Live data from Hacker News

52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

datahorde.org

41–50 of 60 posts

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've clicked that. There's a circle, with circles around, with something around one of these smaller circles. All of it is spinning. I've managed to click the spinny thingy and it turned into quadratic spinny thingy. That's all. What the fuck? Please explain!

It's revolutionary tech, web 5.0 at least, not everyone understands.

The web of the future needs to be beyond numbers entirely.

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#42
post #20

YouTube is deleting pre-2010 videos, meanwhile anything is still possible at https://www.zombo.com

I've clicked that. There's a circle, with circles around, with something around one of these smaller circles. All of it is spinning. I've managed to click the spinny thingy and it turned into quadratic spinny thingy. That's all. What the fuck? Please explain!

That's it. It's Zombo com. The difference is it's been reliably the same since 1999.

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You have to, however, also consider the multi-domainness of YouTube videos. Yeah sure, there's billions of hours of clips not one person can watch in a single life-time. But unlike your 2000-year old Roman shopping lists, we have footage of events that are anchored to a particular time-period. Or location. One of the most impressive things you can do is, try searching up a landmark. My personal favorite is the [Jumpi…

Like so many questions of this type, I think the Internet Archive is the answer. They are not a warehouse of stuff stored on media/formats that are forever becoming obsolete -- they store data, keyed by timestamp, sometimes with metadata. How they store it and serve it up is irrelevant, and they will upgrade as needed (I assume this is a continuous process). If the IA didn't exist, we'd have to invent it. I suspect i…

I don't think that's a complete answer though. The article lists ContentID as the major reason videos get deleted, meaning that copyright trolls could go after IA if they want to. What we desperately need is copyright law reform.

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#44

It's probably time to start saving the videos you like if you haven't already. I still remember when Key and Peele's whole catalog (or a lot of it) was available on youtube back in 2015-2016. For a brief window of time. Some of my favourite songs with 10s of millions of views have been taken down. Many niche videos don't get reuploaded. No guarentees that youtube will keep your unique or exclusive videos publicly ava…

And as the platform ages creators will start to pass away, what then?

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've clicked that. There's a circle, with circles around, with something around one of these smaller circles. All of it is spinning. I've managed to click the spinny thingy and it turned into quadratic spinny thingy. That's all. What the fuck? Please explain!

That's it. It's Zombo com. The difference is it's been reliably the same since 1999.

Zombo is supposed to parody. You know things are rough when it's better than some popular websites!

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've clicked that. There's a circle, with circles around, with something around one of these smaller circles. All of it is spinning. I've managed to click the spinny thingy and it turned into quadratic spinny thingy. That's all. What the fuck? Please explain!

Exactly. (You're not missing anything.)

Thanks!

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#47
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've clicked that. There's a circle, with circles around, with something around one of these smaller circles. All of it is spinning. I've managed to click the spinny thingy and it turned into quadratic spinny thingy. That's all. What the fuck? Please explain!

How old are you? It's possible that you may be outside of the generation that would've appreciated it during it's peak.

I'm over 40. Never heard of it. It happens, I'm not really following anything or keeping up with internet "culture". Haven't for decades.

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've clicked that. There's a circle, with circles around, with something around one of these smaller circles. All of it is spinning. I've managed to click the spinny thingy and it turned into quadratic spinny thingy. That's all. What the fuck? Please explain!

That's it. It's Zombo com. The difference is it's been reliably the same since 1999.

Was better as an auto looping gif with auto playing music. This is zombocom 2.0

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Like so many questions of this type, I think the Internet Archive is the answer. They are not a warehouse of stuff stored on media/formats that are forever becoming obsolete -- they store data, keyed by timestamp, sometimes with metadata. How they store it and serve it up is irrelevant, and they will upgrade as needed (I assume this is a continuous process). If the IA didn't exist, we'd have to invent it. I suspect i…

I don't think that's a complete answer though. The article lists ContentID as the major reason videos get deleted, meaning that copyright trolls could go after IA if they want to. What we desperately need is copyright law reform.

I'm not 100% positive, but I recall a conversation we had on TheEye a while back with some IA reps and they simply can't archive YouTube. I recall a private project to archive just the video Metadata ended up in the hundreds of Terabytes. The videos themselves must be a gargantuan collection. Most YouTube archiving thus far is pretty much done and maintained by private individuals.

Re: 52% of YouTube videos live in 2010 have been deleted

#50
I am a former technical YouTube explainer, active 2007-2010. Two videos had 1m+ views, and dozens of other low-production / highly-technical DIY guides.

Google implemented several changes to their ad / revenue - sharing products, so I decided to remove my digital contributions from YouTube (flatteringly, another YTer re-posted my most-popular video). A few years later, they lost custody of my DIY Technical Manual Website URL (some ICANN snafu), so I left their platform entirely.

The entirety of Google's properties now reside on my DNS blacklists.

Post reply on HN