Live data from Hacker News

Degoogled phones running privacy oriented OS

de-googled.com

31–40 of 80 posts

Re: Degoogled phones running privacy oriented OS

#31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In that case a fairphone might meet your requiements while still being open to installing alternative OS'es.

Is fairphone available in the US yet?

Doesn't look like it, only continental europe & uk. The bands it supports are in use by Sprint and T-mobile though, so if you import it it will probably work on those carriers.

Re: Degoogled phones running privacy oriented OS

#33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I think it's best practice for anyone wanting a de-googeled device to just buy one of these phones in store with cash and then load the custom OS themselves The best practice is to abandon locked down Android phones and switch to GNU/Linux phones (Librem 5 and Pinephone).

Linux phones are entirely impractical for most people. I live in India, and there are several apps I need to use to access government services that only work on iOS and Android. Some services aren't even available over the Web. We're at a point where any successful mobile OS will at least need to support running Android apps, preferably directly from the Play Store. I suspect this is one of the reasons Microsoft is a…

Waydroid allows Linux devices to run Android apps when needed, which also can help bridge the gap in usability until mobile Linux distros are competitive with Android.

Re: Degoogled phones running privacy oriented OS

#34
post #23

There is also eFoundation: https://e.foundation/

i was wondering why de-googled.com does not offer e.foundation as well, but then they sell phones as well, and i guess there is no need to compete on the same product. very happy with /e/OS for more than two years now.

Ditto. Have a fairphone3 with /e/ (bought directly from them) for 2 years also. It has it's quirks and compromises, though most of those are 'features' of not having google. Overall I am happy with it but it takes a bit of work to get most of the features back of a googled phone. Signal backups, shared notes, banking apps, etc. Most banking apps work, though some only with micro-g. I would like to test some other degoogled options to compare/contrast but I would recommend /e/ (which is very close to lineage+microg) to at least technically capable people, not yet ready as a birthday gift for granny though.

Re: Degoogled phones running privacy oriented OS

#35
If this is your jam, it might be worth to contribute to: https://github.com/hiveminds/productivity-phone it is an opinionated, low-quality repo that automatically swaps the operating system of the Fairphone 2 to de-googled LineageOS (and back again if you want to).

It is tested using sample-size=1, does not yet have good documentation and I'm in the process (low priority) of setting up meaningful testing and CI. However, I think the code, once cleaned up, is relatively portable to other devices (that support LineageOS). Disclaimer, I'm involved in the development of that repo.

Re: Degoogled phones running privacy oriented OS

#36
post #2

Typing this on a grapheneos pixel 6 pro. It makes a fine daily driver. Main complaint: Location stamps for google camera photos are a bit intermittent unless I give the sandboxed play services network access. Not sure why it's so hard to ping GPS occasionally in the background, and stick the last known location in the exif data. Still, I would recommend this setup to the HN crowd.

I've been driving Graphene for over a year. Absolutely amazing experience (for a degoogled phone). Kudos to the great team.

No post body was provided.

Re: Degoogled phones running privacy oriented OS

#38
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

i was wondering why de-googled.com does not offer e.foundation as well, but then they sell phones as well, and i guess there is no need to compete on the same product. very happy with /e/OS for more than two years now.

Ditto. Have a fairphone3 with /e/ (bought directly from them) for 2 years also. It has it's quirks and compromises, though most of those are 'features' of not having google. Overall I am happy with it but it takes a bit of work to get most of the features back of a googled phone. Signal backups, shared notes, banking apps, etc. Most banking apps work, though some only with micro-g. I would like to test some other deg…

my mother in europe uses a phone with /e/OS just fine. she doesn't do phone banking though.

i live in a degoogled country ;-) so for me the experience is even smoother than local phones which are filled with spy and ad ware.

Post reply on HN