Live data from Hacker News

Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

theunderstatement.com

21–30 of 88 posts

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#21
post #7

The author is wrong..there is a Google+ sandbox and I am told that Google management is in fact using Google+ through that from Google insiders..

That's never the same thing though (even assuming this rumor stands up). You can dogfood products like Wave internally all you like; the lesson that Google has actually learned here, for the most part, is you also need to spend time field testing in the real world.

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#23

Remember that Larry re-org'd Google into product groups, and the SVP of Social is Vic Gundorota. My understanding is that these groups are supposed to work in a more autonomous fashion, with Larry more of a Jobsian gatekeeper and guiding hand. If you are to make some sort of conclusion based on whether the boss is using it or not, you need to actually choose the boss. Vic is the boss of Google+, and he's made 150+ po…

I think the point is that even senior googlers don't think its valuable/useful enough.

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#24
post #8

> Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg really does use Facebook all day. Twitter CEO Dick Costolo tweeted at least 30 times just yesterday. And, likewise, I'm sure Google's management uses Google Search on a regular basis.

But not Google+... and thats exactly the point.

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#25
This article is flawed. It is making an assumption that public posts correlates with private posts.

"Further, I think it’s reasonable to assume a correlation between private use & public use: if you were constantly posting things on a service and each time you were given the option to make it public or private, surely sometimes you’d make it public, especially as a somewhat public figure wanting to help your own company’s new service get going."

This is fallacy, and it is not even persuasive fallacy.

I make significantly more private posts than I do public posts. I've made exactly two public posts since using it in the early field testing days, and have many more private posts. The friends in my circle tends to share privately, not publicly. You don't have to make public posts to use Google+.

We can say for certain that Google management do not make public posts. We cannot say for certain that Google management do not use Google+ at all.

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#26
This is an opportunity for the Google leadership to be leaders not only in their company but outside of it by contributing their knowledge and lessons learned to the public. Unfortunately, they are not taking this leadership opportunity, since most of the posts from Larry Page and Sergey Brin are from their amazing adventures and travels, which shows that they themselves don't understand the real power of social media and how they can use it to actually contribute to the world.

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#27
post #10

I'm not sure this is fair. Google is a large company with a lot of products. You simply can't expect top management to be an active user of all of them. I'm sure Apple doesn't require its top execs to own an iPhone, iPod, iPod nano, iPod touch, iMac, MacBook Air.... you get the idea. The comparison with Twitter is even worse. Twitter really only has one product. The way this data is organized, I don't see any top exe…

However, the author of the article mentioned that Google is saying Google+ is THE future of the company. In that case, everyone should be using it. It's not "just another" product.

However, the author of the article mentioned that Google is saying Google+ is THE future of the company.

Just because the author mentioned that doesn't make it true.

http://www.oregonlive.com/business/index.ssf/2011/06/googles...

The author cites this article, which (ignoring the fact that it is an interview with Google ex-CEO) doesn't even mention Google Plus by name. Personally, I'd say that the author's post demonstrates that Google doesn't think Google Plus is central to the company's future.

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#28
post #9

This thought: Further, I think it’s reasonable to assume a correlation between private use & public use kills the whole article. No, it isn't a reasonable assumption. If you look at my Facebook without being a friend of mine, you get a picture of me. Five years of use and that is the only public thing I have published. And I am just another dude no one cares about. I am sure billionaire CEOs and board members who hav…

In fact, this was one of the main use-cases G+ hammered on when it launched. That said, I believe G+ has public-facing benefit. It would be nice to see honchos above Vic Gundotra using it publicly.

Marissa Mayer actively uses G+, publicly.

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#29
post #24
post #8

> Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg really does use Facebook all day. Twitter CEO Dick Costolo tweeted at least 30 times just yesterday. And, likewise, I'm sure Google's management uses Google Search on a regular basis.

But not Google+... and thats exactly the point.

A point which is based on a flawed assumption. Public posts don't necessarily correlate with private posts.

Re: Google’s Management Doesn’t Use Google+

#30
Google+ was supposed to compete with Facebook and having people's salaries tied to something this big, you would expect EVERYBODY to be on board.

I'd be pretty pissed if my salary was tied up in this and articles like this come out basically saying, "Your own execs don't think this is a good enough product to use themselves."

Regardless of how private they want to be, they should be using the product or at the very least have some assistant or intern posting for them. I'm pretty certain most celebs and top tech execs don't do all of their updates. You don't have to post private stuff, just make an effort to show you're using the product.

Post reply on HN