Live data from Hacker News

Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

shotcut.org

41–50 of 99 posts

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#41

Anyone use this? Opinions?

I use it every few days to create game videos to share with friends. I like that it's super easy to extract and combine segments from multiple videos and easy to add a second audio track (like from a microphone). It's never crashed on me and it feels relatively polished compared to the other free applications I've used (the names of which escape me).

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#42

Tried to use Shotcut years ago to edit a documentary and it crashed constantly. Neat idea, bad execution. Maybe it’s gotten better since then but it was unusable for serious work ca 2015.

My take: It worked excellent for unserious work a couple of weeks ago.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#43
post #33

This looks identical to Kdenlive, how is this different from kdenlive? https://docs.kdenlive.org/en/user_interface.html#user-interf...

In terms of history, looks like Shotcut had Windows support a few year before Kdenlive, for one. Also the main developer of Shotcut was one of the co-creators of MLT, which is the multimedia framework behind both Shotcut and Kdenlive.

As for features I haven't used Kdenlive enough to compare, since Shotcut works fine for me (never had any crashes, though this was using the Windows version so ymmv)

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#45

Anyone use this? Opinions?

I've only used it for splicing together bike cam videos and then cutting them to 2 minutes before and after the incident for submitting to police (that's quite common for police forces in the UK when dealing with close-pass etc footage). It was easy enough to figure out how to use it and I've got about zero knowledge of video editing. To be honest, I should really change to using ffmpeg instead as OpenShot can be a b…

You want "ffmpeg -ss -t -i .mp4 -c copy output.mp4" or something along those lines.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ffmpeg has an entire page in their wiki devoted to slideshows: https://trac.ffmpeg.org/wiki/Slideshow

There is so much value in doing this in a normal application with a UI that lets you see what you're doing. ffmpeg is a fantastic utility if you already know what you need, but it's absolutely terrible for jobs where you need to be able to see and do things between the two states of "having input" and "having final output".

I agree, although it has to be noted that that you can preview most ffmpeg commands using ffplay. The syntax is the same as the ffmpeg command, without the final output filename obviously.

Re: Shotcut is a free, open-source, cross-platform video editor

#48
post #25

Anyone use this? Opinions?

I used it for awhile, but there are a lot of short comings. It's very unintuitive and I would often spend more time trying to figure out how to do a thing than doing a thing. I switched to DaVinci Resolve (also free), and never looked back. I eventually spent the one time payment of around $300 for access to GPU accelerated encoding and a few additional filters and stuff.

Resolve is free as beer, but Shotcut is free as speech. Know the difference.
Post reply on HN