Live data from Hacker News

Gitlab and remote work

about.gitlab.com

211–214 of 214 posts

Re: Gitlab and remote work

#211
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because physical goods are subject to differently priced logistics and local ingridients and remote work is not? Seriously, how can you even compare?

The price of Coke is influenced by logistics but ultimately it's determined by the market (supply and demand), exactly the same as your work, that's capitalism. What's the market in this context is of course the interesting question.

The market for Coca-Cola is very different from that of software programming labour: Soda pop can only be consumed where it is actually located, so is affected by, as you pointed out, logistics and (local!) supply and demand.

Remote programming work, on the other hand, is the opposite: At least the demand side is, as this whole discussion exemplifies, global -- Gitlab isn't local to all the locations where their remote employees live. (If it were, they wouldn't be remote.)

But then the employees' supply of labour isn't local either: They're offering their labour to Gitlab, a non-local employer (and potentially to other non-local employers too).

It's utterly baffling how much of this discussion seems to be assuming that Gitlab (or other remote employers) play on a global market, but their employees on a local one. If that were the case, how could any of those employees ever be employed by any of these employers? The very fact that any transactions -- i.e. employment contracts -- ever arise shows that both parties are playing on the same market.

Re: Gitlab and remote work

#212

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You pay according to location for the same bottle of Coke? How is work pay different? Why shouldn't payment for work be tied to local price ranges and cost of living?

The cost of most commodities varies by location. This includes Coke. It is called price discrimination. The whole reason DVDs had regions was to price the same DVD differently based on location. As long as companies can, they will price and pay different amounts for the same thing based on local factors.

But price discrimination by region doesn't fit great with boasting about "leadership". Say what you want about the MPAA (and RIAA), but who would buy them crowing about anything like "leading the free global market for media"? Leading the world in exploiting the free market, sure.

So, you were saying that's the kind of "leadership" Gitlab is boasting about, or...?

Re: Gitlab and remote work

#213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Locally-adjusted pay is a fluke if revenues are not locally constrained You don't get paid based on company revenue, you get paid based on the lowest amount you (or someone you're competing with) are willing to agree to sell your labour for. That amount is going to be lower if your cost of living is lower. People earning less if they work remotely in Podunk, Idaho compared to SF is no different from someone earning…

Absolutely true in labor markets where supply exceeds demand, but tech is not currently one of them.

It absolutely is, when speaking on a global/remote scale.

Re: Gitlab and remote work

#214

Earlier quoted context omitted.

GitLab team member here. Thanks for flagging. I contacted the owner of the dashboard and asked if they can get it working. Will report back if/when it is repaired.

Nine days later. Still down?

Some but not all parts of the dashboard are working.
Post reply on HN