Live data from Hacker News

Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

bbc.com

71–80 of 139 posts

Re: Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

#71

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Frankly - this is where I am. The system falls apart if it can't enforce its own rules, and if we don't see some serious perjury charges here, I think it's a very bad sign. The message will no longer be: It's unacceptable to cheat and lie to win. It will be: Cheat and lie better. -- edit: I'd like to see at least two felony perjury charges against Jones. Ideally with max sentences.

I always wonder what truly unlimited free speech would mean. How is it possible that perjury would be a crime? Fraud - just free speech right? And if money is speech, then corruption is just free speech as well. It doesn't really feel like it breaks the system down, it's more like does/did the system even exist?

Free speech exists for a reason - to allow a society to introspect and for truth to be explored and expressed. When one monetizes lies and conspiracy theories, manufacturing false narratives as truth, speech ceases to offer a positive value to society and its freedom should be less protected.

The justice system is designed to find out the truth about disputed events or actions. Deliberately lying to it is a direct attack on its mission and should be considered a criminal offence.

Re: Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

#72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am astounded how someone can sit on the stand and spew lie after lie after lie under oath with no repercussions.

yeah, I guess lying under oath is no big deal? I always thought it mattered. I was deposed to give testimony once in a dispute between two other parties and it was nerve wracking to give testimony about a few questions because it was stuff I hadn't thought about in a couple of year. Turns out it's no big deal to lie under oath? This is really troubling, how can we have the rule of law if lying under oath is allowed f…

It's only a big deal if you're poor, though. It says so in the Constitution... /s

Re: Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

#73

I hope they throw the book at him for punitive damages as well. Maybe then people will learn you don't get to sit there spouting blatant lies without consequence. I thought forwarding his messages to the jan6 committee was just a stunt but apparently there's some juicy stuff in there. Will be interesting to see what comes out of it.

> Maybe then people will learn you don't get to sit there spouting blatant lies without consequence. That is partly true. The ruling class gets to lie with impunity whenever they want, for profit or power. Remember WMDs in Iraq? And Iran has been "6 months away from a nuclear bomb" for the past 50 years.

> The ruling class

Who, exactly, are you referring to with nonspecific language like that?

Re: Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

#74
post #4

So all the memes aside, is anyone else astounded at how poorly that went for Alex Jones? Just a shit-show nearly the entire time. From his terrible legal representation, to his own terrible testimony. Just a mess. I mean, his 'on-air' personality is a mess, but I always sort of thought it was just a show. It's interesting to me that it turned out he really is just an absolute train-wreck of a person.

No post body was provided.

Re: Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

#75
post #4

So all the memes aside, is anyone else astounded at how poorly that went for Alex Jones? Just a shit-show nearly the entire time. From his terrible legal representation, to his own terrible testimony. Just a mess. I mean, his 'on-air' personality is a mess, but I always sort of thought it was just a show. It's interesting to me that it turned out he really is just an absolute train-wreck of a person.

Having followed the case, him being absolutely demolished in court repeatedly is no shock given his brazen contempt for the court system and his refusal to abide by any sort of law or rules. I’m most shocked at his own sheer self-destructiveness. What is he going to do now? Claim the courts conspired against him?

Why are you shocked? So far, up until this point, he's been able to escalate his behavior with absolutely no lasting consequence.

He probably honestly thought he could bluster his way through this. He probably still thinks he can scream his way out of it.

It's literally Jerry's move in Rick and Morty, "I just kept crawling and it kept working"

Re: Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

#76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am astounded how someone can sit on the stand and spew lie after lie after lie under oath with no repercussions.

A person isn't lying if they think they are telling the truth.

While that's broadly true, it's clearly not the case here.

Re: Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

#77

Earlier quoted context omitted.

yeah, I guess lying under oath is no big deal? I always thought it mattered. I was deposed to give testimony once in a dispute between two other parties and it was nerve wracking to give testimony about a few questions because it was stuff I hadn't thought about in a couple of year. Turns out it's no big deal to lie under oath? This is really troubling, how can we have the rule of law if lying under oath is allowed f…

I'm not a lawyer, but I suspect that judges sorta know that people who are being sued or prosecuted are not exactly going to be reliable witnesses if they testify, and that it'd probably be a bigger deal if this were one of Jones' associates who wasn't on the hook for the money. There's also plenty of time for the judge to dial up some perjury referrals.

I could be wrong but my understanding is that technically lawyers are liable if they put someone on the stand they know is going to lie. I’m surprised that isn’t enforced more often.

Re: Alex Jones must pay $4M in damages for Sandy Hook hoax claims

#79
post #4

So all the memes aside, is anyone else astounded at how poorly that went for Alex Jones? Just a shit-show nearly the entire time. From his terrible legal representation, to his own terrible testimony. Just a mess. I mean, his 'on-air' personality is a mess, but I always sort of thought it was just a show. It's interesting to me that it turned out he really is just an absolute train-wreck of a person.

No person is a asshat only 30% of the time. They are an asshat who can occasionally hide it.

You take an asshat and put him under extreme stress, and the true personality comes out.

I can only imagine how working with him was. He may have gone through a bunch of lawyers, and the ones who stuck with it... who knows. I wouldn't be surprised if these people were so done with him, and done with yelling at grieving parents, that they intentionally leaked info. At some point you stop caring about whatever scraps the person is paying you.

I don't feel bad at all.

Post reply on HN