Live data from Hacker News

Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

shotcut.org

71–80 of 99 posts

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#71
post #57
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We use kdenlive at work with the same results. Sometimes crashes but Auto save saves the day

This! Simply presume kdenlive will frequently crash. I found it very disconcerting at first, but I learned to treat kdenlive's frequent crashing as a mildly annoying glitch (peccadillo).

I use kdenlive for quite a bit. Crashing can be a problem when using the system repo version, but when using the flatpak it's very stable. If you haven't tried that, I would recommend it.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#72
post #58

This is very cool! I've been looking for some time for a project that has: - a stellar editing UI for "prototyping" a well-edited video - a well-documented timeline-level API for the file format that can replace, timeshift, and add clips and tracks, and - be able to run on cloud hardware as a render service Imagine creating a promotional video, then automatically swapping in each client's logo and re-rendering it for…

Also give https://kdenlive.org/ a try. I settled on it as a high-power, steep learning curve solution when I found myself hitting the wall with alternatives. It's clunky but it does everything I need.

Like Shotcut, it's all MLT underneath the hood. You can click "Generate script" on the render dialog, and get a .mlt file.

Another lead for you: https://github.com/AcademySoftwareFoundation/OpenTimelineIO

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#73

Shotcut has this one cool feature [1] - drop a bunch of pictures into it and it'll create an animated slide show automatically. I've looked for ways to automate that via something like ffmpeg, but haven't found any better options. [1] https://forum.shotcut.org/t/slideshow-generator/19162

Nice! I think iMovie does this, but I usually use https://www.photofilmstrip.org/en

Apple Photos does it as well.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#74
post #48
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I used it for awhile, but there are a lot of short comings. It's very unintuitive and I would often spend more time trying to figure out how to do a thing than doing a thing. I switched to DaVinci Resolve (also free), and never looked back. I eventually spent the one time payment of around $300 for access to GPU accelerated encoding and a few additional filters and stuff.

Resolve is free as beer, but Shotcut is free as speech. Know the difference.

Yes I'm aware :). Notice I didn't say, "DaVinci (also free OSS)". I wasn't trying to mislead anyone, but I feel like OSS can sometimes be overhyped just because it's Open Source. Not all closed source software is bad (pretty much every major game is closed source), and not all OSS is good.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#75

Here's a bit of feedback, in the event anyone who manages the site reads this comment section: 1) I checked the FAQ and the 2nd and 3rd question in the FAQ were about crashing on Windows. I get the impression that this software is extremely unstable across OSes. This is a really bad foot to start off on. Can anyone speak to the stability of Shotcut? I see a few comments below mentioning crashes, I just can't tell if…

So apparently in Shotcut you can make a transition between clips on the same track by just sliding them into each other. in Kdenlive you have to have them on different tracks and add transitions between them. Not something that makes or breaks the editor, just something that caught my eye watching the tutorial videos. It's great for really simple home video editing.

Thanks for the info. I'm not sure how compelling that would be for my specific use case, but I'm sure some people would find that useful. Thanks! :)

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#76
post #14

Anyone use this? Opinions?

For me, Shotcut, Openshot, Flowblade, Olive and Pitivi have been crashing to often to be worth using. Openshot used to be less flaky when I used it a few years ago when it was in GTK but the Qt version has not been stable to me. Kdenlive is amazing though, especially the timegraphs for applying effects, and the clip proxying which makes it amazingly smooth for large projects on old laptops. I don't think any of the o…

I used flowblade 2.6.0 for my teaching throughout the pandemic. It's a wonderful tool and I never experienced any crashes. Earlier I tried Shotcut, Openshot and others. They were slow to work with (laggy ui), slow to render and sometimes crashed.

My experiences were on Linux btw (Ubuntu 20.04) using well supported hardware.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#78

Tried to use Shotcut years ago to edit a documentary and it crashed constantly. Neat idea, bad execution. Maybe it’s gotten better since then but it was unusable for serious work ca 2015.

It's not the most stable app I've used, but on Linux I rarely crash these days - much better than where it was 2 - 3 years ago.

The Windows version is quite volatile the last time I tried it however.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#80
post #22

Shotcut has this one cool feature [1] - drop a bunch of pictures into it and it'll create an animated slide show automatically. I've looked for ways to automate that via something like ffmpeg, but haven't found any better options. [1] https://forum.shotcut.org/t/slideshow-generator/19162

So basically this[0] with a crossfade[1] between frames? Which would be (by stitching examples together) ffmpeg -framerate 1/5 -pattern_type glob -i '\*.jpg' -pix_fmt yuv420p -filter_complex xfade=transition=fade:duration=2:offset=2 out.mp4 (1 jpg image per 5 seconds with a 2 seconds crossfade in between) [0] https://trac.ffmpeg.org/wiki/Slideshow [1] https://ffmpeg.org/ffmpeg-filters.html#xfade (only available in >4…

I was just about to write that exact same command from my flawless recollection of stitching examples together from that wiki! But you beat me to it.

Honestly, I'd love a podcast called "Quinecast" where each episode consists of hosts talking in detail about the ffmpeg flags that were used to create the podcast.

Post reply on HN