Live data from Hacker News

The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

axios.com

41–50 of 784 posts

Re: The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

#41

Twitter is a cesspool and it seems like the people who are disproportionately influential are all on Twitter. I think it’s a bubble that should not have any political power, because it’s a cesspool!

American political discourse involving the uneducated is a cesspool. Social commentary often leads to political discourse which makes that type of speech sadly often one step away from a cesspool. Twitter is simply facilitating it.

Stop following people who post political things or opinions about social issues and the toxicity is much, much less.

Re: The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

#42

I don't engage on Twitter out of fear. I sometimes see posts that I like and want to retweet but I don't because it means I'm endorsing everything the author has ever said or ever will say. It's not worth the risk. People in my demographic face significant exposure to "cancelling" or ambushing for wrongthink. So it's best for me to avoid it entirely.

I don't think this is a healthy way to live. There was another conversation thread started about an hour ago that dives into this really well:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30602611

I would reiterate my comment on that thread, verbatim:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30603008

Re: The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

#43
post #22

The most active social media users are usually people lacking in real life. Think about it, if you have a great job, a great partner and a great life, are you on Twitter arguing 20 to 30 hours a week. The type of person to argue with strangers all day has none of the above. It's also a matter of recognizing how insignificant we all are. No one cares what I think. Hopefully no one ever will. I do want to create games…

This feels oddly specific. I'm not sure why you can't engage on Twitter and still not be "lacking in real life." Who even gets to define "real life?" And while I'm sure some people spend 20-30 hours per week on Twitter I'm guessing it's such a small percentage of the world that it might as well be statistically insignificant.

> I'm guessing it's such a small percentage of the world that it might as well be statistically insignificant.

Exactly! The vast majority of content on social media is produced by a vanishingly small slice of the world's population. The views expressed should not be understood as representative.

Re: The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

#44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>People in my demographic face significant exposure to "cancelling" or ambushing for wrongthink. I don't use Twitter or pretty much say anything publicly for the same reason, but note that this is definitely a risk for people of all demographics.

It is far more risk for some than others. If you have a minority viewpoint, you get attacked far more easily.

[deleted]

Re: The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

#45

Can someone explain why they would ever put something on Twitter that is not marketing related? (I get it for business, but why for personal use?)

This question needs to be asked more often. It took me quite a while to realize why I'm more engaged on Twitter than I used to be.

In my case, it's to have a conversation. Before I moved to the United States, I could have all sorts of conversations with people at work, no matter how controversial or stupid or weird. But in the US, the culture is different. There are things that you can't discuss with your coworkers, for various reasons.

When the pandemic hit and I stopped going to the office, that made the problem even worse. Sure, I didn't have any real friends here, but at least there was more randomness and diversity in my social life. I love my family, but it's an extremely limited pool of people to talk to.

So I found myself participating more and more on Twitter, on Imgur, and on certain game forums. Which, in turn, had the same impact on me as Facebook used to before I closed my account.

My own, very personal conclusion, is that the society in the United States suffers from a "disease" of alienating people from each other and isolating them, making them turn to social networks to fill the void left by the absence of what used to be normal, every day way to socialize.

Then again, I'm just a sample of one, so my conclusion is almost certain to be wrong.

Re: The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

#46
post #34

I don't engage on Twitter out of fear. I sometimes see posts that I like and want to retweet but I don't because it means I'm endorsing everything the author has ever said or ever will say. It's not worth the risk. People in my demographic face significant exposure to "cancelling" or ambushing for wrongthink. So it's best for me to avoid it entirely.

It's really easy to not be "canceled", just be a good person. What genuinely OK opinion are people being canceled for?

People change. Your "edgy" tweets and shitty jokes from when you were young and stupid can still haunt you in your adult life.

Case in point: James Gunn ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Gunn#Firing_from_Disney_... )

This is why I rarely interact on Twitter and I have a script that deletes all my tweets that are over X days old. If I say something truely insightful, I'll just make a blog post out of it.

Re: The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

#48
I wish someone would go around interviewing reporters like this writer and ask "How long did it take for you to realize that Twitter is not real life? Why do you think you were mislead for so long? How do you plan to avoid similar errors in judgement in the future?"

Except the social status journos have make this like of inquiry uncouth. It is someone both one of the most pressing issues of our media landscape, yet seen as a simple-minded and undignified perspective that sophisticated media won't touch.

Re: The new silent majority: People who don't tweet

#50
post #27

"Never pass up a chance to keep your mouth shut" Words my Dad taught me as I was growing up, but only really sank in the last 5 or so years ago.

Similar quote by Mark Twain > It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt.

Takes one to know one.
Post reply on HN