Live data from Hacker News

Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

apnews.com

61–70 of 103 posts

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#61

Playing armchair general here, but I wonder what's the playbook if Russia decides to conduct a nuclear weapon "experiment".

Same here, armchair general, but I have to wonder what would happen if we parked a carrier strike group off Vladivostok. Russia is enormous and can't defend all its cities.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Launching a missile to explode over the ocean to show resolve to use nukes. Next, launching a missile to explode over some Alaskan waste, if the previous step doesn't induce NATO to start the negotiations. Something like that.

That would trigger an overwhelming response. Nuclear weapons create huge EMP bursts which disrupt communications. One popular type of theoretical first strike is to detonate one or two missiles in the atmosphere to cause confusion, then follow up with the main salvos while peoples' main sensors and communications are blind.

_High-altitude_ explosions create EMP. And nuke yield can be dialed down to Hiroshima levels.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#63
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> ethnic stereotypical Russians are Finno-Ugric people They speak Russian, a Slavic language. The culture is clearly linked and descended from the Old Slavonic people. I'd love to know about the thinking as I'm scratching my head here. This is the first I've heard this claim and I am half Finnish, quarter Russian by ethnicity. My grandparents certainly did not think they were from the same ethnic group.

The first argument is theoretical and controversial. The second point is not.

What part of Russian being a Slavic language is controversial?

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#64
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Launching a missile to explode over the ocean to show resolve to use nukes. Next, launching a missile to explode over some Alaskan waste, if the previous step doesn't induce NATO to start the negotiations. Something like that.

In other words, a madman capable of using Nuclear weapons, will be gentle, sensitive and follow etiquette with his Nuclear actions?

You'd be amazed at how much etiquette there is on nuclear weapons use.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Satellites with high powered lasers are a fantasy that don't exist right now. The converted Boeing 747 airborne laser was a colossal failure and would have only been able to target a missile nearby in its boost/launch phase. It's now dismantled. You think you can send fighters to gun down an icbm MIRV in its re-entry phase? Seriously?

>Satellites with high powered lasers are a fantasy that don't exist right now. You need approximately a 5KW laser to do the job. Virtually all satellites have this much power available. So this 'fantasy' is that you don't believe these sattelites are in orbit? It's quite obvious that this wouldn't be public knowledge. I admit I have no idea. >The converted Boeing 747 airborne laser was a colossal failure and would ha…

>You need approximately a 5KW laser to do the job. Virtually all satellites have this much power available.

"have this much power available" is one part. "having laser system to use that power" is another. If they couldn't get it to work with a laser mounted on top of a 747, what makes you think they can get it to work on a satellite?

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, tomorrow we'll witness the economical suicide. Sberbank - 1$ = 110,49₽ Tinkoff - 1$ = 153,75₽ And the markets are not even opened. For the reference, before Putin started full-scale war against the Ukraine: 1$ = 78.66₽ (23rd Feb)

What do you mean when you say "Sberbank - 1$ = 110,49₽" and "Tinkoff - 1$ = 153,75₽"? Are these different exchange rates for different banks?

He means that the local currency is set to depreciate by half in a span of a week. And the bottom might be far far lower.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, tomorrow we'll witness the economical suicide. Sberbank - 1$ = 110,49₽ Tinkoff - 1$ = 153,75₽ And the markets are not even opened. For the reference, before Putin started full-scale war against the Ukraine: 1$ = 78.66₽ (23rd Feb)

What do you mean when you say "Sberbank - 1$ = 110,49₽" and "Tinkoff - 1$ = 153,75₽"? Are these different exchange rates for different banks?

Yes. You can purchase dollars in exchange of Rubles.

Previous week it was aprox. 80 Rubles per U.S. Dollar.

Now due to the White House's statement that there will be sanctions against the Russia's central bank (they shouldn't able to use the reserves to keep Ruble stable) it is predicted that Ruble will collapse tomorrow.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What do you mean when you say "Sberbank - 1$ = 110,49₽" and "Tinkoff - 1$ = 153,75₽"? Are these different exchange rates for different banks?

Yes. You can purchase dollars in exchange of Rubles. Previous week it was aprox. 80 Rubles per U.S. Dollar. Now due to the White House's statement that there will be sanctions against the Russia's central bank (they shouldn't able to use the reserves to keep Ruble stable) it is predicted that Ruble will collapse tomorrow.

It seems like too large a difference between banks, wouldn't this lead to arbitrage?

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#69
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is an argument that stereotypical ethnic Russians are Finno-Ugric people. Moreover, if you go almost anywhere in Siberia, 50% or more of the locals will be of ethnic minorities native to the area (you may describe their appearance as Asian). More in rural areas. Many regions are dual language, Russian + indigenous. This includes the largest administrative region on Earth that is not a country.

> ethnic stereotypical Russians are Finno-Ugric people They speak Russian, a Slavic language. The culture is clearly linked and descended from the Old Slavonic people. I'd love to know about the thinking as I'm scratching my head here. This is the first I've heard this claim and I am half Finnish, quarter Russian by ethnicity. My grandparents certainly did not think they were from the same ethnic group.

> They speak Russian, a Slavic language

Modern Russian is a little bit older than hundred years.

"Pre-reform" language was significantly different in script, vocabulary and grammar and wasn't older than hundred years itself. Before Napoleonic war 1812 nobility was speaking French, ruling family was German and serfs were speaking Polish, Belarusian, Ukrainian or one of the Turkic dialects.

The only slavic parts remaining in the modern Russian is Cyrillic script and words borrowed from Ukrainian.

Re: Putin puts Russia’s nuclear deterrent forces on alert

#70

Time to ask HN: how do you want to spend the last days of your life?

You might find inspiration in 2012 movie Seeking a Friend for the End of the World. It does not have especially high rating but I liked it. I keep thinking about it today for some reason. Even if the world does not end, finding a friend is always a good thing.

[1] https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1307068/

Post reply on HN