Live data from Hacker News

FBI Didn't Knock Down a Suspect's Door Because 'It Was an Affluent Neighborhood'

reason.com

391–393 of 393 posts

Re: FBI Didn't Knock Down a Suspect's Door Because 'It Was an Affluent Neighborhood'

#391

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In the gun community the NRA is generally seen has having failed gun owners. NRA accomplished some wicked and absurd goals (one might not think it possible if it hadn't already happened) and I think by proxy accomplished a huge one through Justice Scalia which significantly, drastically and fundamentally changed the meaning of the 2nd Amendment from a selfless right to stand guard against tyranny to an intensely an…

> NRA accomplished some wicked and absurd goals Perhaps by the standards of those outside the gun community. For our agenda they've been a failure. The modest policy successes, by our measure, have been obtained in-spite of them. I don't expect you to agree with our agenda, but don't forget that we define our agenda. All the NRA did was water it down.

> we define our agenda. All the NRA did was water it down.

NRA's agenda is guns for everyone, and to change the Founders' intent to make the 2nd include a right self-defense that it neither ever contained nor needs to contain. That's watered down, you say. If that's watered down, wtf.

It has been proven over and over, just about every week, that more guns means more gun deaths, and that is all it means, iow, it does not mean anyone is safer. In fact, owning a gun doubles the chance of death of anyone living in the gun owners' household. Also, it is more likely a gun owner will injure or kill themselves, or someone they love, than they will ever successfully defend themselves against crime. Also, no one needs the 2nd Amendment for self-defense. We all already have the right of self-defense, so it would be awesome if we didn't let pet agendas unnecessarily monkey with the Constitution.

The Founders never intended the citizenry to be armed, unless organized as a well-regulated militia. It's fine to have your own agenda and opinions about guns, certainly, but let's not ever try to wrap that in patriotism, nor label it American, because the Founders had far far different ideas about this than the gun community. And if guns for everyone and warping the 2nd to include self-defense doesn't please the gun community, then no one need ever find out what will. Secure your weapon, and just sit there and be dissatisfied, and try not to hurt yourself or kill anything.

Re: FBI Didn't Knock Down a Suspect's Door Because 'It Was an Affluent Neighborhood'

#392
post #379

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In the gun community the NRA is generally seen has having failed gun owners. NRA accomplished some wicked and absurd goals (one might not think it possible if it hadn't already happened) and I think by proxy accomplished a huge one through Justice Scalia which significantly, drastically and fundamentally changed the meaning of the 2nd Amendment from a selfless right to stand guard against tyranny to an intensely an…

" This was illegal, unconstitutional, and a massive overreach by Scalia, because obviously he undermined the Founders' expressed requirement for a Constitutional convention and 2/3rds both houses of Congress or of State legislatures to change the Constitution." You are obviously not a lawyer. "That this defacement of the Constitution occurred in the way that it did, the 2nd was vandalized without altering the literal…

> You are obviously not a lawyer.

Flattery will get you nowhere. If you're going to disagree, then please just do so and defend your position rather than... I don't know what this is... empty heckles from the peanut gallery I guess. FWIW, since the Heller decision was unconstitutional, and McDonald was based on Heller, then it also is invalid and unconstitutional. The 2nd Amendment does not guarantee the right of the people to keep and bear arms, and never did, not unless you ignore the first three words of the Amendment, placed there at the beginning almost as if to underscore their importance in clearly laying out the scope of the Amendment, "A well-regulated militia."

Re: FBI Didn't Knock Down a Suspect's Door Because 'It Was an Affluent Neighborhood'

#393

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>> You have lots of people who preach permissiveness and self fulfillment in public and practice rigid conformity in their own lives. Growing up I reconciled this as the way my parents did: “things it’s okay for Americans to do versus but not for us to do.” I find that suboptimal now. Are you the product of an immigrant family? Because it sounds quite like something many immigrant parents would say.

> Are you the product of an immigrant family? Because it sounds quite like something many immigrant parents would say. Not only that, I'm one of those immigrant kids who thinks my parents were wise and correct, instead of rebelling.

Did you always think your parents were right? Were there moments in life you thought they should be questioned if not ignored?
Post reply on HN