn't even sound like it should be legal. If you've done something obviously stupid like drop your monitor in the bath then you're hardly going to need such a sticker to detect "unreasonable use". It seems pretty reasonable to expect consumer goods to tolerate small amounts of moisture. In fact a monitor…

Most electronics including Apple mention that they’re rated for 35°C while working and 40°C while off. After a single year, most of Apple warranties void out.

You use your laptop outside a lot?

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#56
post #26

Sounds like a manufacturing or sourcing issue. I can only imagine Apple hasn't recalled or notified customer support to be on the lookout for this because Apple themselves isn't even aware of the issue. How would they know? Techs writing up these issues are probably attributing them all to user damage. Unless someone is actively looking for a noticeable uptick in user damage cases I doubt it even comes up.

They should know it's not normal to replace this many screens on a ~2 year old product line, they should be monitoring this type of data. It shouldn't have to bubble up from the front lines of tech support

They absolutely should, but I would not be shocked if they weren't

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#57
post #11

> Page 49 of 49 That tells you something... Cupertino, we have a problem.

I was shocked when I saw there was 49 pages. Remember, the m1 is just a few years old!

A lot of the 'me too' responses are about other MacBooks - not just the m1 air.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#58
post #46

Impact at the edge of screen created microscopic crack. Thermal change caused the crack to spread. It happens all the time with vehicle windshields.

> Thermal change caused the crack to spread. It happens all the time with vehicle windshields. This happened to my brother’s brand new Tesla. Tiny impact on the edge extended all the way across after a week in Tucson. Very sad, especially because the service was difficult (had to return to SoCal for repair). The next week around Tucson I looked for and spotted over a dozen Teslas with similar crack extensions. It’s p…

Car windshields are laminated with plastic in the middle, precisely to prevent shards, and to not have it completely collapse in the event of an impact.

The rest of the windows are tempered glass, also to prevent shards.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#59
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, I know, but I don't think the chip is the reason for the cracking. I think it may be tolerances in the case. Maybe they also started using a different, more brittle glass, with this generation. Maybe the stress has always been there, but didn't cause cracks, with the last type of glass.

You missed the point. Nobody’s saying chip is the culprit—“M1” in this context refers to the Macbook series powered by the eponymous chip. Which means those Macbooks are only a few years old at most, yet there are 49 pages of user reports that their screens are prone to cracking for no reason.

No, there are 49 pages of complaints, but many of them are about other MacBooks.

Re: MacBook Air M1 screen crack for no apparent reason

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My wife had a MBP with support plan years ago. The track pad started failing and it wouldn't always click even after you felt it depress and was slowly getting worse and worse. I took it in and the guy basally said there was no problem and I was just not pressing hard enough or something... It was very noticeable after using it for a while... Anyway I ended up ordering a new track pad online and replaced it myself an…

It's impossible to do self repairs on macbooks these days. Apple intentionally solders all the components together to prevent self repair. Even the battery is soldered to the system. https://9to5mac.com/2019/07/12/2019-13-macbook-pro-teardown/

Technical quibble here. The batteries are glued to the case, not soldered to anything. The power cables still use connectors and can be easily popped off.
Post reply on HN